Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The structure of the Nation-state is one that is indistinguishable from the racialized legacy of coloniality. The prerogative of empire is to promote a national memory that seeks the sole preservation of biological life above all resulting in the codification of hegemonic norms and mass structural violence.

Grech 19 - John Grech, University of Malta, Mulit-Faculty Affiliations, Lecturer, Nation : State // Technology : Biology Global Relations in an Age of Emerging Algorithms and the Logic of Late Capitalism (Draft), Academia // eshaan

Mapping Nation, State, and Citizen – The world in 1900 If the world at 1900 had already long been transitioning through a period of radical transformation called “modernisation” (Harvey 1990iii), an important distinction needs to be made between society, state (see Held’s “The Development of the Modern State” in Hall and Gieben 1992, also Barrow 1993), and nationiv (Foucault 2010:326-348). Pierre Clastres (1994, 1998i, 1998ii) identifies society as a broad collective of the people making up any specific community. Modern notions of “society” and “civic society”, as well as “community” and “commonwealth” continue to reflect that notion as they refer specifically to groups of people as distinguished by their collectivity. Society, according to Clastres, contrasts with the modern “Nation-State” at two levels. The State can be said to be the set of modes, means, rules and instruments of governance that society uses to implement and maintain its internal composition, structure, organisation, and identity. The idea of the “Nation”, on the other hand, and in particular the Nation-State since the 16th century (Foucault 2010:332), is a relatively modern invention (Anderson 2016) pointing to a particular form of organisation and structure of internal components, institutions and identities and the various hegemonic orders of governance and discourse these call into being. The emergence of the Nation-State coincides with the conglomeration of larger communities becoming totalised and imagining themselves as both collectively unique and sovereign. The Nation-State seeks to unify both larger groups of people and a variety of geophysical terrains into a singularity and which is again contrasted to the organs of State which are regarded as a body of legal as well as social codes of behaviour and the institutions that police the members of this modern Nation-State and that together order the collective actions and beliefs as well as lives of people in forming such specific modern Nation-State societies. The State’s instruments and apparati are thus essentially involved in, and promote, a particular kind of social order, and the peculiarities such as language, habits, customs, traditions, as well as myths and images that the State holds about itself and that underpin it. Needless to say, the State’s spaces overlap with other imaginary spaces created by the formation of “the Nation” as well as by “society” in order to coalesce the social imaginings of “the People” that underpins them. A first level distinction can be made with the formation of the Nation-State. Foucault (2010) charts a history of the evolution of the French Nation, analysing the process of subjectification underpinning the invention of modern citizenship (Beck 2006, Chambers 1995, Hennerz 2000, Ianelli & Mossaro 2017, Sennett 1986, Stevenson 2001, 2003).v Commencing with a series of traits and characteristics, the first object of the Nation-forming project is to subject people to certain normative forms and rationalisations. The practice of national identity starts in a series of internalised as well as external State imposed actions. To be French, an individual must not only demonstrate a “native” command of (standardised Parisian) French but also to trade in a range of currencies that distinguish and connect to myths and ideas of the French Nation. In addition to language, markers include attitudes, food, culture and dress, education, as well as subservience to the State’s legal, educational, and taxation regimes and regulatory legislative instruments. People could still consider themselves Poitier-ians, or Avignon-ese, or Strasbourg-ians, but they had first to think of themselves as French. So being “French” became synonymous for a unified world shared by those living in a specified geographical area and unified by certain beliefs and practices which became generalised by themselves and others. It is ideas of “French” and “France” that bind people together (Barthes 1981:116-117). In Imagined Communities (2006), Benedict Anderson investigates the origins and spread of nationalism and the emergence of modern Nation-States. Anderson wants to understand why individuals form a relationship of “horizontal” “comradeship” and “fraternity” so strong that it makes “possible, over the past two centuries, for so many millions of people, not so much to kill, as willingly die for such a limited imagining” of themselves as conceived by the Nation’s apparatus. The bond that nationalism engenders is limited, as Anderson sees it, because those who mostly died in defending their nation did so even though the benefits afforded to them by their State was minimal. For Anderson, the power of the privileged classes to convince more impoverished and disadvantaged members of the broader community to not just willingly give up their pursuit of their own interests, but also their lives, to defend a system which oppresses them seems irrational. Anderson is drawn to conclude that inventions like the “national imagination” and “national memory” (as well as a “national amnesia”) help to project generic notions and ideas on to individuals and on those around them and gain and grant a sense of singular unity, affection, and belonging (Anderson 2006: 1-7). Anderson wants to understand how and why nationalism enables people to feel “closer” to people who, in many respects, are their oppressors while seeking to kill others who do not have any impact on their lives whatsoever. He wants to understand how nationalism