Norway will escalate-to-deescalate – increasing US cooperation inculcates the cult of offensive.
Heier, 18—professor, Norwegian Defence University College (Tormod, “Avoiding War: How Should Northern Europe Respond to the US-Russian Rivalry?,” Arctic Review on Law and Politics Vol. 9, 2018, pp. 267–286, dml)
Norwegian willing compliance with allied injunctions has contributed to making Norway a “small middle power” in Europe.44 This is because NATO guidance has helped Norway stir a military transformation that has channelled scarce resources from a large mobilisation force into a more agile professional force. Despite a lack of sustainability however, prospects for more permanent US reinforcements – seen since 2014 – have to some extent eased Norwegian apprehensions. This is particularly so as Russian “snap exercises” and cyberattacks towards critical infrastructure have increased over the past few years.45 Burden sharing in Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria, as well as intensified intelligence gathering towards Russia’s Northern Fleet have nevertheless cemented transatlantic ties. This logic has long roots in Norwegian strategic thinking. According to Defence Minister (1986–1989) Johan Jørgen Holst, a potential crisis with Russia should not end up as a war with Norway, but rather as a war about Norway.46 Burden sharing abroad would make it easier to get US attention and support if a Norwegian tripwire needed to be triggered in the High North. This burden sharing takes place in part through military channels in the Norwegian Intelligence Service, as well as in various parts of the Navy, Air Force and Special Forces commands, which on a daily basis operate closely with US forces in the United States, Norway, Belgium, Germany, Jordan, Iraq and the United Arab Emirates. It also occurs through Norway’s extensive diplomatic networks embodied in the Ministry of Defence and Foreign Affairs, which on a daily basis cultivates US ties in Washington D.C., Brussels and London.47 Norway’s fears of abandonment by NATO have been allayed, in accordance with Snyder’s theoretical assumptions.
In addition, these networks can be interpreted as a sort of deterrence towards Russia. A more visible US presence in Norwegian airspace and territorial waters, as well as in the northern counties of Finnmark, Troms and Trøndelag underscores a more credible US deterrent component in Northern Europe. Combined with updated reinforcement and readiness plans, as well as more allied exercises, this enhanced NATO presence sends the signal to Russia that Norwegian and US security are inseparable, at least in theory. The credibility of this claim is further seen through a softening of previously self-imposed restraints, such as restrictions on allied bases and exercises closer to Russia’s second strike capability on the Kola Peninsula. Other examples are found in the US Marine Corps’ presence on a rotational basis in Mid-Norway,48 high intensity combat exercises in Finnmark county with extensive US participation,49 new infrastructure for US Air Forces in southeast Norway, and new facilities for the US ground forces in Troms county.50 These developments are consistent with Walt’s expectation of a small state’s balancing behaviour towards an assertive neighbour.
Coupled with more security arrangements between Sweden, Finland, the US and NATO, Norway’s renewed “policy of invitation” has tied US commitments more explicitly to the Nordic states’ national security concerns. Vulnerable states on Russia’s border are assured, while the United States gets a firmer grip on the geopolitical challenge of providing Baltic NATO allies with credible reinforcements while preventing Russian submarines and aircraft access to the North Atlantic. Lifting the Cold War’s self-imposed restraints can be interpreted as a way of compensating for the abnegation of a sustainable territorial force, which during the 1980s enabled Norway to solve national episodes, incidents and crises alone – and even sustain national operations for more than four weeks.51 The contemporary absence of trimmed and well-functioning command structure in NATO increases the validity of this perspective.52
5.1 The Disadvantage of Allied Compliance
Relinquishing an adequate defence in the lower end of the conflict spectrum has long-term implications. The most serious but often neglected side effect is that Norwegian forces have become more inclined to pursue a more robust combat posture closer to Russia’s border. This means that deterrence is favoured before restraint; the “stick” becomes more important than the “carrot”. Minor bilateral events, episodes and crises are more likely to escalate than de-escalate, at least up to the point where Russian forces consider withdrawing out of fear of possible US involvement. How can this slide towards a more robust combat posture be explained?
Propensities to go on the offensive are closely linked to inadequate sustainability, which is a key characteristic for smaller allies that have undergone a cost-intensive transformation in NATO. Lack of volume and sustainability therefore makes it more rational to communicate resolve and combat agility. This is because a decisive outcome becomes critically important on short notice – preferably within a few days. The alternative, which would be a prolonged and indecisive situation, would instantly stir operative deterioration and a subsequent collapse before a clear political outcome has been reached. This is because troops that are put on a ‘24–7’ alert status face grave problems in sustaining agility without the constant support of sufficient logistics, maintenance and extra troops.
