Only opening communication on biotech increase’s NATO’s soft power which increases its global diplomatic ability
Cansu Gulec, 2021 “NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century.” MEF University Of Political Science And International Relations, Faculty Member and Underwriter at Anadolu Sigorta, Perceptions (Ankara, Turkey), vol. 26, no. 1, Balgat: Center for Strategic Research, pp. 100–20//AL
The term “public diplomacy” contains the word “diplomacy.” As an instrument of statecraft, diplomacy has long been used as a tool by states in their relations with other states. Although it does not have a commonly agreed-upon definition, diplomacy is generally considered to be the conduct and management of relations, through peaceful means, by and among international actors. The major international actors are states, and diplomacy mainly involves relations among states or between states, international organizations and other international actors. Today, diplomacy continues to be conducted mainly by states, but also includes international and regional organizations, multinational corporations, non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and even individuals. Since the number and types of actors involved in international affairs have expanded, and the interaction among these actors has increased, the agenda and conduct of diplomacy has evolved in line with these developments. The expansion of intergovernmental and regional organizations does not mean the weakening of diplomacy, but rather a shift from traditional state diplomacy to new forms. Especially in today’s world, international and regional organizations generally compete for better visibility, and they consider their image, identity and brand important. As a collective defense and security organization, NATO has defined itself as the security branch of an institution of liberal-democratic norms and values, and has embraced the main principles of the Western world since its foundation in April 1949. Nonetheless, after the end of the Cold War and the disappearance of the Soviet threat, there emerged deep disagreements about the future role of the Alliance. In today’s global information environment, it is apparent that NATO needs to strengthen its communication tools and approaches, consider public audiences and develop its agenda setting according to the current communication challenges and opportunities. Accordingly, the main purpose of this paper is to understand and interpret the evolution of NATO’s public diplomacy efforts, taking into account the opportunities and limitations of today’s globalized environment. Public diplomacy is based on the ability of states and non-state actors to better explain their values to the world. It concentrates particularly on “soft power” tools such as science, art, culture, sports and media that enable interaction between societies. As an organization widely associated with security and defense issues, it is important to understand how NATO responds to the developments of today’s diplomatic As an organization widely associated with security and defense issues, it is important to understand how NATO responds to the developments of today’s diplomatic trends with its public diplomacy and communication activities. Cansu GÜLEÇ 102 trends with its public diplomacy and communication activities. Since technology has changed and evolved, NATO’s communication strategies must adjust to new types of networks and platforms. Having recently celebrated its 70th anniversary, and now in its 72nd year of existence, the Alliance is seeking to develop a contemporary communication policy and to implement it by means of new mechanisms. In this framework, this paper will first present a working definition of the concept of public diplomacy; next, the historical evolution of NATO’s public diplomacy agenda will be evaluated. Then, NATO’s coordination activities, its values, its practical means of communication and their expected impact will be discussed. The aim of this study is to explore the effects of the opportunities and challenges of the contemporary international environment on NATO’s public diplomacy efforts. Definition and Evolution of Public Diplomacy Diplomacy is derived from a Greek word diploma that means an official document or state paper. The Oxford dictionary defines diplomacy as “management of a country’s affairs by its agents abroad and the activity of managing relations between different countries.”1 As a key process of communication and negotiation in world politics and an important policy device used by international actors, the term diplomacy has been given a number of definitions in International Relations discipline. While some definitions associate diplomacy with the activity of engaging in foreign policy, others use the term to refer to a tool or technique of foreign policy. Accordingly, the term is therefore described as “a foreign policy instrument for establishing and developing peaceful relations between the governments of the various states through the use of intermediaries mutually recognized by the respective parties.” 2 As one of the oldest instruments of world politics, diplomacy is seen as an art, specifically the art of managing relations among sovereign actors. Originally, diplomacy was considered an instrument used by states in order to deal with other states. After the establishment of international and regional organizations, these entities too became involved in diplomatic practices. It can be stated that communication is the focus of diplomacy in managing relations among different international actors. In order to create effective communication mechanisms among different players, diplomacy is supported by an established body of rules and practices.3 Since diplomacy is based on the conduct of relationships using peaceful means, these rules and practices should be implemented by governments and other international actors alike. In practice, diplomacy aims to create a favorable image of the global actor. Modern communication, in that sense, functions to shape views and perceptions around the world. NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century 103 In contemporary global environment, although states and governments remain the main actors within the international system, the number and variety of actors, from governments to regional and intergovernmental organizations, multinational corporations and NGOs, have been rapidly expanding. In tandem, the domain and scope of the diplomacy have expanded to involve different sectors that expand beyond traditional high foreign policy issues. Globalization with its the complex web of interdependence has increased the range of