NATO action is constructive of Empire – it relies on discourses of legitimated war which lays the universal values necessary for imperial biopolitical control
Kuus ‘7 (Merje Kuss; professor of geography at University of British Columbia. “’Love, Peace, and Nato’: Imperial-Subject Making in Central Europe” https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1467-8330.2007.00521.x 25 April 2007) // ELog
NATO enlargement involves a two-fold legitimation. It rests firstly on making NATO everyday and unremarkable, and secondly on making it morally good. The effect is one of simultaneous banalization and glorification of NATO. The alliance is on the one hand made so common sense as to be boring—below political debate. It is on the other hand made existential and essential—above debate. The first side of this coin of legitimation—that of banalization—is a key feature of geopolitical discourses. These discourses rely not as much on formal arguments about science and strategy as on the notion of common sense (O’Tuathail and Agnew 1992:193). Their political success stems not from their deep meaning, but from their dailiness and banality. The militarization of political debate and everyday life is made possible in significant measure by domesticating military power as everyday (Cohn 1987; Lutz 2001). The military–industrial complex, or the military–industrial–media–entertainment network in Der Derian’s (2001) more precise terminology, is made to appear both virtual and virtuous, both clean and good. Its material infrastructure and material effects are thereby erased from political debate. This is clearly the case with NATO. Military terminology is all but absent from discussions of the world’s most powerful military alliance (Sidaway 2001:602). It has thus become acceptable and indeed common to speak of war— such as the one in Kosovo in 1999—as an “operation” concerned with “building civil society” (see also Feldman 2003; Sidaway 2003). Yet as Arendt (1964:288) famously pointed out over 40 years ago, banal is not synonymous with benign. Evil can arise not from sinister intent but from unthinking adherence to the taken-for-granted (see also Billig 1995; Gregory 2004). To speak of the banality of the military–industrial complex, then, is not to imply triviality, but to specify its mechanisms of operation and legitimation. It is to underscore the “set of silent ethical assertions that pre-organize explicit ethicopolitical discourses” (Shapiro 1997:16)—in this case the assertions that enable discussions of NATO to revolve around the notions of right, peace, culture, and values. As Enloe (2004:220) points out, most of the militarization of social life, a process in which social practices gain value and legitimacy by being associated with military force, occurs in peacetime. To understand the dynamics of this process, then, we need to look at the mundane rather than the spectacular, the civilian rather than the military. The second aspect of the legitimation of NATO—the constitution of military power as good—is a key part of what Hardt and Negri (2000:9) call the new inscription of authority. Today’s global power relations, they argue, are based not on force itself, but on the capacity to present force as being in the service of right and peace. These relations rely on an “ethico-political dynamic”, which envelops the entire space of what it considers civilization—a boundless, universal space (ibid.:11). This ethico-political dynamic lays the foundation for a renewed notion of just war: no longer an activity of defense or resistance, but one that is justified in itself, by the appeal to essential values and justice. This just war combines two elements: first, the legitimacy of the military apparatus insofar as it is ethically grounded, and second, the effectiveness of military action to achieve the desired order and peace. The Empire’s powers of intervention do not begin directly with its weapons of lethal force but rather with its moral instruments (Hardt and Negri 2000:35). They are based on the production of the normative space of imperial right. Intervention becomes juridically legitimate only when it is inserted into existing international consensuses. The first task of the Empire is “to enlarge the realm of the consensuses that support its own power” (ibid.:15).2 The military complex becomes a key part of the production of moral good (see also Flint and Falah 2004 for an in-depth discussion of the concept of just war). Hardt and Negri conceptualize this new notion of right as a substantively new phenomenon. In the earlier disciplinary society, they argue, social power was effected through administrative apparatuses that produce and regulate customs and habits. In today’s society of control, in contrast, mechanisms of command become ever more “democratic”, ever more immanent in the social field. The normalizing apparatuses of disciplinary power do not simply intensify. In addition, and in contrast to disciplinary society, social control today extends well outside the structured sites of social institutions through flexible and fluctuating networks (Hardt and Negri 2000:23). Power has become biopolitical in that it extends throughout the depths of the consciousnesses and bodies of the population. The new notion of right, then, is not simply imposed on localities and subjects from the outside. It is rather part and parcel of the very production of locality and subjectivity (Hardt and Negri 2000:30). According to Hardt and Negri (2004:13), security is a form of biopower in the sense that it is aimed not only at controlling a population but producing and reproducing all aspects of social life.3 It is effective if it is an integral vital function of individuals. The movement from defense to security represents a shift from a reactive and conservative attitude to an active and constructive one (Agamben 2002). The normative space of imperial right is produced by a variety of bodies in the civil society, including the news media and especially non-governmental organizations (NGOs). Because these institutions are not run by governments, they are easily presented as acting on the basis of moral or ethical imperatives (ibid.:36). This dynamic is especially visible in the current “war on terror”, which popular legitimation centers on the concepts of identity and universal moral values (Dalby 2005). It is made possible by constructing military solutions as morally just (Flint and Falah 2004). Al Quaeda’s motives are identified as cultural and moral and so are the “western” or US responses.4 As such bundling up of security, culture, and moral values has moved to the centre stage of political legitimation since the terrorist attacks of September 2001, we need to closely investigate how the process works (Agamben 2002). Hardt and Negri overemphasize the novelty of imperial subjectmaking. They downplay the much longer processes of the construction of geographical and geopolitical knowledge, in which the notion of universal values has occupied a central position at least since the Age of Exploration (see Agnew 1998; Mignolo 1995). They also under-estimate the spatiality of power by conceptualizing imperial right as essentially a non-territorial universalizing process that encompasses the whole globe regardless of the current spatial configurations.5 Their argument’s utility for the present analysis stems from its focus on a key mechanism by which hegemonic power works today: not against but through the creative efforts of individuals. NATO enlargement exemplifies this mechanism. Whereas national security discourses still invoke the negative notion of threat, however “soft” and however indirect, NATO enlargement discourse invokes only positive categories—values, democracy, openness. NATO, like Empire, is a “machine for universal integration. It does not fortify its boundaries to push others away, but rather pulls them within its pacific order” (Hardt and Negri 2000:198). NATO is central to the institutional structure through which military intervention is organized and legitimized today, and it is continually bolstering its technical capabilities to operate globally. Its enlargement discourse is moralistic, affective, and adamantly non-territorial, as it emphasizes not territories but universal values. NATO enlargement can therefore illuminate in rich empirical detail how the production of imperial right and the militarization of social life work on a daily basis.