Deep mitigation will never have popular support AND democracies have to be perfect across every country because pollution is trans-boundary---it’s try-or-die for a global political transition
Dr. Chien-Yi Lu 21, PhD and MA in Government from the University of Texas, Austin, Visiting Scholar at Harvard University, Associate Research Fellow at the Institute of European and American Studies of Academia Sinica, Surviving Democracy: Mitigating Climate Change in a Neoliberalized World, Paperback Edition, 12/13/2021, p. 2-3 [language modified]
The doubt about the ability of democracy to handle climate challenges is palpable from the intellectual Left as well. Eric Hobsbawm offered a threefold explanation for his pessimism. To begin with, many of the strategies needed to avoid climate change would be extremely unpopular and therefore difficult to implement in a democracy. As a result, even as “the impact of human action on nature and the globe has become a force of geological proportions,” “no support will be found by counting votes” for measures required for mitigating these problems. Moreover, given that nature is border-blind, even if voters of some democratic states were sensible, the political mechanisms available to human kind in the 21th century are “effectively confined within the borders of nation-states” and “dramatically ill-suited” to deal with problems lying beyond their range of operation (2007: 113). Finally, democratic national governments are not the only relevant organizational entities that can have an effect on an increasingly globalized and transnational world. “A growing part of human life now occurs beyond the influence of voters, in transnational public and private entities that have no electorates, or at least no democratic ones.” Thus, “[d]emocracy, however desirable, is not an effective device for solving global or transnational problems”(2007: 118).
This wave of academic literature that questions the compatibility of democracy with timely and effective climate mitigation resonates with works dating back to the 1970s that focused on the role of democracy in environmental conservation. In An Inquiry into the Human Prospect, Heilbroner set to answer, in a world plagued by problems such as rapid environmental degradation, “is there hope for man?” Writing in 1974, he highlighted that:
the amount of CO2 in the air is expected to double by the year 2020… sufficient to raise surface temperatures on earth by some 1.5o to 3.0o … bring[ing] sea levels above the level of the land in the populous delta areas of Asia, the coastal areas of Europe, and much of Florida. Long before that it is feared that the rise in temperature would have irreversibly altered rainfall patterns, with grave potential effects. (1980 [1974]: 72)
With the approaching of the depletion of natural resources, Heilbroner expressed deep doubt about the ability of the democratic form of government in ensuring the survival of [hu]mankind.
[C]andor compels me to suggest that the passage through the gantlet ahead may be possible only under governments capable of rallying obedience far more effectively than would be possible in a democratic setting. If the issue for [hu]mankind is survival, such governments may be unavoidable, even necessary. (1980: 130)