Feminist perspective solves the most serious impacts of war
Sjoberg 08(Laura, American feminist scholar of international relations and international security and Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London, “Why Just War Needs Feminism Now More Than Ever”, CS)
Through gendered lenses, we can see a number of guidelines for the reinterpretation of these standards. First, a feminist perspective would argue that the question of just cause is one that should not be decided by any one actor or from any one epistemological perspective or political standpoint. Instead, in keeping with strong objectivity, justice needs to be considered dialogically. Additionally, feminists’ interest in empathy would mean that potential belligerents should, in the dialogue about the meaning of justice, attempt not only to comprehend but also to emotionally identify with the positions of the other actors in the dialogue. An ethic of care demands that the planning and fighting of wars be done with a special concern for the plight of those traditionally marginalized in social and political life. A care-based politics of war-making demands that states and/or other political actors refrain from fighting wars that will not mainly impact those people against whom those actors have just cause. It also suggests that calculations of the ‘civilian damage’ of war include a broader range of human insecurities, including issues like unemployment, debt, transportation damage, health infrastructure damage, and the like (Tickner, 1992). Along the same lines, a gender perspective suggests a broader group of situations that just war theory should be used to analyze. These include any situations where conflict is likely to cause mass human insecurity, including economic sanctions, civil conflicts, and/or religious or cultural oppression. The source of these observations is feminist work on the continuity of violence in international politics. Twenty years ago, Betty Reardon called the international political arena a ‘war system’, indicating that constant political violence, economic deprivation, gender and cultural subordination, and environmental destruction are a structural feature of people’s (and especially women’s) lives in global politics (1985). Chris Cuomo followed up, arguing that war ‘is not just an event’ and instead can be seen as a continuous property of global politics (1996). These insights demonstrate that a feminist approach to war, and its moral consequences, differs substantively from conventional just war approaches. As such, a feminist perspective suggests several foundational principles for a reformulated just war tradition, less totalizing but more honest about its capacities, less deterministic but more prepared to deal with the contingency of today’s international conflicts: (1) A dialogue about the meaning of justice for just cause, inclusive of a broad array of international actors and aiming at building consensus through empathetic cooperation. (2) Emotional identification as a major component of international relations in times of conflict. (3) An ad bellum prescription that an actor should not engage a war, no matter how just the cause, that cannot be fought mainly against those who have created the just cause. (4) Special attention to the impacts of war on those traditionally marginalized in social and political life, especially women. (5) A new, more sensitive principle of discrimination, which acknowledges the terrible civilian damages caused by war, and calculates not only the immediate effects of guns and bombs, but also the lasting human effects of conflict and violence. (6) A modified, ‘war system’ approach to those situations that should be covered by just war analysis that covers the most intense sources of humaninflicted human insecurity, even outside of the traditional confines of ‘war’.