Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Voluntary agreements solve all relevant concerns

Springer, 17—University of Victoria (Simon, “The limits to Marx: David Harvey and the condition of postfraternity,” Dialogues in Human Geography 2017, Vol. 7(3) 280–294, dml)

Stretching the horizontal vision: Federation beyond hierarchy and authority Life already shows in which direction the change will be made. Not in increasing the powers of the State, but in resorting to free organization and free federation in all those branches which are now considered as attributes of the State. —Peter Kropotkin (2002 [1887]: 68–69) The second major claim that Harvey draws from Barcelona is that anarchism lacks the ability ‘to stretch the vision of political activism from local to far broader geographical scales’ (2017: 242). Harvey means to warn us of what he elsewhere refers to as the ‘fetishism of organizational preference’ (2012a: 7), which he assumes to be a mistaken prioritization of the method of organizing over its desired outcome. To Harvey, such a prefigurative politics, which is the here and now of anarchism (Ince, 2012; Springer, 2012), supposedly prevents anarchists from being able to plan major infrastructures, manage environmental concerns, or service transport and communication networks. Of course, I already provide a partial answer to this in my original essay (Springer, 2014d), where I point to Colin Ward’s (2004) example of postal services functioning not through a central world authority, but via voluntary agreements. Kropotkin (2002 [1887]) makes the same point with respect to the independent federation of European railways in his time. Harvey attempts to preempt being called out on the inaccuracy of his claim by stating that ‘anarchist town planners (including Bookchin) understood this problem but their work is largely ignored within the anarchist movement’ (2017: 242–3). To say this work is overlooked only reveals Harvey’s limited knowledge of the literature and the scant attention he pays to anarchist writings, and particularly to anarchosyndicalism, anarchism’s oldest answer to industrial relations wherein worker-managed production systems are networked into a stateless socialist society (Rocker, 2004 [1938]; Solidarity Federation, 2012). Harvey knows of Bookchin’s libertarian municipalism, but he doesn’t take it seriously. Demonstrating the depths of his state-centric imagination, he lampoons it by saying ‘if it looks like a state, and feels like a state, and quacks like a state, then it’s a state’ (Harvey, 2012c: n.p.). Elsewhere, he suggests Bookchin’s idea about assemblies is ‘well worth elaborating as part of a radical anti-capitalist agenda’ (Harvey, 2012a: 85), yet instead of actually doing so, Harvey falls back on a centralization argument, where the state takes center stage. Perhaps the most confounding statement in Harvey’s entire essay is that the dialectic between decentralization and centralization is one of the most important contradictions within capital ... and I wish all those, like Springer, who advocate decentralization as if it is an unalloyed good would look more closely at its consequences and contradictions. Given that I dedicate an entire essay to this exact question (Springer, 2014b), it’s unfortunate that Harvey asks me to listen when he clearly doesn’t do so himself. Far from treating decentralization as a pure virtue, I attempt to work through what a progressive, anarchist view of decentralized horizontalism actually means. In the process, I identify the contradictions that lurk within Harvey’s hierarchical political outlook, arguing that he ‘poisons the well of decentralization by pre-emptively refusing its possibilities and positioning every movement towards a more autonomous political arrangement as a device that somehow necessarily greases the rails for a neoliberal future’ (Springer, 2014b: 403). Harvey dismisses anarchism’s coupling of decentralization with anti-capitalism precisely because Marxism cannot accommodate prefigurative politics, treating horizontality as a charming, but ultimately limited if not futile, distraction from realizing the bigger revolutionary picture. Horizontalism is consequently positioned as something that might happen after the promised great withering of the state, and so we can see plainly that the ‘stages of history’ is not a caricature, but an unacknowledged specter that continues to haunt the Marxist project. Failing to understand this particular limit to Marxism, Harvey invokes the idea that ‘it is difficult if not impossible ... to take consensual horizontality to much larger scales’ and that it is impossible to proceed without setting up ‘confederal’ or ‘nested’ (which means inevitably hierarchical in my view but then this too may just be semantics) structures of decision-making that entail[s] serious adjustments in organized thinking as well as forms of institutionalized governance. (2017: 248) I’ve already offered a lengthy response, where I make clear that the relationship between scale and hierarchy is not mere semantics (Springer, 2014b), yet Harvey is content to ignore the whole critique of the scalar imagination and the emancipatory politics that flow from a flat ontology (Marston et al., 2005; Woodward et al., 2012). To Harvey it would seem that a caricature of authority is a better reply than thinking through how a rhizomic politics can indeed ‘stretch the vision of political activism’ (2017: 242), and how it does so without resorting to the hierarchical politics that are necessarily implied by scalar thinking. Federalism is, of course, the long-standing anarchist answer to hierarchy (Proudhon, 1980 [1863]; Ward, 2011), yet Harvey apparently can’t be bothered to work through their differences. Instead of a serious discussion of authority, we get nuggets like I certainly would not welcome a pilot landing at JFK proclaiming that as a good anarchist she does not accept the legitimacy of the air traffic controllers’ authority and that she proposes to disregard all aviation rules in the landing process. (Harvey, 2017: 239) While Harvey assumes he has stumbled upon the ultimate trump card, he simply confuses specialist knowledge with authority. This is a question that Bakunin (2010 [1882]: 24) answered long ago when he wrote: In the matter of boots, I refer to the authority of the bootmaker; concerning houses, canals, or railroads, I consult that of the architect or the engineer. For such or such special knowledge I apply to such or such a savant. But I allow neither the bootmaker nor the architect nor savant to impose his authority upon me. I listen to them freely and with all the respect merited by their intelligence, their character, their knowledge, reserving always my incontestable right of criticism and censure. This isn’t good enough for Harvey though, and he routinely ridicules horizontal organization, using extreme examples like nuclear power plants and air traffic control to make his case. For example, in a lecture delivered at London School of Economics (LSE), he argued that horizontalism is impractical because there are many aspects of contemporary life that are now organized in what you might call ‘tightly-coupled systems’ where you need command and control structures. I wouldn’t want my anarchist friends to be in charge of a nuclear power station. (Harvey, 2012b: n.p.) Yet since horizontal organizational tactics in anarchism are usually part of a broader class struggle (Solidarity Federation, 2012), it is absurd to suggest that there would ever be a time where anarchists would enter into assembly—federated or otherwise—during a nuclear meltdown or the complex operation of landing an airplane. Indeed, without a discernable hierarchy to oppose, ‘in what possible circumstance would collective struggle be necessary during such risky periods?’ (fkshultze, 2013). Nonetheless, mutual aid in times of disaster—both natural and manufactured—is a recurrent human theme, where people regularly come together and organize themselves effectively around an ensuing crisis in the complete absence of a centralized authority. We saw this with spectacular effect in the wake of Hurricane Katrina, where the state was more concerned with restoring ‘law and order’ and criminalizing desperate people than it was with relief and rescue efforts. In response to the state’s failure, people instead helped themselves and each other, particularly through the formation of the Common Ground Collective. For Kropotkin (2008 [1902]: 137), the tendency for mutual aid ‘has so remote an origin, and is so deeply interwoven with all the past evolution of the human race, that it has been maintained ... notwithstanding all vicissitudes of history’.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.