Solves disease and drug resistance
Fischbach 2013 - UCSF Center for Systems and Synthetic Biology, University of California, San Francisco Michael A, Jeffrey A Bluestone, and Wendell A Lim, "Cell-Based Therapeutics: The Next Pillar of Medicine," Science Translational Medicine 03 Apr 2013: Vol. 5, Issue 179, pp. 179ps7
Today, biomedical science sits on the cusp of another revolution: the use of human and microbial cells as therapeutic entities (1). In principle, cells have therapeutic capabilities that are distinct from those of small molecules and biologics and that extend beyond the regenerative-medicine arena. Part drug and part device, cells can sense diverse signals, move to specific sites in the body, integrate inputs to make decisions, and execute complex response behaviors—all in the context of a specific tissue environment. These attributes could potentially be harnessed to treat infections, autoimmunity, cancers, metabolic diseases, and tissue degeneration as well as realizing tissue repair and regeneration. Indeed, pioneering clinical trials have highlighted the benefits of using cells as therapeutic agents (2–7). However, the complexity of cells and the challenge of controlling their actions in a therapeutic setting provide daunting scientific, regulatory, economic, and cultural obstacles to the establishment of cells as a widespread and viable pharmaceutical platform.
With our deep mechanistic understanding of cellular systems biology, researchers are poised to harness these intricate behaviors in new ways to generate an array of precisely regulated weapons against a broad range of diseases. However, a critical step that will enable the emergence of cells as the next therapeutic pillar is the development of cellular engineering as a foundational science. This will include mechanisms for editing and recoding genomes, the assembly of a toolkit of molecular parts and regulatory modules that behave predictably, and a systems-based theoretical framework that can provide strategies for tuning and optimizing cellular behaviors.
HOW WHOLE CELLS TRUMP THEIR PARTS
If small molecules and biologics are tools, then cells are carpenters—and architects and engineers as well. Of the three pillars, only cells sense their surroundings, make decisions, and exhibit varied and regulable behaviors (Table 1). Devices share some of these advantages; indeed, some abiotic therapeutic nanodevices mimic cellular behaviors, although these equally fascinating new therapeutic candidates will not be discussed here.
Cells naturally perform therapeutic tasks
The human body has three kinds of natural agents that perform the tasks we demand of therapeutics. The first two are small molecules (for example, neurotransmitters) and biologics (such as antibodies, growth factors, cytokines, and peptide hormones). Cells are the third—and the only ones that can perform complex biological functions. For example, macrophages engulf pathogens and recruit adaptive immune cells; hematopoietic stem cells give rise to myeloid and lymphoid lineages; chondrocytes produce a cartilaginous extracellular matrix; pancreatic β cells sense glucose and respond by producing insulin; and gut bacteria convert indigestible fibers into short-chain fatty acids that fuel intestinal epithelial cells.
Cell behavior is exquisitely selective
Most small molecules and biologics are always active; they do not have ON or OFF switches, and if they reach their target, they will bind it and exert a biological effect. In contrast, cells sense their environment and respond with an action only when in the presence of a specific array of molecular inputs. Thus, cells can have exquisite sensitivity and specificity, which impart a greater ability to limit off-target action. Engineering and controlling key cellular receptors and how their signals are processed could, in principle, allow customization of responses such that only therapeutically relevant signals trigger activation of a selected cellular behavior (8).
Cells are special delivery agents
PK and PD properties and metabolism determine where in the body small molecules and biologics distribute. The inability to limit their distribution to a single tissue or cell type often results in off-target effects, which can be serious enough to end a drug-development program, even at a costly late stage. For example, the insulin sensitization activity of rosiglitazone, a peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR)–γ ligand, results from its activity in adipocytes, but the increased risk of myocardial infarction observed in some patients arises from the drug’s action in cardiac cells. Although rare, this outcome has had a chilling effect on drug sales and on the development of other PPAR-γ–targeted drugs. Cells are less likely to have off-target effects because they can selectively recognize and actively migrate toward specific signals and exert their effects in a highly targeted manner. One can imagine an ideal cellular agent that is engineered to produce a PPAR-γ ligand, but only in the local environment of adipocytes.
