Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Asking for the ballot is a double turn.

Rita Dhamoon 05. Professor at the Department of Political Science in the University of British Columbia. “Beyond Inclusion Politics: Reconstituting the Political Order”. 6/2/5. https://www.cpsa-acsp.ca/papers-2005/Dhamoon.pdf. GJII

Furthermore, inclusion discourses can potentially relativize and trivialize differences (Lee & Cardinal, 1998: 226). The CAPAR goes to some length to avoid this. It cites the Ethnic Diversity Survey which found that nearly 50 percent of Blacks reported discrimination or unfair treatment compared to 33 percent of South Asians and 33 percent of Chinese respondents (Heritage, 2005: 8); it acknowledges that in exploring “the different experiences of ethno-racial and ethno-cultural groups and to provide meaningful statistics on racism, race must be compared with other factors such as gender, age, education and income” (Heritage, 2005: 9); and it specifically identifies the value of intersectional analysis because of the particular “issues affecting Aboriginal women, racial minority women, and migrant, immigrant and refugee women” (Heritage, 2005: 27). Yet despite these measures, it is striking to note that the plan conflates racism with colonialism and anti-Semitism, thereby undermining the ability to address differences. Whilst the plan acknowledges particular kinds of experiences -- such as employment discrimination against ethnic groups, disproportionate numbers of Indigenous people in prisons, and attacks against Jewish synagogues -- it does not name these as racism, colonialism and anti-Semitism. Thus even though the plan lays out a working definition of racism (Heritage, 2005: 7-9), it fails to identify the differing forms of racialized, colonial and anti-Semitic experiences. This is important, for instance, because of the ways in which Indigenous people are addressed in the CAPAR without reference to historical and on-going colonial legislative acts that are racially oppressive, including for the example the Indian Act which continues to be used by the state to control status determination and band membership.4 Though Indigenous peoples are racialized in ways similar to people of colour through white supremacy, the attempted erasure of Indigenous bodies, knowledge, resources and land is distinct from the racism faced by people of colour in Canada. As Lee and Cardinal state, “By not recognizing hierarchies in categorical difference, strategies of inclusion contribute to the erasure of inequality by pluralizing differences and ignoring power and resource differentials” (Lee & Cardinal, 1998: 226). The role of power should be critical in any analysis of racialized, ethnic and/or cultural identities and relations, and yet is strangely neglected in the CAPAR. Instead, the plan articulates inclusion through a discourse of collective unity. One of the three objectives of the CAPAR is “to strengthen social cohesion through antiracism measures” (Heritage, 2005: 10). The conclusion reiterates this point in which it is stated that the priorities of the CAPAR “enhance the value of Canadian citizenship by strengthening our social bonds, and making our shared values more relevant to contemporary life in Canada” (Heritage, 2005: 56). In particular the plan highlights the role of Citizenship and Immigration Canada in integrating immigrants. Whilst the framing of integration presents ways to include otherwise excluded peoples, the discourse of inclusion masks the ways in which integration itself can be wrought with conformist and assimilationalist tendencies. Whilst the necessity to develop bonds of social cohesion and shared values and citizenship should be an important feature of the political order, mechanisms of inclusion can also potentially erase differences that some groups want to maintain. Many Indigenous leaders made this argument following the 1969 White Paper which suggested that erasing the requirement of status for Indians would bring this group of Indigenous people to the same level of citizenship as other Canadians. As Indigenous activist and scholar Harold Cardinal (1969) argued shortly after the White Paper was published, while First Nations people have historically been excluded because of their status they also depend on their legal status as ‘Indians’ to assert treaty rights and make claims of self-determination.5 Inclusionary goals, in other words, presume that integration is desirable but without fully accounting for the fine line between integration and assimilation. That is not to say that the CAPAR promotes a model of forced assimilation. Rather, the plan expresses the desire for inclusion through what Richard Day calls ‘seductive integration’ (2000: 9). Day argues that dominant groups create a society in which excluded Others are implicitly seduced into dominant norms, values and structures because their chances of political, economic and social success are dependent on integrating (or being included) into the core. As such, inclusion is framed for the benefit of racialized Others rather than as a way to demand forced conformity; if ethnic and racial minorities become included into mainstream society through participation in dominant practices and structures, or so the argument goes, they will reap material benefits. This not only overestimates the potential of inclusion to eliminate repressive and productive forms of power (where one outcome is racism), but it also underestimates the ways in which inclusion enables the state to manage the ‘strangeness’ of Others through indirect measures. Put differently, inclusion does not necessarily end racism and at the same time it allows the state to regulate racialized Others by bringing those on the outside into the core.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.