Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff causes free riding but the cp solves it

Reveron 15, PhD, Professor @ Naval War College (Derek, “Examining Department of Defense Security Cooperation,” Committee on Armed Services Hearing, Lexis)

The rationale for security cooperation has been based on the as- sumption that instability breeds chaos, which would make it more likely that the U.S. or the international community would face pressure in the future to intervene. Given America's global foreign policy, many countries have large expectations for assistance from the United States. But the U.S. also derives benefits from security cooperation. Among these are obtaining base access as a quid pro quo; augmenting U.S. force structure by providing logistics and in- telligence support to coalition partners in the Middle East; pro- moting a favorable balance of power by selling weapons systems and training programs to Gulf Cooperation Council countries to balance Iran; harmonizing areas of cooperation by working with Japan and Israel on missile defense; promoting self-defense through the Georgia Train and Equip Program; reinforcing sov- ereignty, like programs such as the Merida Initiative with Mexico; and supporting the U.S. industrial base and creating interoperable air forces through the F—35 program. At times, security cooperation can be limitless, dissatisfying, and futile. Further, risks abound. First, the non-exclusive nature of these activities will produce more failures than successes, which negatively impacts confidence in security cooperation as a tool. Second, the personnel system is not producing sufficient talent to support these missions. American forces no longer operate in isolation and need an appreciation of the historical, cultural, and polit- ical context of where they operate. Third, there is a tendency to over-rely on partners, thinking they can accomplish U.S. objectives when they either lack the political motivation or the skills to do so. Without indigenous political legitimacy, programs can only have a marginal impact on a country's security and stability. Finally, other countries will rely on the U.S. to subsidize their own defense budgets, creating a free rider problem. Given the disappointments in Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan, there is the potential for the value of security cooperation to be ignored. But these programs are not confined to combat zones alone. When thinking about security cooperation, we should look at how international partners contribute to coalition operations, peacekeeping, and global security. U.S. budgetary declines will likely reinforce the importance of security cooperation, as the U.S. will need more partners and allies to augment its own defense capacities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.