Older models and justifications for waging war no longer hold up, a feminist lens provides these theories with empathy and morality, making conflict increasingly avoidable
Sjoberg 08(Laura, American feminist scholar of international relations and international security and Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London, “Why Just War Needs Feminism Now More Than Ever”, CS)
In a world where there are as many just war theories as there are just war theorists, yet massively destructive wars take place, just war theory needs both focused moral priorities and some way to regulate meaning without excluding perspectives. Because excluding perspectives is likely to increase, rather than decrease, the number and intensity of international conflicts; just war cannot regulate meaning either by imposing some actors’ meanings on others or by giving way to absolute relativism. Instead, an approach to meaning that is both communicative and empathetic has a number of distinct advantages. First, it demands that parties in a conflict listen to their opponents’ and third parties’ understandings of the meaning of justice. Listening can be a first step to overcoming conflicts. Second, it requires that parties reconsider the claimed universalism of their understandings of global politics. This could inspire less myopic understandings of security states, transgressing realism as a selffulfilling prophecy. Third, the element of emotional identification adds an important additional layer to listening. In empathetic cooperation, actors not only have to ‘hear’ other states’ positions, but are also asked to attempt to understand on rational and emotional levels. Finally, attention to the political margins is important, and long-neglected, in the analysis of the ethics of war. The 21st century has seen a number of international political conflicts that are increasingly violent and increasingly difficult to analyze using traditional just war standards. Where just war theory used to be able to find a state that made war, the war on terrorism has made obvious the relevance of non-state actors to war-making. Where just war theory used to be able to talk about noncombatant identification and immunity, guerilla wars, air wars, and wars against an unidentified enemy have complicated the discrimination principle. Where just war used to be able to confine itself to the cultural context of the belligerents, an increasingly global world sees conflicts between cultural contexts. In such an international political atmosphere, political leaders need an ethical compass to war-making and war-fighting now more than ever. In the face of this increasing need for a moral compass, political leaders find a just war tradition that struggles with being outdated, risks susceptibility to political manipulation, lacks clarity in conceptual understandings of justice and war, and entrenches gender subordination in global politics. Just war needs a unifying motivating morality that allows for both diversity and decisionmaking. The feminist reformulated just war principles contained in this article provide the groundwork for such a motivating morality. Just war needs a way to adapt to cultural pluralism; feminist empathy constructs a workable dialogue. Just war needs a way to adapt to the constant challenge of technological change; feminisms center their moral thinking on the lives of individuals and thus provide a framework for thinking about new technologies. Just war needs a way to pay attention to the structural violence and human security effects of infrastructural attacks and aerial wars. Feminisms’ focus on political marginality helps just war to see this suffering, and to prioritize it in ethical evaluation. From the top levels of strategic policy-making to the margins of political life, people need just war theory now more than ever. Because people need just war theory, just war theory needs feminism.