Goal entrapment undermines alliance unity
David Edelstein 18 — (David Edelstein; Vice Dean of Faculty in Georgetown College and a professor in the Department of Government, Published: December 2018; "Entrapment Revisited: Strategic and Structural Dynamics"; Accessed: 7-5-2022; https://cpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/u.osu.edu/dist/5/66008/files/2018/12/Entrapment-Revisited-Strategic-and-Structural-Dynamics-1xpycy1.pdf)//Pen-SY
A third type of entrapment is goal entrapment. Here, Ally A may be willing to initiate a confrontation or fight alongside Ally B, but the two states diverge in their preferences for the goals of the contest and/or terms for settling the dispute. In theory, this can occur through two different pathways. First, if Ally A has more modest goals than Ally B, A may become entrapped in the more ambitious goals of its ally once confrontation begins simply by B’s refusal to end a standoff or conflict when A desires. Again, A’s only alternative is to abandon its ally, a risky proposition with a confrontation looming or war at hand. Second, and closely related, one ally may entrap another by expanding the scope of a confrontation. Here, Ally B might seek broader gains or more ambitious terms than A, and so layer on new demands or carry a contest into new venues. This move risks entrapping Ally A, as failure to back B may result in B’s defeat, the loss of crucial resources, and opening up inter-allied political fissures that may dissolve the alliance. As an example of goal entrapment, consider the sequence of decisions that led to the allied Operation Torch landings in northern Africa in 1942. In May 1942, President Franklin D. Roosevelt promised Josef Stalin that the allies would shortly alleviate the pressure that the Germans were putting on the Soviet Union. Great Britain, however, resisted a cross-channel attack, seeing in an assault against the main body of German strength in Western Europe – which would have to be led largely by British forces as the U.S. forces were still mobilizing – an exercise that risked exhausting British strength. British leaders instead preferred an assault on North Africa, a move that would be less costly, divert (at least in theory) German resources away from the Soviet Union, and relieve continued Axis threats to British colonial holdings in the Mediterranean/Middle East. The resulting Anglo-American dispute over military strategy continued throughout the summer of 1942 and, as Mark Stoler showcases, significantly undermined Allied unity. Ultimately, American leaders faced with sustained and immutable British opposition to a 1942 attack on France acceded to British demands. Though many American leaders suspected that Britain’s efforts were motivated less by military factors and more by a political effort to bring American resources to bear to protect British influence in the Mediterranean, no cross-channel assault was to come until 1944.35 What is striking about the decisions leading up to Operation Torch is how the driving considerations were simultaneously the pledge of assistance made to Stalin, and Britain’s successful efforts to channel these pledges into a campaign that widened the European war to include North Africa. Once again, entrapment does not have to entail fighting a war against one’s own interests - it can mean pursuing certain objectives for little reason other than to accommodate a partner. Vincent O’Hara offers a damning critique of Operation Torch, “"Torch was a rushed, half-baked experiment in the art of war, full of untested ideas and amateur touches. The politicians mandated if for political reasons over the objections of most of their military chiefs." O’Hara’s political reasons were precisely Roosevelt’s determination to meet the obligation he felt he had to intervene in a way that would distract Germany from its assault on the Soviet Union.36 The entrapment in this case was in terms of the goal of the war, not the general decision to fight in the first place.37