Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Global nuclear war

Dr. Richard H. Speier 17, Adjunct Staff with the RAND Corp, Founded the Office of Non- Proliferation Policy at the DOD, Recipient of the Meritorious Civilian Service Medal as the “Father of the MTCR,” now Consults in the Washington DC area; George Nacouzi, Senior Engineer at the RAND Corporation, Supports Projects within PAF (Project Air Force) and NSRD (National Security Research Division), Carrie A. Lee, Researcher at RAND, and Richard M. Moore, Researcher at RAND. 2017. “Hypersonic Missile Nonproliferation: Hindering the Spread of a New Class of Weapons.” RAND. https://www.rand.org/pubs/research_reports/RR2137.html

Strategic Implications of Hypersonic Weapons Compressed Timelines The U.S. military uses an acronym to describe the decisionmaking and action process cycle: OODA (Observe, Orient, Decide, Act). These four steps take time, and hypersonic missiles compress available response time to the point that a lesser nation’s strategic forces might be disarmed before acting. As an illustration of the time required to act with respect to an existential missile threat, the Nuclear Threat Initiative organization estimated a timeline for a U.S. response to a massive Russian intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) attack, as follows:9 • 0 minutes—Russia launches missiles • 1 minute—U.S. satellite detects missiles • 2 minutes—U.S. radar detects missiles • 3 minutes—North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD) assesses information (2 minutes max) • 4 minutes—NORAD alerts White House • 5 minutes—first detonations of submarine-launched ballistic missiles • 7 minutes—locate president and advisers, assemble them, brief them, get decision (8 minutes max) • 13 minutes—decision • 15 minutes—transmit orders to start launch sequence • 20 minutes—launch officers receive, decode, and authenticate orders • 23 minutes—complete launch sequence (2 minutes max) • 25 minutes—Russian ICBM detonations. This timeline is not, of course, representative of two hostile parties in closer proximity or with less effective warning systems than Russia and the United States. Nor is it representative of less-than-Armageddon possibilities. However, for adjacent enemies within a 1,000-km range, a hypersonic missile traveling at ten times the speed of sound could cover that distance and reduce response times to about six minutes.10 Targets As discussed earlier, hypersonic missiles increase the threat over current generations of missiles in cases where the target nation has missile defenses. The targets in such nations would primarily be high value and heavily defended. Prime targets could include destroying a nation’s leadership and command and control, referred to as “decapitation,” to prevent the target nation from responding with an effective follow-on attack. Other key targets could be carrier strike groups, with the objective of striking a key blow or pushing the naval formation further from the coast. And, because of their time sensitivity, strategic forces and storage facilities for weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) could warrant hypersonic attack. Implications for Targeted Nations Any government faced with the possibility that hypersonic missiles would be employed against it—particularly in a decapitating attack— would plan countermeasures, many of which could be destabilizing. For example, countermeasures could include devolution of strategic forces’ command and control so that lower levels of authority could execute a strategic strike, which would obviously increase the risk of accidental strategic war; or strategic forces could be more widely dispersed— a tactic risking greater exposure to subnational capture. An obvious measure would be a launch-on-warning posture—a hair-trigger tactic that would increase crisis instability. Or the target nation could adopt a policy of preemption during a crisis—guaranteeing highly destructive military action. To be sure, such measures could be invoked against threats from current types of missiles.11 But, for nations with effective ballistic mis- sile and/or cruise missile defenses in the time frame when hypersonic missiles might proliferate, the hard choices would be forced when facing hypersonic threats. Advanced nations with adequate resources could take other steps against hypersonic threats. They could strengthen the resilience of their command and control, harden the siting of their strategic forces, and make a deterrent force mobile or sea-based. These tactics may or may not be effective, especially for lesser nations. And they certainly will be expensive—putting them out of reach of some. Even for major powers, the proliferation of hypersonic missiles will create new threats by allowing lesser powers to hold them at risk of effective missile attacks especially against “unhardened” targets, e.g., cities. Over the coming decades, the ability of a lesser nation with a handful of ICBMs to threaten major powers will continue to decrease as wide area missile defenses continue to improve. However, HGVs and HCMs will be more difficult to defend against. Implications for Major Powers The ability of hypersonic missiles to penetrate advanced missile defenses will increase the risks for nations with such defenses. Lesser powers with hypersonic weapons may see these weapons as a deterrent against greater power intervention, and feel free to pursue potentially destabilizing regional agendas. Moreover, lesser nations with hypersonic missiles could affect the force deployments of major powers. As noted above, carrier strike groups might be pushed further out to sea or an intervening power’s regional military bases might become exposed to more effective attacks. The Broader Picture of Increased Risk The ability of hypersonic forces to penetrate defenses and compress decision time could aggravate the instabilities in regions that are already tense—for example, Iran-Israel and North Korea–Japan. Conflicts in these regions could evolve to include major powers aligned on opposite sides. An Israel-Iran conflict, with the United States and much of Europe aligned with Israel and Russia and perhaps China aligned with Iran, would create new paths for escalation to an even-larger conflict. The basic roles of external actors would not necessarily change—the alignments would stay the same—but external powers might suddenly find themselves in a more-unstable situation in which their patron states are increasingly trigger-happy. As noted previously, lesser powers could gain influence over major powers by threatening a hypersonic attack. At the least, lesser powers might be emboldened if they saw themselves as possessing a deterrent against major power intervention. Finally, because hypersonic weapons increase the expectation of a disarming attack, they lower the threshold for military action.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.