negotiations, especially in multilateral meetings.4 Under these circumstances, diplomatic activities require the use of diplomatic tools to directly influence the people of nations as well. In that respect, public diplomacy can be regarded as one of the efficient means of diplomacy in use today. Thanks to this tool, relations between states and global actors progress more peacefully, with inclusion of public opinion alongside that of official representatives. The term ‘public diplomacy’ was first coined in 1965 by Edmund Gullion. According to Gullion, public diplomacy is concerned with the influence of social viewpoints have on the formulation and implementation of foreign policy.5 Indeed, the rise of the concept of public diplomacy is best understood in terms of its relationship with soft power. As mentioned above, with the increase in numbers and types of actors, with the expansion of the subject matter or content of diplomacy, and with the change in the modes, types, and techniques of diplomacy, a new terminology of Public Diplomacy as the language of prestige and international image has brought the concepts like soft power and branding to the nation states’ agenda.6 In IR discipline, power is generally defined as the ability to affect others to obtain desired outcomes. According to Joseph Nye, others’ behavior can be affected in three main ways: threats of coercion; inducements and payments; and attraction that makes others want what you want.7 While discussing the concept, Nye puts a distinction between hard power and soft power.8 The former is achieved through military threat or use, and by economic menace or reward. However, in the 21st century, under the influence of technological developments and globalization, international politics is also changing, and a state cannot address its problems or achieve all of its goals by acting alone. In this environment, it is important to set the agenda and attract others in world politics, as it is not always feasible or desirable to force them to change by means of threats or the use of military or economic weapons. In that sense, ‘soft power’ co-opts people rather than coerces them. Nye coined the ‘soft power’ as “the ability of affect others to obtain the outcomes one wants through attraction rather than coercion or payment.”9 While military force remains the fundamental form of power in international system, abilities like communication, organizational and institutional skills, have also become important instruments in today’s global environment of growing interdependence.10 Diplomacy is a crucial instrument enabling allies to cooperate, and adversaries to resolve conflicts without Cansu GÜLEÇ 104 using force. International actors communicate, influence one another, bargain and adapt their differences through diplomacy. As a key process of communication and negotiation, diplomacy is used as a significant policy instrument by global actors. Today, diplomacy takes place between actors with a wide range of authority, power, tools and impact. A country’s soft power capacity has a crucial role in the success of an actor’s public diplomacy as much as efficacy of its policies; indeed, a country’s political values, culture and foreign policies are important indicators of its soft power.11 Credibility is the significant source of soft power. Since reputation has become one of the main objectives of today’s global actors, they make efforts to increase their credibility around the world. States compete with other states, and also with other actors including media, NGOs, international organizations and other networks in the quest to gain and maintain credibility.12 Public diplomacy is about relationship building. It is about understanding the requirements of other countries, cultures and people; communicating one’s perspectives; correcting misperceptions; and searching areas of common ground.13 Nye defines public diplomacy as an instrument that governments use to mobilize these resources to communicate with and attract the public of other countries, rather than only their governments. Public diplomacy seeks to attract by bringing attention to potential areas of commonality, interest and attraction through broadcasting, supporting cultural initiatives and organizing exchanges.14 The main distinction between traditional and public diplomacy is that the latter involves a much broader group of people on both sides, and a wider set of interests that go beyond those of the government of the day.15 Listening, advocacy, cultural diplomacy, exchange, and international broadcasting are five components of public diplomacy.16 Understanding, planning and engagement are also very important concepts for the establishment of powerful relationships. In the 20th century, public diplomacy was considered a state-based tool used by foreign ministries and other governmental entities to engage and persuade foreign publics with the aim of influencing their governments. Today, public diplomacy has become an instrument used by states, associations of states, and some sub-state and non-state actors to understand cultures, attitudes and behavior; to build and manage relationships; and to influence thoughts and mobilize actions to advance their interests and values.17 A country’s soft power capacity has a crucial role in the success of an actor’s public diplomacy as much as efficacy of its policies; indeed, a country’s political values, culture and foreign policies are important indicators of its soft power. NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century 105 Public diplomacy is a process of creating an overall international image that strengthens a country’s ability in order to achieve diplomatic success. This is also important for “propaganda.” Propaganda is an attempt to influence another country through emotional techniques rather than minds by creating fear, doubt, sympathy, anger or other feelings. In order to change or influence other actors’ opinions, actions or policies, propaganda also operates by means of symbols, such as words, gestures, banners, monuments, music, clothing, etc. Propaganda acquired negative connotations in the 20th century, although it was an effective tool of foreign policy during the First and Second World Wars, as well as the Cold War. During these times, propaganda was associated with manipulating populations at home and abroad.18 Unlike public diplomacy, propaganda is generally not interested in dialogue or any meaningful form of relationship-building.19 The main objective of the propaganda is to influence opinion and behavior of its targeted audience. Although both public diplomacy and propaganda intend to convince people to create a favorable image, the