bifurcates the world between those who share a sense of an inside populated by (imagined) connectivity, loyalty, relatedness, and identification from an exteriorised swathe of others (aliens, foreigners, or simply unknown strangers) but with whom – from a relative subjectivity that more closely reflects their own than that of their masters – such individuals respective everyday realities share more in common with the enemies of the Nation-State. Moving further from the “centre” of the world at 1900, Edward Said’s Orientalism (Penguin 1995) glimpses life beyond Europe and of someone living in a colonial State and the dehumanised subjectivity that creates (Fanon 2001: 13). A well-to-do, educated native of Algiers or Martinique or Vietnam may have felt French but, as Frantz Fanon himself learns while studying in Paris, being French is not the same as being a French colonial. “The first thing which the native learns” writes Fanon as a result of his learning his ‘lesson’ in Paris, “is to stay in his place, and not to go beyond certain limits. […] The settlers’ world is a hostile world, which spurns the native, but at the same time, is a world of which he is envious” (Fanon, 2001: 40-41). So Fanon describes the inner conflicts and contradictions created by colonisation in the colonised. The point I’m making is this; Be it coloniser or native, the object of the State is to control people and maintain the existing hegemonic order. From the State’s perspective, the body of a native is no less significant than the body of the coloniser, both must be disciplined as well as enabled, for social order depends on every individual playing their respective part to perpetuate the colonial world. As long as either have the capacity to threaten colonial rule, the State must discipline, reinforce and reward individual behaviour. Even in colonial States, the body of the individual is the focus of State attention. The imaginary slice of life at 1900 I am trying to portrayvi suggests that although there are clear stratifications in forms of identity and propriety attributed to individuals depending on colour, gender, race, inheritance, and social status, the individual remains the crucial pivot around which both the Nation and the State organise themselves. Individuals also retained a central role in the formation and ongoing (re)production of society. This centrality made the individual the target and the goal of society’s sometimes perfunctory moves towards community. In contrast to society, the Nation-State, on the other hand, asks more of individuals than mere participation in daily routines of social renewal. Nation-States demand the individual’s subjectification to a universal rule of law, coded rules that reinforce the Nation-State’s hegemony. The willingness of the State to resort to violence (see Agamben 2005, Benjamin’s “Critique of Violence” in Eiland and Jennings 2006, Clastres’ “Of Ethnocide” 1994, and Foucault 2010) to enforce the individual’s subjectification indicates both the seriousness of the State’s intention to unify the Nation as well as its determination to subdue threatening, oppositional, counter-hegemonic rationalities and ideologies. If the State’s role can be thought of as a servant that maintains discipline and reduce the threat of change, the Nation, in contrast to both society and the State, appears to establish and unify a singular notion of identity – the formation of “the people”. Thus while the world in 1900 subjectified individuals according to and depending on where they stood in the global stratifications of different States and Nations, the individual’s role in the formation and renewal of society and the social bonds and cultural relations to establish and maintain social order remained both central and necessary. Even marginal, insignificant individuals played a crucial role even if only as the subject of discipline, or, less commonlt, as a vehicle for social change and re/evolution. So the nature of society at the beginning of the 20th century still relied on and reflected the centrality of individuals and communities. That centrality was characteristic of both modern as well as traditional society during the first half of the 20th century and was reflected in the highest form of human organisation at the time, the Nation-State. So, it can be said, the institutions making up the Nation-State were entirely motivated by and responded to the biological imperatives that they were established to facilitate. Secondly, the Nation-State had, by 1900, become the highest singular authority that individuals and collectives could recourse to in either asserting their assumed rights or in defence against incursions upon those rights by others. Just as individuals were the focus of the NationState’s attention, so the Nation-State became the focus and at the same time most powerful arbiter and guarantor of individuals interests, welfare, safety, and what gradually became regarded as rights. As long as the individual’s biology, that is, the quanta of sentient existence and not just the chemical and molecular processes that conventions of biology often prescribe, remained central to society, so the Nation-State directed itself at serving and responding to individuals biological essentials. Nowhere was this more evident than in production. Since time immemorial, production essentially focused on satisfying the material, psychological, environmental, cultural, and physical needs and so promote individual wellbeing and benefit society as a whole. The welfare of specific individuals and the classes from which they came, such as slaves and colonial natives, the labouring classes, women, and children, not to mention the preservation of a hospitable environment for people to exist in, were, however, elaborated in and by the means and modes of production. While the logics of production attributed higher and lower priorities to individuals depending on their status, the object of the Nation-State remained focused on maintaining the interests of living individual organisms.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.