Best studies conclude yes entrapment
Wilhelmsen ’20 [Julie.; Sep 30; Norwegian Institute of International Affairs; Journal of Global Security Studies, “Spiraling toward a New Cold War in the North? The Effect of Mutual and Multifaceted Securitization ,” https://academic.oup.com/jogss/article/6/3/ogaa044/5916402; Vol. 6, 2021, pp. 1–19]
This study builds on in-depth, systematic scrutiny of official statements from the years 2014 to 2018. The Norwegian data are statements, press releases, speeches, etc., from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA), the Prime Minister's Office, and the Ministry of Defense (MoD). The Russian data are transcripts and statements from the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and transcripts from the public appearances of the President. The texts have been “scraped”—downloaded in full—from www.regjeringen.no, www.mid.ru, and www.kremlin.ru. Using the open source “corporaexplorer” software (Gjerde 2019), we then extracted a clearly defined subset of this large document collection: The final text collection contains documents that include references to both Russia and the Arctic on the Norwegian side, and documents that include references to Norway or the Arctic on the Russian side—the difference being due to the far higher number of documents on the Norwegian side. In certain parts of the analysis, the official texts retrieved through web-scraping have been supplemented by media articles referring to comments from Russian and Norwegian officials. The aim has been to sample more statements at particularly critical events in order to study action–reaction patterns.
The texts have been studied by using discourse analysis in the tradition of Laclau and Mouffe (1985), with emphasis on the contested nature of meaning-making. This has implied systematically mapping the changing pattern of self and other representations in official texts. The method has been designed to foreground the constitutive power of language and capture securitization as a process by studying a plethora of official utterances over time (Wilhelmsen 2014, 58–64; Stengel 2019). I focus not only on how certain verbs, adverbs, and adjectives attached to nouns might help to constitute the other as increasingly different and dangerous to the self (Milliken 1999, 232–33), but also on how linguistic repetitions, mergers, and comparisons might contribute to such a process. The article also lists concrete policy practices that have been implemented in line with Norway's changing representations of Russia in the section “A new Norwegian approach to Russia.” These have been retrieved from Norwegian media and from Norwegian MOD and MFA websites. While the combination of systematically reading and manually coding such large bodies of text is exceptionally time-consuming, the mixture arguably strengthens the reliability of interpretivist endeavors such as this (Hopf and Allan 2016, 20).
More generally, the approach used here recovers the identity categories from texts and other sources of shared meaning (Hopf and Allan 2016, 27). That Norway and Russia are securitizing each other is thus not a claim made a priori, but a conclusion I draw after consulting a plethora of texts. In the fifth section, on internal cohesion and external offense, the challenge has been to stay within the confines of relying on explicit utterances to capture the interactive dynamics at play when two social entities engage in mutual and multifaceted securitization. This has entailed trying to reach conclusions on strategies of externalization and mirroring by consulting texts where one party explicitly refers to something the other party said or did.