Biotech can create more sustainable, efficient, and productive agriculture
Chatterjee 21 (Jayanta Chatterjee, “Developing More Sustainable Global Food Systems Through Agroecology and Biotechnology”, US Department of State, September 30th 2021, https://www.state.gov/dipnote-u-s-department-of-state-official-blog/developing-more-sustainable-global-food-systems-through-agroecology-and-biotechnology/, WC-NAS
Agroecological systems are meant to be highly diverse and biotechnology can help keep them diverse. All breeding techniques depend on diversity, embracing the range of traits found in plants and beyond to develop robust, tasty crops needed to feed our families. Sometimes these traits already exist in the same or related species and need just a little selective breeding to have the new trait(s) incorporated in that crop, as has been done for , since we invented agriculture. In other cases, traits need to be shared between two unrelated (sexually incompatible) species, which is accomplished by genetic modification, both naturally or through engineering. In fact, all plant species naturally have to survive and thrive on dry land. Modern biotechnology is helping diversify our diets and adapt to changing conditions. Purple tomatoes that contain more antioxidants than blueberries, more nutritious and less pungent , a mustard variety with with great health benefits and are just a few examples worth noting.
Agroecology depends on context-specific knowledge. Co-creation and sharing of knowledge have been essential to our understanding of the biology of living organisms and their interactions at the molecular level. Research in molecular biology and its application in the form of biotechnology can help to scientifically validate and improve upon immensely powerful traditional and indigenous knowledge while protecting vulnerable ecosystems and promoting biodiversity. Unfortunately, ideological arguments and unfounded fears often jeopardize scientists’ ability to verify the efficacy, ensure the safety, and demonstrate the benefits of biotechnology.
Improving efficiency is a vital element of agroecology and can be directly strengthened by biotechnology. This could include developing a crop variety that can grow with less water or require significantly less or no chemical pesticide or fertilizer or vegetables or fruits with longer shelf life. It can also include commonly consumed crops supplemented with needed micro/macro-nutrients like , , vitamins (e.g., , as achieved by Golden Rice) and many other such nutrients via through genetic engineering. All of these innovations increase the efficiency of our agricultural systems. A recently published showed that the average amount of herbicide active ingredient applied to the biotech crop area was 26 percent lower and 36 percent lower in terms of environmental impact of the herbicide use as compared to control fields planted with non-biotech crops.
Agroecology places a strong emphasis on human and social values. Increases in agricultural productivity with the use of biotechnology have resulted in better farmer livelihoods. In Vietnam, the farmers earned an additional income of $6.84 to $12.55 for every extra $1 spent on biotech seed relative to conventional seed.
In agroecology, recycling means agricultural production with lower economic and environmental costs. Biodegradable plastic (bio-plastic) is enabled using biotechnology in and increasingly in . There are many other ways biotechnology can help in recycling not just farm byproducts but also polluted water and , including heavy metal and petrochemical pollution.
People, communities, and nations show more resilience when their food systems satisfy all the three pillars of sustainability – economic, social, and environmental. Overemphasis on one or two of these pillars can lead to gaps in achieving food security, community development, or biodiversity objectives, especially in many developing countries and farming communities. Standard organic and regenerative farming practices, which are often equated with agroecological principles, aim to meet resilience and sustainability goals, but there are differences in productivity.
Gaps in productivity have been noted in , particularly important for wheat, with a “yield gaps ranging between 40 percent (Germany) and 85 percent (Italy) of conventional yields.” Yield loss has also occurred in , which has while trying to shift to organic farming. In the United States, are estimated to be $83–$98 higher per acre than their conventional counterparts and costs for organic soybeans are estimated at $106–$125 higher. Buyers must pay a higher price for such organic products. Farmers producing organic crops need to charge proportionately more to compensate for the yield loss. Most farmers and other consumers in the world do not have the luxury to buy more expensive food. Together, agroecology and biotechnology can overcome the gap.