Freedom to pollute and rights to consume guarantee overshoot
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 3-4
This pessimism stems from the unavoidable transition of capitalism from its expanding form to a stationary one under severe scarcity of resources, as “whether we are unable to sustain growth or unable to tolerate it…,it seems beyond dispute that the present orientation of society must change” (1980: 110, original emphasis). Social tensions will inevitably rise when scarcity-propelled stationary or even slow-growing capitalism renders infeasible the usual method of appeasing the lower and middle classes by further deepening the grab into the nature to improve their economic positions, leaving the diminishing of the incomes of the upper echelons of society the only option (1980: 102). Given the widespread belief that “centralized authority will cope with crisis and unrest more ‘successfully’ than less authoritarian structures” and the historic pattern in democracies where “the pressure of political movement in times of war, civil commotion, or general anxiety pushes in the direction of authority, not away from it,” (1980: 128–9, original emphasis) Heilbroner concluded that intolerable socioeconomic strains will eventually exceed the capabilities of representative democracy, leading governments of these societies to resort to authoritarian measures (1980: 106).
Similarly, Ophuls contended that under conditions of ecological scarcity, if individuals are allowed to pursue their self-interest “unrestrained by a common authority,” the result is bound to be “common environmental ruin” (1977: 151). Accordingly:
the individualistic basis of society, the concept of inalienable rights, the purely self-defined pursuit of happiness, liberty as maximum freedom of action, and laissez faire itself all become problematic, requiring major modification or perhaps even abandonment if we wish to avert inexorable environmental degradation and eventual extinction as a civilization. (1977: 152)
To him, the only solution is “a sufficient measure of coercion;” and “democracy as we know it cannot conceivably survive” (1977: 151–2).
In the same vein, Ophuls and Boyan (1992) talked about the crucial role that “ecological mandarins” must play under resource scarcity. Concurring with Robert Dahl’spoint that “a reasonable man will want the most competent people to have authority over the matters on which they are most competent” (Dahl, 1970: 58), Ophuls and Boyan emphasized that “under certain circumstances democracy must give way to elite rule,” and “the more closely one’s situation resembles a perilous sea voyage, the stronger the rationale for placing power and authority in the hands of the few who know how to run the ship” (Ophuls and Boyan, 1992: 209, original emphasis). Given that ecology is esoteric and that only those with talents and training are qualified as specialists, “a class of ecological mandarins who possess the esoteric knowledge” is required to run the “ecologically complex steady-state society” well. Such a society
will not only be ostensibly more authoritarian and less democratic than the industrial societies of today (the necessity of coping with the tragedy of the commons would alone ensure that), but it may also be more oligarchic as well, with full participation in the political process restricted to those who possess the ecological and other competencies necessary to make prudent decisions. (1992: 215)