Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Increased European populism is challenging the continuity of democratic institutions

Pintsch et. al 6-15-22, Anne Pintsch is an associate professor at the Department of Political Science and Management and the coordinator of the Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence at the University of Agder in Norway; Dennis Hammerschmidt is a data scientist with a PhD in International Relations and Quantitative Methods from the University of Mannheim; Cosima Meyer is a data scientist with a PhD in political science from the University of Mannheim, “Introduction: the declime of democracy and rise of populism in Europe and their effect on democracy promotion,” June 15th 2022, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09557571.2022.2082797

European countries, international organisations (IOs) and civil society organisations have a long history as major democracy promoters around the world (Calingaert et al. 2014; OECD-DAC 2020). Democracy promotion here refers to deliberate ‘activities engaged in by external actors to encourage the development of democracy within a given country’ (Stewart 2009, 647). However, democracy promotion is currently facing several challenges. First, democracy promoters are increasingly experiencing a pushback across the globe. Former recipient governments have passed laws or established practical hurdles that impede external support for democracy and non-governmental organisations (Carothers and Brechenmacher 2014; Dupuy and Prakash 2020). One of the latest examples is the closing of both Russia’s oldest human rights group Memorial and a related Human Rights Centre in December 2021. They were accused, among others, of having broken the foreign agent law by not labelling all their publications with the respective label indicating foreign funding (Osborn and Antonov 2021; Osborn and Kiselyova 2021). Second, the very model of liberal democracy has also lost attractiveness for citizens (Bridoux, Hobson, and Kurki 2012; Poppe, Richter, and Wolff 2018, 2). In democracies even more than in autocracies, people doubt that their voices are heard and governments act in their interest (Rasmussen Global 2018). Finally, democracy promotion ‘is simultaneously undermined by serious problems on the side of key democracy promoters’ (Poppe, Richter, and Wolff 2018, 1). One of those is the decreasing material leverage. As one of the most important democracy promoters worldwide, the European Union (EU) has lost relative economic power (Godfrey and Youngs 2019). Between 2009 and 2020, the EU’s share of world trade in goods and services declined from 18.1 per cent1 to 16.8 per cent, while China’s share increased from 9.6 per cent to 14.7 per cent (European Commission 2021, 21). Another problem runs even deeper and concerns the ‘phenomenon of democratic contestation and erosion “at home”’ (Poppe, Richter, and Wolff 2018 2018, 2). This global phenomenon has been described as a ‘long democratic recession’, which has been ongoing for 15 years (Repucci and Slipowitz 2021, 1). The European continent is no exception. As Smolka’s (2021) analysis of democratic decline in the European Union and decreases in democratic quality shows, both old and new member states are affected by the two phenomena. 20 EU member states2 faced at least one period of democratic decline between 2004 and 2016. While Smolka does not identify a systematic third wave of democratic decline in the EU, she calls the observations ‘gloomy’ (2021, 101). In many cases, this challenge of domestic democratic contestation and erosion is directly – if not exclusively – related to the rise of populism (International IDEA 2020; Kyle and Mounk 2018). Out of 22 countries in which Luhrmann and her co-authors determine a downturn of liberal democracy € between 2008 and 2018, 14 were governed by a populist government or president (Luhrmann et al. € 2019, 906).3 Hungary and Poland – democratic forerunners after the end of the Cold War and later advocates of democracy with a unique transition experience – have become the most prominent examples of this development (Stanley 2017). However, populist parties have achieved significant electoral successes in Western Europe too, and formed part of the government in various countries such as Austria, Greece, Italy and Switzerland (Taggart 2017, 248). As Copelovitch and Pevehouse point out, ‘[t]his rising populism/nationalism has been most prevalent in the very countries that founded and have been at the core of global leadership: the United States and Western Europe’ (2019, 170). At the same time, populism’s relationship with democracy itself continues to be debated. Overall, while populism has been identified as a potential challenge to both democracy and democracy promotion, we do not know much about its actual impact. That is, while we observe a rise in populism in Western democratic states, we know very little about the impact of this rise on states’ and their organisations’ policy-making and the consequences thereof.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.