Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Unconditional security cooperation entangles the US in allied conflicts. Only the counterplan solves.

Priebe et al ’21 [Miranda; Dec 2021; Ph.D. in political science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; M.P.A. in international relations, Princeton University; RAND Corporation “Do Alliances and Partnerships Entangle the United States in Conflict?,” https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA739-3.html]

Advocates of a grand strategy of restraint or offshore balancing, also known as restrainers, call for greater emphasis on diplomacy and less U.S. military engagement abroad. These strategists call for reduced forward military presence, a higher bar for the use of force, and negotiations to settle conflicts of interest with U.S. adversaries diplomatically. They argue that the United States should stop expanding its alliances, renegotiate alliances to reduce entanglement risks, or even end some of its existing alliances and partnerships.

Fear of entanglement is one of the reasons that advocates of restraint say the United States should reexamine its security relationships. This is not to say that all restrainers believe that the United States should end all existing commitments. Rather, many of these strategists argue that the United States should keep its security commitments limited to states that help protect vital U.S. interests and should take steps to mitigate entanglement risks.

For example, some restrainers have called for maintaining the U.S. alliance with Japan to balance against China but have advocated for renegotiating the alliance terms so that Japan does more for its own defense.

Advocates of restraint highlight three ways in which alliances entangle. First, allies and partners might see a U.S. security commitment as evidence that the United States will defend them regardless of how a conflict begins. This belief in an unconditional U.S. commitment could embolden allies and partners to adopt policies that make a conflict more likely because they think they have a “blank check” to bankroll aggressive policies. As one group of restrainers put it, When someone else is going to pay the price for an ill-advised action— that is, when the United States is going to come “fix” any predicament that its allies get into—there is little incentive to avoid trouble. It is easy to gamble with someone else’s money.

Restrainers express the fear that, if a crisis escalates, the United States might feel compelled to defend the reckless ally or partner because it believes that its own credibility is on the line, so failing to act could cause other allies and adversaries to question U.S. commitments elsewhere. This combination of ally emboldenment and U.S. intervention to defend the ally constitutes entrapment.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.