Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Empirics prove entrapment even with narrow commitments

Priebe et al ’21 [Miranda; Dec 2021; Ph.D. in political science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; M.P.A. in international relations, Princeton University; RAND Corporation “Do Alliances and Partnerships Entangle the United States in Conflict?,” https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RRA739-3.html]

Advocates of restraint often present entrapment as a general risk that is associated with U.S. security relationships. They have not made any explicit distinctions between alliances and partnerships as we do here. These strategists have pointed to the potential entrapment risks associated with the U.S. alliances with Japan, the Philippines, and Eastern European and Baltic allies in NATO. Restrainers also see risks in relationships with U.S. partners, such as Taiwan and Georgia. They argue that Taiwan’s leaders would have been more cautious in their rhetoric about independence in the past if Taiwan had not had a long-standing security relationship with the United States. Advocates of restraint also claim that expectations of U.S. support led Georgia to adopt provocative policies toward South Ossetia in 2008, which led to war with Russia. Although the United States was not drawn into this conflict, restrainers argue that the case highlights how U.S. security relationships incentivize risk-taking by allies and partners.

Second, alliances can entangle if the United States sees its credibility— specifically, its reputation for upholding its commitments—as being on the line in a wider variety of issues involving its allies and partners. Even though a U.S. commitment might be narrow, such as defending the ally’s homeland in the event of an attack, the United States might worry that other allies and adversaries see a U.S. response to any issue involving the ally as an indication of U.S. commitment in different contexts. The United States might come to believe that, to protect its credibility, it has to fight wars over peripheral interests involving U.S. allies both to reassure allies and to deter adversaries. Entanglement dynamics do not have to involve the ally or partner that the United States is defending. Rather, entanglement would be at work if the United States were to become involved in conflict to show its reliability to other allies and partners who might be watching. These mechanisms could result in the United States risking or fighting wars that it would not have considered absent the alliance or partnership.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.