Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Entrapment is wrong and adaption solves.

Cohen and Monie 19 [Jordan Cohen is a Political science Ph.D. student at George Mason University and Connor Monie is a Master's candidate in international security at George Mason University. "The True Value of a NATO Membership" The National Interest, 25 November 2019, https://nationalinterest.org/feature/true-value-nato-membership-99817.]

The second part of the counterargument deals with entanglement and entrapment. The idea that U.S. presence in an alliance with an extensive security commitment and an ever-increasing number of European countries and can entangle it in a conflict with Russia is persistent and not entirely incorrect.

On one hand, the academic literature suggests entrapment is far less common than perceived. Separate research by Tongfi Kim, Michael Beckley, and Alexander Lanoszka all finds that entrapment is an unlikely scenario in international politics. In fact, the work by Beckley finds that the United States has been able to avoid entanglement by using a large alliance portfolio to balance counteracting commitments.

Even if one is still concerned with the risks of entrapment, this is a major reason why NATO should adopt a strategy less focused on deterring Russia. As we noted previously, by constantly focusing on defense spending and balancing, NATO has threatened Russia. Thus, our argument actually suggests entanglement will be less likely if NATO begins to focus more on cooperative and humanitarian actions within the alliance.

By the mere fact of its continued existence, NATO has displayed a penchant for adaptation to new circumstances. To continue surviving, though, it needs to adapt once again. The focus on balancing against Russia made sense during the Cold War but has made Europe less secure while also decreasing the popularity of the alliance.

By shifting its focus to the promotion of shared values and broader international political cooperation, NATO can prove Macron incorrect, and revitalize its existence in a new era.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.