Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Economies of scale---contracts build resiliency into defense industry supply chains AND reduce domestic production costs, that’s Key to readiness

Eugene Gholz, 2019 Associate professor of political science at the University of Notre Dame, and he was awarded the US Department of Defense Exceptional Public Service Medal for his service as senior advisor to the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Manufacturing and Industrial Base Policy, “Conventional Arms Transfers and US Economic Security” https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/SSQ/documents/Volume-13_Issue-1/Gholz.pdf

CATs have a clearer, direct effect on economic security via their effect on US defense manufacturing. Because weapon systems tend to stay in the US military inventory for so long, they often require spare parts for maintenance years after the initial production run is complete. DOD needs to pay the overhead cost of maintaining the production capacity for those spare parts, even when the production rate for spares is much slower than the initial production rate during original manufacture of the defense system. That slower rate tends to drive the unit cost of spare parts dramatically upward. In some cases, demand for spare parts drops below the minimum technical sustaining rate, meaning that the workers lose the ability to maintain quality standards even when the buyer is willing to pay very high unit costs. In other cases, the government does not realize how much the cost of production has risen over time and does not invest enough to keep the supplier interested or able to produce the part profitably, so production drops below the minimum economic sustaining rate. These situations create potentially very costly Diminishing Manufacturing Sources or Material Shortage (DMSMS) problems.20 Arms exports and the expanded demand for future spare parts business that they create can help reduce the unit cost of spares production by keeping up production rates, maintaining workers’ skills, and ameliorating the risk of DMSMS by bolstering revenue for critical and fragile niches in the supply chain. These effects have been observed in recent years in export sales of M-1 Abrams tanks and M-2 Bradley infantry fighting vehicles, among others. Assessing these manufacturing effects of arms sales requires detailed knowledge of the defense supply chain, including the technical characteristics of the components that suppliers make, the financial status of each of those suppliers, and the business strategy of the executives at each supplier—knowledge that is not often available to the government or defense industry prime contractors. Finally, CATs can contribute economic benefits to the United States through the economies of scale that are often available in defense systems production. If foreign sales are figured into the cost estimates from the start of a project, and foreign buyers contribute to development and capital investment spending, the cost of a project to the US defense budget will be proportionately reduced, benefiting US economic security. For example, the F-35 program claims to have benefited from this dynamic, although the higher overhead cost of managing a multinational development program and the redundancies of building extra final assembly and sustainment facilities overseas cut against the economies of scale benefits.21 In some European multinational aircraft development programs, governments have presumed that programs would gain very large benefits from economies of scale that have not materialized. This is due to technical and management challenges in the programs or the countries’ failure to follow through on their initial purchase commitments. The result in those cases was that including projected economy of scale benefits of foreign sales in a program’s management baseline added to rather than reduced program instability and hurt economic security.22 Estimating the net economic effect of expected economies of scale as part of a CAT decision would require sophisticated, reliable understanding of program dynamics that might be beyond what the US government should reasonably count on in its decision making. Overall, the new economic assessment in the CAT policy could meaningfully consider two separate types of economic benefits that might derive from arms sales: first, macroeconomic effects, especially via effects on employment, and second, microeconomic effects on specific firms and products, such as funding for component upgrades and prevention of DMSMS challenges. The methods for assessing these two types of effects would likely differ, and each would present its own challenges to the data collection and analysis process.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.