Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

It solves diverging policy in cyberspace the best – it allows states to find common ground

Ponta 21 [Adina Ponta, December 2021, <<Adina is Faculty of Law @ Babes Bolyai University>>, “Legal instability in cyberspace and OSCE’s mitigation role,” Juridical Tribune Journal, Volume 11, Issue 3]\\pairie

Although the OSCE process cannot force States to implement their recommendations, it can employ preventive and quiet diplomacy, as well as results orientated dialogue to find common grounds on emerging security challenges.52 As GGE processes share almost overlapping mandates with the OEWG, the OSCE can be among the most promising venues for multilateral cybersecurity cooperation. In this regard, the OSCE’s ability to bring the United States and Russia to the conversation table is crucial, and with EU support, it should strive at engaging Chinese representatives as well. The People’s Republic of China, which takes a similar view to Russia, also participated in the GGEs, but is not an OSCE member. The preliminary conversations should focus on national interpretations and application of fundamental international law principles. To ensure a candid exchange of views, initial conversations should be held under Chatham House Rule and avoid public scrutiny.

Fifth, as the coordinating fora for CBMs, the OSCE, has accumulated political capital of addressing States’ reluctance regarding information-sharing and inherent challenges that create multi-stakeholder cooperation problems. During the previous rounds, the OSCE gained an overview on which objectives can reasonably be achieved multilaterally, and which ones are more suited for bilateral cooperation mechanisms.53 Deriving lessons learned from past processes enables better approaches to national interests, concerns, and operational practices. 54

It would be utopic to believe that major powers will agree on interpretations of every legal institution. Even the experts of the Tallinn Manual Process could not agree on basic principles, although as mentioned, they mainly originated from likeminded states and cultures. The first part of this paper highlighted that the process of norm-creation may matter as much as the destination, as participants agree to disagree and understand each other’s differences and underlying rationales.

Another important endeavor is the analysis of past and present challenges of effective implementation of voluntary norms. The OSCE should strive at assisting States to recognize the prospective domestic and foreign policy value of recognizing CBMs.55 The reasons why some of the measures were perceived as being less important, implementation challenges, and responses within the civil society and industry shall be thoroughly examined.

The Proliferation Security Initiative (PSI) is sometimes cited as a possible model for future cybersecurity cooperation. 56 This approach has been described as a “coalition of the willing” against a global threat by means of flexible coordination of national and international instruments.57 The proposed institutional architecture encourages collective action for a common cause, without requiring legally binding commitments. This agreement is also recognized for reaching a political commitment by only a few States, which accepted that they have different capacities and resources to identify and respond to threats. This initiative represents a successful example of voluntary cooperation, first among like-minded States, around enforcement of specific, agreed norms of behavior.

The OSCE participating States should capitalize on lessons learned to operationalize norms in a practical manner, such as was the case of the 1990 OSCE Vienna Document on Negotiations on CSBMs, which contained voluntary military measures aiming at enhancing transparency, trust building, and arms control. After their translation into the cyber realm, these tools departed from the traditional military components of CSBMs and adopted more cyber diplomacy approaches, bringing both likeminded and non-likeminded States to the table.58

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.