Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

The DIB is in the dumps

Tegler 22, 2-4-2022, Eric Tegler is a Contributor for Forbes in AEROSPACE & DEFENSE"The Defense Industrial Base’s Vital Signs Aren’t Looking Good," https://www.forbes.com/sites/erictegler/2022/02/04/the-defense-industrial-bases-vital-signs-arent-looking-good/?sh=215e90c02101

For the last three years, the  has issued an annual report on the health of America’s Defense Industrial Base. While the state of the U.S. defense industry has been a source of angst for decades, the NDIA’s latest report is the first to assess the environment in which its members operate as broadly failing.

The study, , found deteriorating conditions for the Defense Industrial Base (DIB) in eight categories, including industrial security, supply chains, productive capacity and surge readiness.

Wes Hallman, NDIA’s senior vice president of strategy and policy, says that this year’s study depicted a broadly negative environment in part because it uses lagging publicly available data. Though compiled in 2021, it uses 2020 data (SEC Form 10-K public filings, public contract data, government indicators including contract failure rates) which finally became available in the first quarter of 2021. It will similarly use the 2021 data it receives this March for next year’s report.

The study does include a survey conducted in summer 2021 of NDIA’s members, large and small, with over 400 respondents. That more up-to-date survey illustrates a situation that is not improving, exacerbated by inflationary pressure and congressional gridlock on the defense budget.

“As you look at our previous reports, you see areas of fragility and concern,” Hallman notes. “Covid really shined a spotlight on those concerns whether they’re workforce challenges, supply chain, etc.”

NDIA’s researchers say they expect they’ll get similar responses to their survey questions this coming year, which should raise alarm bells adding to those that have been sounding for years. The NDIA asked members if they thought their 2022 performance would match their 2021 business. Fourteen percent said they thought they would not perform as well.

NDIA’s regulatory policy associate Robert Van Steenburg, adds that one survey response pointedly stood out.

“We asked our members, ‘Are you the sole eligible supplier for the good or service you provide? Thirty percent of them said yes.”

Altogether, the public data and survey responses in the report yielded five key takeaways, the first centering on the effects of the pandemic. Not surprisingly, 71% of respondents reported “moderate negative” or “large negative” impacts due to Covid-19. This was reflected in a cash conversion cycle that fell by 38 points in 2020 according to NDIA scoring.

The data lag in the report may not fully reflect the impact of massive government expenditures for Covid relief. Total relief spending by the U.S. on the pandemic is over $6 trillion, or roughly 27.1% of the nation's GDP, the third-highest globally, according to data published by the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget.

The defense contractors which constitute NDIA membership were declared “essential” early in the pandemic and thus never stopped working during initial lockdowns. Nevertheless, many of these companies had exposure to the broader economic activity halt through complimentary commercial business lines in aerospace, airlines and elsewhere. More pure defense contractors with less exposure appeared to do better but still suffered productivity losses.

Those have continued despite the torrent of spending thanks in part to federal measures - or the threat of federal measures - related to vaccine mandates.

“There is a portion of the [DIB] workforce that is reticent about vaccines,” Hallman affirms. “Even where companies are 90% vaccinated, there are key personnel that are hard to replace which has caused some lines to shut down, some contracts to go into failure.” He adds that NDIA continues to communicate this reality to policy makers “so there is an understanding that these policies have real impact on the defense industrial base”.

Workforce issues continue to be a challenge, the pandemic notwithstanding. In the report, 67% respondents said it was “somewhat difficult” or “extremely difficult” to find cleared workers. There were similar results for skilled trade workers, and STEM workers. A security clearance backlog that reached approximately 700,000 individuals a few years ago has improved, but Hallman says that progress appears to have stagnated.

Nick Jones, NDIA’s regulatory policy director, says contractors view this as a critical systemic problem beside lower workforce participation across the economy.

“Our membership was asked what part of your supply chain is most vulnerable? The most frequent response was the gap in U.S.-based human capital. It’s really the workforce that is increasingly the limiting factor for many of these companies. There’s an aspect of Covid in this but it’s been ongoing and is really tangential to the Covid crisis.”

The prospects for innovation in the DIB scored negatively as well. The study reported a drop in the number of new entrants in the sector from 6,500 in FY19 to 6,300 in FY20. That trend looks set to continue, a reality reflected in a series of public discussions by policy makers, participants and the Pentagon over the last year.

“There should have been a lot more new entrants into the contractor ranks whether through Covid-related Defense Production Act contracts or through companies in the commercial sector looking for a safe haven,” Wes Hallman asserts. “The fact that the number didn’t go up but down despite Covid [contracting/spending] is an interesting statistic.”

The oft cited problem of the so-called “Valley of Death” wherein innovative, small defense companies go out of business in the gap between receiving R&D funding and getting an actual contract in a program of record may get worse Hallman points out.

“The latest version of the National Defense Authorization Act [NDAA] did not extend the SBIR [Small Business Innovation Research] authority. The program sunsets on the 1st of October of this year. That’s a bad signal.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.