Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm fails

Simon Springer 12, professor of geography at the University of Victoria, “Anarchism! Or What Geography Ought To Be,” Antipode Vol. 44(5) pg. 1613

That radical geography retains a decidedly statist focus perhaps also betrays the colonial origins of the discipline itself and a hesitation in breaking from old disciplining habits. Yet the contemporary nation-state, following Anderson (1991) and Billig (1995), must be understood as a smaller-scale replica of the colonial state. Although differing in their diffusion and distribution across space, both national and colonial state power express the same violent principles of a privileged few wielding influence over others, and imposing a singular identity upon antecedent ways of imagining belonging. Marx was not oblivious to this critique, yet here again he advanced a utilitarian ideal. As capitalism spread around the globe, it gave rise to powerful resistance movements by oppressed workers and peasants—led by vanguards—which Marx believed would eventually engender the transcendence of capitalism. In particular instances Marx supported nationalist struggles, viewing nationalism as another “stage in development” towards a future workers’ internationalism (Lewis 2000). Yet from an anarchist perspective it is hard to see the emancipatory end when the means are shot through with violence. What “national liberation” actually represents is the trading of one set of elites for another, and thus one form of colonialism for another. While the territorial expression has been scaled down, the underlying logic remains unchanged. Just as the colonial state sought and was frequently able to impose a monopoly on violence, the struggle to create the nation-state is likewise a struggle for the monopoly of violence (Harris 2004). What is created in both instances—a colonial or national state— is itself a means of violence. In recognizing this congruency—notwithstanding Hart’s (2008:680) so-called “properly post-colonial frame of understanding” that continues to privilege the state—to be “post-colonial” in any meaningful sense is to also be “post-statist” or anarchic, wherein the hierarchies, order, authority, and violence upon which these parallel state projects have been built are rejected outright. Moreover, internationalism by definition can never actually transcend the state; instead it continues to presuppose and assume nations. By calling for trans- geographical co-operation between nations, Marx’s internationalism fails to move beyond the notion of the nation-state as the foundational unit of belonging. Why then has contemporary radical geography not developed an “anti-colonial imagination” that rises to the post-statist challenge that Anderson (2005) argues such a vision actually demands? Reclus and Kropotkin demonstrated long ago that geography lends itself well to emancipatory ideas, and “it was no accident that two of the major anarchists of the late Nineteenth Century were also geographers” (Ward 2010:209). There exists an extraordinary latent potential within contemporary radical geography to become even more radical in its critiques, and thus more liberationist in its focus by embracing an anarchist ethos. Anarchism is able to recognize capitalism, imperialism, colonialism, neoliberalism, militarism, nationalism, classism, racism, ethnocentrism, Orientalism, sexism, genderism, ageism, ableism, speciesism, carnism, homophobia, transphobia, sovereignty and the state as interlocking systems of domination. The mutually reinforcing composition of these various dimensions of “archy” consequently means that to uncritically exempt one from interrogation, is to perpetuate this omnicidal conglomeration as a whole. Unlike the circumscriptions of Marxian geography, the promise of anarchist geographies rests precisely in their ability to think integrally and therein refuse to assign priority to any one of the multiple dominating apparatuses, as all are irreducible to one another (Brown 1996). This means that no one struggle can wait on any other. It’s all or nothing, and the a priori privilege of the workers, the vanguards, or any other class over others is to be rejected on the basis of its incipient hierarchy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.