Cells can handle human genetic variability
Determining the right dose of a drug for a diverse patient population can be challenging. Common polymorphisms in genes that encode drug transporters or drug-metabolizing cytochromes P450 can tweak the transport of a small molecule in and out of cells or alter drug metabolism, respectively; as a result, the same dose of a small molecule can, in different individuals, result in widely varying amounts of the active metabolite reaching its target. For example, common polymorphisms in the gene that encodes organic cation transporter 1 (OCT1) lead to reduced uptake of the type 2 diabetes drug metformin, resulting in differences in the efficacy of metformin among individuals (9). In contrast, cells could potentially be engineered to automatically adjust to differences in host metabolism and transport by harboring a rheostat-like circuit that produces more of a molecule when needed and degrades the excess when a threshold concentration is exceeded. Thus, in principle, cells could yield therapeutic responses that are less variable in different individuals.
Cell behaviors can be engineered
To manage their disease, patients with autoimmune (type 1) diabetes (T1D) have to monitor their blood sugar, inject insulin, and limit their diets. Failure to control T1D can have grave consequences, including blindness, limb amputation, and death. Because T1D results from the autoimmune destruction of insulin-synthesizing pancreatic β cells, simply replacing these cells is not a viable therapeutic strategy. Instead, introducing a cell that has been engineered to perform an unnatural yet important task—for example, a T lymphocyte that has been modified to sense glucose and produce insulin—is a provocative alternative. Such a cell is potentially within the reach of synthetic biology and, if it relieved the insulin dependency of T1D patients, would represent a major therapeutic breakthrough. For the subset of T1D cases characterized by the presence of autoantibodies that recognize and destroy insulin, this cell might be engineered to produce an insulin derivative that recognizes and modulates the activity of insulin receptors but evades binding by insulin autoantibodies.
KILLER APPS FOR CELL THERAPY
Although small molecules and biologics will always have important therapeutic niches, there are applications for which cells are better equipped. This section explores critical unmet needs in human disease that cell-based therapeutics are uniquely well suited to address (Fig. 1). We focus on three specific cases, although there are arrays of other promising applications that are not discussed here, including stem cell and dendritic-cell therapeutics, which have been the subjects of numerous reviews (10–13). Two of these cases are built on recent pioneering examples of cell-based therapies that have demonstrated clinical efficacy: chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)–modified T cells and fecal transplantations.
Immune cells that seek and destroy cancer
The most effective new small-molecule (kinase inhibitors) and biologic (antibody) cancer therapies offer as little as 6 to 36 months of disease-free survival before cancer progression (14, 15). Therefore, one of the major challenges for cancer therapy is to block the growth of drug-tolerant or resistant cancer cells that underlie progression and to kill metastatic cells that have broken free of the primary tumor mass and intravasated into a blood or lymphatic vessel.
Combination therapies that prevent the outgrowth of resistant cells are one possible therapeutic avenue, but small molecules and biologics have a difficult time being sentinels. They cannot turn themselves on and off, and so they rely entirely on specific molecular recognition to determine whether or not they act. And because the target cell can evolve resistance mechanisms (14), the therapeutically useful lifetime of a small molecule or biologic is limited.
The job of detecting and destroying a shape-shifting cellular target may be better suited to a cell-based therapeutic. Recent clinical studies have shown the efficacy of using engineered T lymphocytes in treating chronic lymphoid leukemia (3, 4). The ex vivo-transformed T cells were modified to express a CAR in which the receptor extra-cellular targeting domain has been replaced by an single-chain antibody that recognizes a tumor-specific molecule. These and related studies: (7) (i) prove that it is possible to retarget immune cells to detect and respond to new, non-natural signals and (ii) establish T cells as a favorable chassis for engineering. Future versions of CAR-modified T cells may encode control circuits that enable them to be activated or deactivated in a small-molecule–dependent fashion and to produce a biologic that counteracts adverse side effects, such as cytokine storm (for example, an anti–IL-6 antibody).
Establishment of drug resistance is less likely to be a problem for a sentinel cell therapeutic than for small molecules and biologics. A therapeutic cell could be engineered to recognize multiple features of a target cell so that changing any one of them would not be enough to evade detection (in effect, a combination therapy). Given the ability of a cell-based therapeutic to adapt to an evolving pathogen, cells may be a natural choice for other surveillance jobs as well, including seeking and destroying activated cells from chronic infections, such as a latent Mycobacterium tuberculosis population.