The nation-state is a façade meant to cover mass exploitation and the rapid proliferation of smart technology in the form of AI. The 1AC’s call to emerging AI technologies in a quest for absolute rationality is one that obfuscates the role of humans in governmentality and allows algorithmic governance under silicon-based life forms.
Grech 19 - John Grech, University of Malta, Mulit-Faculty Affiliations, Lecturer, Nation : State // Technology : Biology Global Relations in an Age of Emerging Algorithms and the Logic of Late Capitalism (Draft), Academia // eshaan
The damage these nationalist movements are wreaking is amplified when minorities such as Muslims and refugees are singled out in hate-filled discourses in popular media representations that then get immediately reinforced by social media piggy-backing. These encourage disgruntled individuals, acting as supposedly “lone wolfs”, to violently vent their anger against innocent people. Targets including religious worshippers, burka clad women, innocent children, migrant workers, asylum seekers and refugees clearly indicate that these minorities are being scapegoated for grievances against exploitative economic practices employed by the global Western order. But instead of addressing the underlying causes of such grievances, nationalist movements appear to be delivering popular masses into the hands of those controlling production and consumption. With anti-intellectual anti-elitist bitterness driving discourses, popular white nationalist movements during the first two decades of the 21st century reject analysis and reasoning for simplistic blame games exonerating white privilege while blaming those who are different and poorer than themselves. On the whole, contemporary nationalist movements would appear to be better considered as counter-revolutionary, reactionary, or conservative movements that seek to reinforce white privilege rather than address the very real problems that people face. I backgrounded the emergence of these social movements with the changes taking place in the public sphere – the space of Nation – during the 20th century, and particularly the emergence of an ever more sophisticated notion of economy, globalisation, and technology. All these innovations and developments have reduced the scope of the national domain at the same time as opening up a relatively ungoverned international space. There are many, entire communities in fact, disempowered by this process, not least indigenous communities who happen to be situated in the transnational resource rich spheres that global corporates such as miners and loggers decide to exploit ruthlessly. These displaced communities then provide the guest workers, refugees, illegal immigrants, and asylum seekers being targeted by disgruntled whites. Rather than protecting vulnerable individuals and communities, the realigning of State power in the latter part of the 20th century has only exposed the world to greater human exploitation while at the same time as empowering global corporations to take greater advantage of prevailing circumstances and opportunities. In a sense, this has resulted in a new form of global citizen, the multinational corporation, which is arguably now the single biggest player in a world where power, money, and influence intermingle with ever increasing subtlety and speed. Then turning to and mapping technological developments during the last 200 years suggests that the corporation itself may be in the process of being colonised as new ever smarter technology increasingly finds convenient shelter under corporate umbrellas, or, as a geek might see it, adopting corporate skins for new technological processes produced in highly integrated networks by increasingly sophisticated algorithms. If corporations remain the source of greatest power in the new emerging global order, the driving force is still the driven power-lusting individual, who stands atop the corporations’s mast and beckons those who man the oars below to follow his (for CEOs remain predominantly men) direction. However, as the actual work of international corporations is increasingly performed by smart machines, so artificial intelligence is assuming the true locus of power with great alacrity. Under such circumstances, the CEO may think he’s in command, but in actuality he too has become merely an operative for a greater will working surreptitiously behind the corporate’s skyscraped facade. And it is technology which may ultimately prove to be the greatest factor to be reckoned with, not high-flyers like Rupert Murdoch, Mark Zuckerberg, Donald Trump, and Robert Mercer. Mapping the world after 2000 suggests that the real nexus of power is shifting away from the centrality biology once took for granted over social, political, and economic activity and the governmental formations that sought to control them, and towards a new form of organisation realised in and by centrally located intelligent algorithms. While the stratification of society according to human prejudice and predispostion continues to shape the natural and the social worlds there is emerging a new machine like rationality, one that carbon-based life forms have not even started to comprehend. If this alternative new world order is still being assembled, the design, capabilities, and limitations of the system are already deeply embedded in what I’ll term the logic of global capital on the one hand, and the invisible hand of intelligent algorithms on the other. Increasingly today, resources and energies are directed not towards human and other biological requirements, but rather the increasingly hungry but still mysterious rationalities of the global order. The single most potent symbol of global capital is undoubtedly the multinational corporation, whose objective is increasingly “actualised” by and through technology, so it seems predictable that the global economy will increasingly respond to the needs of technology. In the glitzy whirpool of sparkling LEDs, who will notice the ever decreasing political economic interest in and support for sustaining biological life, particularly with the environment and the other ecological disasters that are threatening it with extinction. Enter again the multinational corporation’s heroic CEO, who, striding confidently onto a stage TEDs-like stage, stands proudly like a Caeser, Darius or Alexander Come Lately, and confidently proclaims how “his” latest innovation are about to sweep (what remains of) the world asunder. Fully expecting his company’s ever boldly blinking bottom line to continue streaking, perhaps extending its global reach and dominance to infinity, and with the kindness and generosity of the internet, he is about to tell his audience all about how they too can emulate his successes. Then at the bottom of the screen flashes an immediate alert as the global stock market responds to computer-triggered impulses from around the world. The automated(?) self governing bots have already kicked in and within nanoseconds fortunes capable of feeding the entire human population twice over for a year are made and lost. Meanwhile, unbeknownst to him, little electronic bots are preparing the final touches in the bedroom where our ‘CEO as Hero’ will soon assume his final resting place. As the long laid plans for the smooth transition from the last human CEO to the first fully computer generated New Man (this one comes with a mind made up from a network of electronic synapses) are about to be put into place. Everything has been programmed to ensure that the process will be neat and tidy as well as bloodless, a surgical extraction that neutralises an unstable component without any teetering or shimmering of the delicately balanced system and ensure there is no collateral damage as a result of this long awaited transition. In a world where climate change and mass extinction have brought an end to the viability for carbon based organisms, it has become expedient, rational, logical, economic, as well as fiscally clever for smart silicon-based algorithms (its not called “life” anymore as that doesn’t accurately describe what it really is) to finally assume command over all ongoing processes behind what remains of the Rand Corporation. With the redundancy of carbon-based life both imminent and certain, homo-CEO-erectus.2, the embryo like electronic child in the new Monoverse, is about to claim ascendency as the rightful evolutionary offspring to humanity.