Ambiguous incidents, episodes or crises that are neither proper war nor proper peace, but something in between, may thereby reduce prospects for rapid assistance, and may ultimately lead to a diplomatic fait accompli where Norway ends up in a bilateral crisis with Russia before a US tripwire has been activated. This would complicate the Norwegian Armed Forces’ strategy, which – in the wording of former Chief of Defence (2005–2009) General Sverre Diesen – is as follows: faced with “… a limited military provocation, Norwegian forces must […] create a conflict which is so intense that our allies, due to reasons of national and collective credibility, are forced to get involved”.53
By default, then, Norwegian forces might be forced to pursue an aggressive “deterrence by punishment” 54 strategy in situations where disputes could be solved diplomatically with more patience, and a more cautious modus operandi. Maintaining a more agile force closer to Russia’s border counteracts a defensive posture, which during the Cold War was accomplished by a strategy labelled “deterrence by denial” in Troms county, approximately 1000 kilometres from the Russian border.55
Norway’s slide towards a more agile posture is underscored by empirical evidence from the Norwegian Defence Concept. Since 2012, the threshold defence concept has emphasised deterrence rather than assurance towards Russia.56 By rapidly raising the costs of aggression, scaring Russia from assertive action has become more important than pursuing self-restraints as a means of building confidence. Moving more forces closer to the Northern Fleet thereby challenges Norway’s previous self-imposed restraints codified in limitations on US exercises in Finnmark, or US bases in Trøndelag and Troms in peacetime.57 During the Cold War, keeping military forces further away from the border provided both Russia and Norway with longer strategic warning time.58 As these restraints have been removed, Norway’s strategy towards Russia has also evolved. From following a logic of absolute security for both states during the Cold War, which according to Johan Jørgen Holst was called “a silent cooperation”,59 the contemporary strategy seems to emphasise relative security for Norway at the expense of Russia. More emphasis on this kind of ‘zero-sum’ logic is also found in the political rhetoric of the Stoltenberg-II (2009–2013) and the Solberg Governments (2013–).60 Empirical evidence is also found in the conceptual idea of Threshold defence, 61 as well as in the pattern of contemporary joint exercises. According to Norwegian senior staff officers, NATO exercises, such as Cold Response, are more focused on rehearsing high intensity warfare after “deterrence failed”, than on mechanisms for de-escalation, mediation, and civil-military cooperation, which characterised most of the joint exercises between 2002 and 2010.62
6. Conclusion
Based on the Norwegian case, how should Northern Europe respond to the Russian assertiveness? Is closer integration into Western security arrangements a viable approach, e.g. for smaller non-aligned states like Sweden and Finland? Three conclusions can be deduced.
First, as Northern Europe increasingly aligns with the US and other NATO forces, states like Sweden and Finland may more easily gain access to US decision makers. From this vantage point, national concerns can be voiced more clearly in tough competition with numerous other European allies striving for US attention and reinforcements. Such access increases US awareness, and thus prospects for successful activation of US security guaranties if needed. This logic is anchored in the traditional tenets of alliance theory, where balancing is more commonly pursued by smaller states than bandwagoning.63
But such a strategy may also increase the risk of more tension, instability and unpredictability. This is arguably so because Russia’s strategic forces will need an extended zone of security to protect their forces from US or other NATO allies’ precision guided missiles. As an extended part of Northern Europe opens up for US and NATO operations on their own territories, this reassuring effect could be nullified by Russian counter efforts aiming to protect its force. Balancing with the stronger part thereby creates a typical security dilemma because Russia, according to Snyder, will respond with more assertiveness.64 In particular, Sweden and Finland’s slide from “buffer” to “springboard” may increase the risk of geopolitical change in Northern Europe. This is because both states’ territories play a more prominent role in US and Russian defence planning.
It can be argued that this is not likely to provide the population with more security because their national territories will be more exposed to unwanted Russian attention necessary for military planning and readiness. A question for further research could be to examine to what extent accelerated Nordic-Baltic defence cooperation could alleviate a situation where smaller states more vigorously can address a military vacuum currently filled by US and Russian forces.
Second, the slide from “buffer” to “springboard” also means that domestic policy in Sweden and Finland will be more exposed to US expectations and demands. Based on the Norwegian experience, this is particularly so with regard to US expectations of reciprocity abroad. As in the case of Norway and Denmark, more troops from Northern Europe will be expected to participate in open-ended engagements in Central Asia, the Middle East and possibly Africa. This logic is consistent with another alliance dilemma raised by Snyder, which is that clients may easily become entrapped into a patron’s war elsewhere because clients are afraid of being abandoned at home.65
Deployments abroad may on the one hand energise combat experience and critical competence among forces that will also operate at home. But they may also increase the risk of fragmentation and critical shortcomings within a national force structure that needs to be cohesively trained at home. Vulnerabilities deriving from this over-stretch problématique may accelerate US dependency because simultaneous engagements abroad and at home are detrimental to small states’ military readiness and cohesiveness in the lower end of the conflict spectre. This trend, it may be argued, may hamper efforts undertaken by small states, such as Sweden and Finland, to exert influence on how the strategic balance between deterrence and restraint can be tailored vis-a-vis Russia.
A question for further research however, would be falsify this assumption, and explore alternative ways to cope with small states’ endemic over-stretch problématique. Could it be that “pooling and sharing” among small states would provide more security than outsourcing defence responsibilities to US forces even at the lower end of the conflict spectrum?
Third, increased US dependency may increase the risk of energising a “cult of the offensive” among smaller states in Northern Europe. While dependency may favour integration and interoperability among like-minded states in the West, it may also lead to a deterioration in diplomatic relations with Russia. This is because national vulnerabilities make smaller states more inclined to escalate rather than de-escalate tense situations; seeking to avoid a fait accompli with Russia, a decisive outcome on short notice will be required in order to trigger a US tripwire.
Such a strategy may – in a narrow sense – provide more security for Northern Europe because Russia will gain less security in relative terms. But in absolute terms, it will also, in accordance with the logic put forth by both Schelling and Holst, create less security for Northern Europe and Russia. This is because US forces will be increasingly important at a much earlier stage in a potentially tense situation, which forces Russia to take precautionary efforts.66 It is important to note that Russia does not fear the smaller states in Northern Europe. Russia only fears that the region will become a ‘stepping stone’ for US operations towards Russia. A question for further research could therefore be to what extent self-imposed restraints put forth by smaller North European states are possible without displaying weakness and thus invoking more Russian assertiveness. Could stronger mutual dependency between Russia and Northern Europe, e.g. on energy and trade, alleviate some of the military tension currently fuelling the regional security situation?