Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Modern war uses narratives of beautiful and helpless women to justify atrocious acts, only a feminist critique of war theory can reveal the deep flaws in IR theory

Sjoberg 08(Laura, American feminist scholar of international relations and international security and Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London, “Why Just War Needs Feminism Now More Than Ever”, CS)

Feminists argue that the construction of women as ‘beautiful souls’ at once serves as moral justification for war-fighting stronger than the underlying jus ad bellum standards (protecting innocent women and children), obscures women’s actual suffering in war (given the moral reliance of war-fighting on women’s being shielded from the actions and effects of war), and props up gender subordination more generally (by limiting women’s capabilities inside war and supporting gender differentiation in citizenship status and other social roles). As such, the just war tradition’s reliance on gendered ideal-types in the non-combatant immunity principle has real negative impacts, both inside and outside of the making of war. The gender subordination that just war theory perpetrates is another problem to add to the laundry list of difficulties that the tradition has as it looks for current applicability. Not only does a gender-based critique of the just war tradition demonstrate gender bias in the just war tradition, but also reveals that just war theory often fails on its own terms because of that gender bias (Sjoberg, 2006b). This demonstrates that just war’s difficulties cannot be solved by simply adding new rules for new sorts of war; broader problems exist. A feminist critique of just war theory reveals important ways forward, and suggests broader solutions. This paper argues that a gender-based critique and reformulation of just war theory can suggest an agenda for the reinvention of the tradition in a sharper, more relevant form. Before proceeding to that reformulation, perhaps a note on the method by which one draws gender-based critique is appropriate. Feminist scholars study global politics through ‘gendered lenses’, where gender as an evaluative and constitutive variable frames their analysis of global politics (Peterson and Runyan, 1999). When looking through gendered lenses, feminists are concerned with the influence of gender subordination in global politics and interested in paths to redress that subordination. As Jill Steans notes, ‘feminist critical theorists are trying to find a way forward which retains both gender as a category of analysis and retain the historical commitment to the emancipator project in feminism’ while addressing broader policy issues across state and cultural boundaries (Steans, 1998, 29). A feminist critique of the just war tradition, then, looks for locations of gender subordination within the foundations of just war theory, and then uses gender as a category of analysis to search for emancipatory alternatives.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.