Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their securitization of climate change is the continuation of a long line of failed militaristic policies, only embracing a feminist perspective can we truly mitigate their impacts

Nagel 15(Joane, Social and Behavioral Sciences – Sociology Professor, “Gender, Conflict, and the Militarization of Climate Change Policy”, CS)

In their 2007 report, National Security and the Threat of Climate Change, a group of prominent retired U.S. military advisors described climate change as a “threat multiplier” facing many countries in the world, especially the United States. They cataloged dangers to national security from climate changerelated flooding, drought, extreme weather, disease, famine, and environmentally forced migration. The report’s focus on dangers and conflicts reflected the institutional perspective and interests of its all-male military advisory board. They recommended strategic planning to defend against the threat of climate change. They did not call for action on the causes of climate change such as the reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. The militarization of climate change, by defining it primarily as a security threat, represents one of several ways in which climate change policy is gendered. The international failure to respond effectively to climate change also can be understood by analyzing the gender dimensions of the institutions that dominate international climate change research, planning, and negotiations. In her 2010 Nature article, “Call in the Women,” feminist geographer Susan Buckingham argued that gender imbalance is a major reason for the ongoing stalemate in international efforts to curb greenhouse gas emissions. Starting in 1995, international environmental leaders have gathered each year at United Nations Conference of Parties (COP) meetings around the world to settle on a response to escalating changes in the global climate. In the past twenty years of annual COP meetings, these mainly male negotiators have not managed to produce any significant binding agreements to reduce the rate and scale of climate change. Negotiators’ inability to craft an international climate change agreement has persisted in the face of mounting scientific evidence and wide consensus about the dangerous consequences of climate change to the planet’s biosphere and human societies. Critics of negotiators’ ineffectiveness typically fault the economic interests of carbon emitting countries in maintaining a global energy and economic system that benefits them. They seldom attribute COP meeting failures to the enduring power of gender privilege. Buckingham, however, sees a more gendered COP landscape marked by the gendered culture and approach of male negotiators. To bolster this critique, she reports consistent research findings supporting improved decision making in economic and political settings where women are included in adequate numbers. Not surprisingly, this research is ignored by predominately male representatives who dominate the ranks of COP representatives (women comprise less than thirty percent of COP delegates). This is despite the fact that in 1995 the United Nations called for including women in all levels of environmental decision making. Buckingham’s conclusion: “there is enough evidence now to justify increasing women’s involvement in decision-making on climate change. We should do so without delay.” It is not simply their gender that accounts for the poor track record of the mainly male negotiators; it also is the interests that they represent. If women representatives replaced some or all of the men at these meetings, would agreements be reached, GHG levels reduced, and the dangers of climate change averted? It would be an interesting experiment, and simply on the ethical grounds of gender equity, it warrants mandating equal gender representation at all COP meetings and other United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)–sponsored bodies and activities, including the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Gender parity, however, would not change the national and economic interests dominating COP meetings. Whether they are men or women from the global North or South, representatives at COP meetings typically represent elite interests. Women might bring a different experiential and gendered perspective to the negotiations, but they still would face institutional resistance to change, especially by a UN system historically run by elite men. This is partly because gender is not only a feature of individuals. Gendered cultures, practices, and networks characterize organizations as well.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.