distinction between propaganda and public diplomacy lies in the pattern of communication. In that respect, public diplomacy goes beyond propaganda. It is comprised of what is actually said and done by political figures, as well as practices of promotion and other forms of public relations that are utilized by the business sector.20 In other words, public diplomacy, like propaganda, is about creating influence. However, unlike propaganda, that influence is not a one-way street from the speakers to their target audience. Public diplomacy is perceived as a two-way street with a process of mutual influence, in which the foreign public is seen as an active participant.21 In that sense, the objective of public diplomacy is not propaganda, but building a strategic language of communication based on objective facts and truth. Nye asserts that if public diplomacy degenerates into propaganda, it not only fails to convince, but can undercut soft power. Since soft power depends upon an understanding of the minds of others, an efficient public diplomacy is regarded as a two-way street.22 After the end of the Second World War in 1945, a new type of conflict emerged between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, known as the Cold War. The Cold War was based on a contest of ideologies that divided the world into a bipolar competition characterized by a war of words and the threatened use of nuclear weapons, rather than their actual use. In that era, the idea of nuclear war was ever-present in the minds of the international public. U.S.-Soviet relations became the main global, political agenda, and the erection of the Berlin Wall in 1961 became the symbol of a world separated by the “Iron Curtain.”23 Moreover, in both the U.S. and the Soviet Union, and in their alliance blocs of NATO and the Warsaw Pact, the objective was to convince people that fear of the enemy was genuine, legitimate and justified. This, in turn, would legitimate and justify the need to sustain a Cansu GÜLEÇ 106 nuclear arsenal that would have to be at least equal to that of the other side, although there might never be a use for it. This climate of fear was also played out in the media. Propaganda exploited these fears, and the ‘other side’ had always to be portrayed as aggressive, militaristic and repressive.24 In other words, during the Cold War period, propaganda had a special importance in the foreign policy objectives of the U.S. and the USSR. Both used an organized form of propaganda activities with one-sided, deformed messages, mainly based on their respective ideologies; while the U.S. underlined the material prosperity of the Western world and the desirability of individual freedoms, the USSR emphasized the adverse sides of capitalism. This kind of propaganda sought to stress the admirable side of one’s own country, while denigrating the other side by focusing on specific issues.25 In order to shape public attitudes all over the world toward their respective ideologies, the main tools used by the two superpowers were international broadcasting and radio stations, such as the Voice of America (VOA), Radio Liberty and Radio Free Europe on the American side, and Radio Moscow on the Soviet side.26 The U.S. government developed a number of propaganda channels through the work of the United States Information Agency (USIA), and promoted the universal attractiveness of such American brands as Coca-Cola, Levi jeans and McDonalds, as well as American music and Hollywood films. With the end of the bipolar world, the international environment faced new problems with the rapid expansion in the number and scope of interactions. Contemporary challenges emerged in a new, global communication that had different features from that of the Cold War period. Under these circumstances, it can be claimed that the end of the Cold War made public diplomacy much more important. The spread of democracy, media proliferation and the expansion of global NGOs changed the nature of power and now exert much more influence on the freedom of action of national governments than ever before.27 With these developments, public diplomacy has been used in non-traditional forms with new participants, such as non-state actors; with new sorts of relations between state and non-state actors; and with new goals, such as gaining the support of foreign actors to maintain profound relations rather than using propaganda to influence them. The mechanisms used by these actors to communicate with the world public are supported by new, real-time, global technologies, especially by the Internet. These new technologies have blurred the formerly rigid lines between the domestic and international news spheres. A new emphasis has emerged on people-to-people contact for mutual enlightenment, with international actors playing the role of facilitator. Consequently, instead of top-down messaging, “relationship-building” has become the chief task of the new public diplomacy.28 NATO and Public Diplomacy: Opportunities and Constraints of 21st Century 107 Although public diplomacy is accepted as a two-way relationship, there is no agreement on how to measure its impact and success, as there is no clear variable that shows the political outcome of public diplomacy initiatives. However, the establishment of daily communications with the target audience to explain foreign policy decisions and the enhancement of lasting relationships with target groups, including individuals, may help to build relationships and to foster understanding. Since public diplomacy begins with listening, one of the pathways of understanding the success of its activities is to measure “public opinion” to see the largest impact of the attraction. In that sense, successful public diplomacy projects increase favorable public opinion toward the practitioner actor. Another pathway for understanding an initiative’s success is “agenda setting,” which determines the issues covered in the media or discussed in the target population. “Framing” is yet another pathway that changes the media coverage of the practitioner actor’s foreign policy in the host country.29 In sum, public diplomacy increases people’s familiarity with one’s country or international institution by making them think about it, update their image of it and change negative opinions. It also increases people’s appreciation of one’s country or international institution by creating positive perceptions, getting others to see issues of global importance from the same perspective. Moreover, it also helps strengthen ties by getting people to understand and subscribe to common values. More importantly, it influences people and/ or politicians by making them favored partners.30