Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Military spending improves economic growth.

Carter et al. 20, Heather L. Ondercin, Glenn Palmer; Assistant Professor in the Department of Government and Justice Studies at Appalachian State University; Ph.D. and M.A. in political science; Executive Director of Peace Science Society, Liberal Arts Professor of Political Science and Director of Graduate Studies at Penn State; (Jeff, January 6th, 2020; “Guns, Butter, and Growth: The Consequences of Military Spending Reconsidered”; https://doi.org/10.1177%2F1065912919890417; Political Research Quarterly)

Figure 1 presents the quarterly effect of a one-period, one-standard deviation increase in Military Spending on Social Spending (with 95% confidence intervals) over twenty quarters for each of our four scenarios.

The first thing that stands out in Figure 1 is that the relationship between increases in military spending and social spending is conditional on the contemporaneous ordering of the variables in our VAR model. Most importantly, the first quarter following an increase in military spending sees a significant increase in social spending in scenarios 1 and 2 and a significant decrease in social spending in scenarios 3 and 4. This lack of a general, short-term trade-off between military spending and social spending is consistent with most empirical research on the topic. Furthermore, the relationship between military spending and social expenditures in the short run is not random. That is, when military spending increases, we observe a guns-versus-butter trade-off in the two scenarios that mimic leaders willing to reduce social spending (scenarios 3 and 4) and a complementary relationship between military and social spending when the variable orderings reflect leaders who want to protect or expand the social welfare state (scenarios 1 and 2). Our results, therefore, are consistent with research that finds the guns-versus-butter trade-off is conditional on decision-makers’ preferences regarding the social welfare state.

The results in Figure 1 also demonstrate that the marginal effect of military spending on social spending can vary over time. For example, increasing spending on national defense has a negative and significant marginal effect on social spending in quarter 1 and positive and statistically significant marginal effects in quarters 2 and 4 in scenario 3. Less dramatically, increasing military expenditures has a positive and significant marginal effect on social spending in quarter 1 and then negative and insignificant marginal effects in quarters 2–20 in scenario 2. The differences in the direction and magnitude of the marginal effects over time complicate our ability to identify the overall effect of military expenditures on social spending. Figure 2, therefore, plots the cumulative effect of a one-period, one-standard deviation shock to Military Spending on Social Spending (with 95% confidence intervals) over twenty quarters.

Figure 2 illustrates the utility of considering both the marginal and cumulative effects of military spending on social spending. This is perhaps most clear with scenario 4. Here, the cumulative effect of increasing military spending is a statistically significant reduction in social spending in quarters 1–3. However, the direction of this relationship reverses in quarter 4 and is positive and statistically significant between quarters 7 and 16. The cumulative effects of increasing military spending on social spending are informative but less dramatic in the other scenarios. The overall effect of military spending on social expenditures is negative and significant in scenario 3 in quarter 1 and statistically insignificant in the remaining quarters. Scenario 2 suggests a positive and significant relationship between military expenditures and social spending in quarters 1 and 2 and an insignificant relationship in subsequent quarters. Finally, the cumulative effects of increasing military spending on social spending are positive and statistically significant for quarters 1–15 in scenario 1.

Figure 3 reports the FEVD (with 95% confidence intervals) for each of the four scenarios for a one-quarter, one-standard deviation shock to Military Spending. FEVDs identify the importance of changes in military spending for changes in social spending relative to the other variables in the VAR model. The change in military spending has a large influence on social spending in scenario 1, explaining between 49 and 59 percent of the variance in social spending starting in the second quarter after the shock in military spending. The shock to military spending explains between 5 and 10 percent of the variance in social spending during the first four quarters and between 10 and 15 percent of changes in social spending in subsequent quarters in scenario 2. In scenario 3, changes in military spending explain approximately 35 percent of the growth in military spending during the second quarter following the increase and approximately 20 percent of social spending in subsequent quarters. Changes in military spending also have a significant influence on social spending in scenario 4, explaining roughly 30 percent of the growth in social spending in quarters 2–4 and 45–50 percent of social spending in quarters 5–20.

The results presented thus far suggest that the direction and relative magnitude of the effect military spending has on social spending is conditional on variation in leaders’ preferences over how to finance national defense and can change over time. We now present our findings for the relationship between changes in military spending and economic growth.

The Effects of Military Spending on Economic Growth

Figure 4 presents the marginal effect of a one-period, one-standard deviation increase in Military Spending on GDP over twenty quarters in each of our four scenarios.

Two things stand out about Figure 4. First, the IRFs identify the same qualitative relationship between military spending and economic growth in each scenario. Second, changes in military spending have a non-linear effect on economic growth that varies over time. The initial marginal effect of increasing military spending on economic performance is negative and statistically significant in each scenario. However, the marginal effect of military spending on the economy quickly changes signs and becomes positive and statistically significant for multiple quarters in each of the four scenarios (scenario 1: quarters 5–7; scenarios 2 and 3: quarters 4–7; scenario 4: quarters 4–8). Notably, the results in Figure 4 are substantively similar to Oatley’s (2015, 95–97) findings on the short- to medium-term relationship between security shocks, the military build-ups they induce, and economic growth.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.