Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff embraces system hospice, starting from the assumption that modernity is irredeemable and reform thru the system is impossible

De Andreotti, 15 (Vanessa de Oliveira Andreotti, Professor of Education at University of British Columbia, “Mapping interpretations of decolonization in the context of higher education”, accessed: 9-11-15, http://decolonization.org/index.php/des/article/view/22168/18470, tab)

Analyses within the soft-reform space call for a form of inclusion or access that does not require major shifts, whereas systemic analyses within the radical-reform space demand a more drastic interruption of business-as-usual. This interruption entails transforming the way power and resources are accumulated by current beneficiaries, in order to make space for difference and for the redistribution of resources, opportunities, and symbolic value. Thus, radical-reform critiques are often characterized by a fragmentation in the analyses of oppression (single-issue politics) and a strong normative stance focused on ‘fixing’ an aspect of the system (to make it work for marginalised subjects), which ultimately leads to an expansion of the existing, modern system, rather than enabling alternatives to it. What distinguishes beyond-reform spaces from radical-reform spaces is the recognition of ontological dominance (largely absent in the radical-reform space). Analyses in this space connect different dimensions of oppression and reject the idea that the mere addition of other ways of knowing (through a critique of epistemological dominance) will ultimately change the system, as dominance is exercised primarily through the conditioning of particular ways of being that, in turn, prescribe particular ways of knowing. In other words, the incorporation of multiple ways of knowing (grafted onto the same hegemonic ontological foundation that is left unexamined) through strategies of equity, access, voice, recognition, representation, or redistribution, does not change ontological dominance (see also Coulthard, 2014). Within the ‘beyond-reform’ space, the modern system itself is perceived as inherently violent, exploitative, and unsustainable. Modernity’s myriad oppressions are understood to be interlinked. Critiques made from within this space recognize modernity as irrecoverable; that is, they recognize the limits of even the most radical transformations that do not disrupt the underlying modern system and its grammars and logics. This does not preclude ‘beyond-reform’ advocates from valuing the importance of non-ontological transformations as necessary and important in the short-term, but merely advocating for expansion or radical transformation of the system (e.g. through equity, access, voice, recognition, representation, or redistribution) is insufficient. This form of critique tends to lead to one of three primary responses: system walk out, hacking, or ‘hospicing’. System walk out (alternatives ‘with guarantees’) enunciates a commitment to develop alternatives to modernity that will not reproduce its violences. Alternative communities and epistemologies are developed or reclaimed in spaces that may be external or marginal to mainstream institutions, either as supplementary, transitional, or wholesale alternatives. While ‘walking out’ often leads to remarkably creative and generative spaces, these spaces may nonetheless reproduce at least some of the same problems as modernity, as they are still broadly situated within its teleological grammar, particularly in its dialectically structured desire for an uncontaminated ‘outside’. This focus on alternatives ‘with guarantees’ tends to support the same affective investments (e.g. in fixed teleologies, normativity, consensus, and innocence) and can lead to the foreclosure of the complexities and complicities that arise in the making of alternatives. System hacking involves creating spaces within the system, using its resources, where people can be educated about the violences of the system and have their desires re-oriented away from it. This requires ‘playing the game’ of institutions at the same time that rules are bent to generate alternative outcomes. This strategy can also be remarkably creative and generative; however, it can be difficult to recognize when one is ‘hacking’ the system or ‘being hacked’ by it. In addition, like system walk outs, the risk of reproducing modernity’s violence precisely when one is trying to move beyond it remains high as the success of initiatives is measured in 28 V. de Oliveira Andreotti et al identifiable outcomes, and identities may become scripted around vanguardist heroism that inadvertently recentres individuals. In contrast to system walk out, system ‘hospicing’ recognizes that although ultimately new systems are necessary, alternatives articulated from within modernity’s frames will tend to reproduce it. In identifying modernity’s metaphysical enclosures, hospicing problematizes the desire to embrace or reject modernity as a form of desire where modern subjects demand the world conform to our will (Silva, 2014). Instead, hospicing would entail sitting with a system in decline, learning from its history, offering palliative care, seeing oneself in that which is dying, attending to the integrity of the process, dealing with tantrums, incontinence, anger and hopelessness, ‘cleaning up’, and clearing the space for something new. This is unlikely to be a glamorous process; it will entail many frustrations, an uncertain timeline, and unforeseeable outcomes without guarantees. Our definition of hospicing entails three different insights. One, that the modern global capitalist system is unsustainable, and that it is already collapsing. Two, that our current languages, identities and sense-making are inescapably historically connected to it. Three, that we need to be properly taught by the system’s successes and failures by facing its death and attending to its affliction rather than turning our back or attempting to murder it before it is ready to go. Hospicing enacts a willingness to learn enough from the (re)current mistakes of the current system in order to make different mistakes in caring for the arrival of something new. Going through the pains of this death, and recognizing we have been both bewildered and enchanted by the mythology of the Enlightenment, may be the only way we c an really understand the depth of modernity’s limits (within us) and recognize its real gifts. Hospicing demands a critique that is self-implicated rather than heroic, vanguardist or ‘innocent’. It demands a kind of courage that is un-neurotic (not invested in self-affirmation): a kind of courage that helps us to look the bull in the eye, to recognize ourselves in the bull, and to see the bull as a teacher, precisely when it is trying to kill us. In practice, this means that experimenting with alternatives is perceived as important not for generating predetermined solutions, but rather as a means to be taught by the successes and failures of the experimentation process. These teachings are indispensible for exploring the depths of the existing system, and for learning to discern between its poisons and its medicines. In this space, the effects of violence and pain are attended to; at the same time that there is also an acute attention to the roots and mechanisms of the disease so that its death leaves a legacy of prudence that grounds the emergence of something radically new and potentially wiser. We represent this possibility as a question mark in our fourth space where other modes of existence grounded on different cosmologies operate. The question mark indicates that these are unintelligible to those entrapped in the metaphysics of modernity (which does not mean they are separate from our experience, or beyond meaning and understanding).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.