Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The CP disregards bioethics.

Hamilton '21 [R. Alexander Hamilton, Ruth Mampuys, S. E. Galaitsi, Aengus Collins, Ivan Istomin, Marko Ahteensuu & Lela Bakanidze, "Opportunities, Challenges, and Future Considerations for Top-Down Governance for Biosecurity and Synthetic Biology," in Emerging Threats of Synthetic Biology and Biotechnology, pp 37–58]

A laissez-faire governance approach cedes much of the regulatory power to existing or emerging bottom-up initiatives, placing trust in the capacity of technology producers, industry and users to play an active role in their own regulation. Under this approach, such non-governmental actors are encouraged to determine (at least in part) how safety and security practices are structured, implemented and enforced, while centralized government plays a role in setting minimum standards and intervening in the event of regulatory failures. This approach is generally intended to promote innovation and flexibility, as well as rapid adaption and response to emerging threats (Linkov et al. 2018a, b).

While laissez-faire governance is a promising approach that recognizes the important role that non-governmental actors can play in the regulatory process, there are also potential pitfalls. One such example, albeit focused on bioethics rather than biosecurity, can be traced to the use of germline editing in humans to produce the first CRISPR baby. In this case, despite broad international agreement that scientists should “hold off on editing human eggs, sperm or embryos until gene-editing technology (and the implications of the edits) are better understood.”Footnote13 (See also Cyranoski and Ledford 2018), a researcher in China took advantage of laissez-faire regulatory controls that resulted in multiple potential risks and unintended consequences. These included the possibility of long-term changes to the human germline; encouraging other scientists (including those working internationally) to pursue germline editing in humans (Cyranoski 2019a, b), and motivating Chinese regulators to introduce stricter regulatory controls on genetic research (ibid.).

As the above example suggests, one risk of laissez-faire governance is that an individual’s risk tolerance may not (intentionally or unintentionally) conform to existing norms and their actions may subsequently expose everyone to undue risk or irreversible harm, with implications for the laissez-faire state as well as other states. Additionally, the more a state relies on soft law, the more responsibility the government delegates to individuals, groups and organizations, not only to establish norms and follow them, but also to enforce them. In the case of synthetic biology, such bottom-up initiatives have played an important role in this rapidly developing field. Organizations such as the International Gene Synthesis Consortium (IGSC) have come to play an important role in the regulatory process by, for example, developing industry standards and guidelines (IGSC 2017). For better or worse, the success of such approaches will depend on the commitment of non-governmental actors to act in the best interests of society, valuing safety and security as a public good.

Ultimately, while a laissez-faire approach may effectively supplement aspects of centralized government regulation, it cannot be expected to fully replace it. This is because, as history has shown, individual researchers or individual members of industry will sometimes choose to value personal prestige or cost cutting over safety and security. Moreover, from the standpoint of non-governmental actors, including the DNA synthesis consortia noted above, regulation is not necessarily a bad thing. Indeed, by some accounts, the standards and codes of conduct produced by the DNA synthesis industry were motivated by a lack of top-down regulations that could provide a benchmark for not only mitigating potential biosecurity risks, but also liability issues and reputational costs in the event of an incident. For this reason, the US Government’s own DNA screening guidanceFootnote14 has been largely welcomed by industry.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.