Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A Russian nuke would make escalation inevitable – regardless of what NATO does.

Slocombe 22 [Walter Becker Slocombe is a former Under Secretary of Defense for Policy and was the Senior Advisor for Security and Defense to the Coalition Provisional Authority in Baghdad., 5-10-2022, "Will Putin use nuclear weapons in Ukraine? Our experts answer three burning questions.", https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/will-putin-use-nuclear-weapons-in-ukraine-our-experts-answer-three-burning-questions/, DOA: 7-3-2022 //ArchanSen]

Assuming the United States, NATO, and Ukraine could agree on any action, there are several possibilities. If the Russian attack caused little damage, NATO might first try to issue an ultimatum with the aim of reaching a settlement on the Alliance’s and Ukraine’s terms. But if Putin had convinced himself that there was no other option but to strike, he would be unlikely to acquiesce to any allied proposals for such a settlement. Similarly, a non-nuclear military response (for example, conventional strikes on military bases and infrastructure in Russian territory that are supporting the invasion) would probably not be decisive and would appear inadequate to many—in addition to carrying its own risks of escalation.

That leaves the option, for which NATO forces are fully adequate, of a strike tailored to the scale and character of the Russian one. Some would understandably argue that continuing to defend Ukraine is simply not worth risking a nuclear escalation. But while it is easy to see the risks of a nuclear counterstrike, there are also serious implications of not doing it: The absence of a US nuclear response would gravely weaken the credibility among both friends and adversaries of the entire strategy of deterring nuclear attack through the prospect of US nuclear retaliation. This, in turn, would make a bigger war more likely. May we never need to face the choice.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.