Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turkey won’t invoke Article 5 – low cred and Turkey doesn’t think they say yes

İbrahim KARATAŞ 20 (10/20/2020, “Analyzing the Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty as an Assurance of Turkey’s Security”, Middle Eastern Studies, 13-2 (2021):155-176//) EZAY

Article 5 of the NATO agreement that orders collective defense for a member that has incurred an armed attack has always been a matter of debate in Turkey. Turks are suspicious of it if it involves Turkey in a likely war or conflict. This study analyzed whether Turkey and other members can rely on NATO’s assurance of security stemming from Article 5. After examining certain events and surveys measuring public opinion of member states about NATO, it has been concluded that it is not clear that other members will defend Turkey or any other member since the article was invoked only once in the history of NATO to protect the US against relatively small states and a terrorist group. However, regarding Turkey’s position, the claim that NATO will not protect Turkey cannot be proven since Turkey did not face an existential threat after becoming a NATO member. In addition, deterring the Soviet Union from attacking Turkey by making it a NATO member can be regarded as a benefit of Article 5 without invoking it. On the other hand, Turkey’s own preferences and compelling reasons in foreign policy made it to be in contention with its NATO allies. However, when NATO members’ attitudes are examined, it can be concluded that they could still have proposed better solutions for Turkey. In addition to the above, as per public opinion surveys, NATO members hint that they may not sacrifice themselves for others unless (1) they are at War, (2) the enemy attacks all, (3) all attack the enemy, and (4) the US leads. According to surveys, this thesis is valid for Turkey since it favors NATO least and does not seem to join a collective defense of its allies. Yet, NATO’s and some members’ failure or reluctance to address Turkey’s security problems has a significant impact on Turkish people’s views. Surveys also show that NATO members are not as much in allegiance to the organization as they were in the past, probably due to the non-existence of an imminent threat.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.