Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

CP kills assurances – freeriding accusations and contested metrics

Foucalt and Mérand 12, Martial Foucault is a professor of political science at Sciences Pro Paris and a researches of political economy and political behavior, Frédéric Mérand is a profession of political science and the Scientific Director of the Centre for International Studies at the University of Montreal and a researcher in international relations and global security, “The Challenge of Burden Sharing,” Spring 2012, International Journal, Vol. 67, No. 2, https://www.jstor.org/stable/23266017

Accusations of free-riding have marred transatlantic relations ever since the creation of the Atlantic alliance in 1949. Then as now, the rhetoric of burden-sharing has served as a useful rhetorical weapon to blame those who were seen as not contributing enough to the cause. Each time, however, Washington's call has fallen on deaf ears, at least in public. In private, European and Canadian officials highlight other contributions they think they are making to NATO operations, for example in the shape of development aid or considerable troop casualties in Afghanistan. They mention UN peacekeeping missions, such as in Lebanon, where the US is not involved. Cynics admit that they never really bought much into the military adventures into which the US threw them, and that the US itself did not seem to believe much in the Libya mission. The reality, French foreign minister Alain Juppe retorted to Gates, is that it is the Europeans who "think the Americans aren't doing enough."3 The evolution of the transatlantic debate suggests two things. First, burden-sharing is about more than NATO. One cannot just look at defence spending at a time when humanitarian aid, diplomatic mediation, and the fight against climate change can all be considered contributions of a sort to collective security.4 Disentangling what counts as a contribution to which public good is no easy thing. Second, burden-sharing is a contested political concept. Statesmen and diplomats do not speak the abstract language of public choice, with its "non-excludable" and "non-rival" goods. Rather, they talk about "being fair," "doing what you can," and "making a real contribution." In other words, they speak the normative language of justice rather than the utilitarian language of economics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.