Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

It causes bloodshed

Springer et al. 12. Simon Springer, professor of geography at the University of Victoria (Canada), Anthony Ince, professor of geographical and earth sciences at the University of Glasgow, Jenny Pickerill, professor of geography the University of Leicester (UK), Gavin Brown, professor of geography the University of Leicester (UK), and Adam J. Barker, professor of geography the University of Leicester (UK), “Reanimating Anarchist Geographies: A New Burst of Colour,” Antipode Vol. 44 No. 5 2012 pg. 1598

Social transformation is, of course, necessarily a spatial project, and a spatial dimension to the effective critique of existing structures is an important element of imagining and forging spaces for new ones. Accordingly, we remain deeply cynical of those ostensibly “radical” views that leave the prescriptions and authority of the state firmly intact. Without appreciating the infinite possibilities that actually exist if we only had the collective courage and freedom to explore them, we are left with an all too limited vision of the geographical horizons of human organization. We must similarly remain attentive to the idea that adaptations and abuses of state power are intrinsic not only to neoliberalism and capitalism more generally (Peck 2001), but also to Marxism in its traditional sense. In the face of the sheer enormity of the bloodshed that came with communist projects in the former Soviet Union, Maoist China, and Pol Pot’s Cambodia, and the conflict, othering, and violence that is facilitated by a Westphalian system of sovereign rule, we long for and are actively committed to procuring alternative socio-spatial arrangements wherein people are liberated from all forms of domination and are free to collectively make of themselves what they will. While we are keen to critique Marxist-Leninism in all its various guises, we acknowledge that there are heterodox Marxists working with more autonomist and libertarian ideas that share similar concerns and are far less antithetical to anarchist approaches. At the same time, we recognize that it is incorrect to suggest— as post-left anarchists like Fredy Perlman (1983) have argued—that if we simply choose to act differently then society will magically transform into a post-capitalist, post-statist world. Anarchist thinkers have long interrogated complex matrices of control and surveillance, highlighting the ways in which the agents of state and capital converge to produce powerful regimes of containment or straightforward obliteration of their political opponents (Graham 2005, 2009; Gue ́rin 2005; Marshall 1992; Woodcock 2004). Indeed, Daniel Gue ́rin’s (2010 [1936]) careful tracing of the synergies between the rise of European fascism in the 1930s and the organizational and disciplinary logic of the capitalist state can be read as a powerful warning from history in the current context of recession, unrest, and the re-emergence of the far right.

Thus, anarchist approaches to understanding and acting in society operate in a tension between an assertion of peoples’ agency to collectively self-manage their affairs on the one hand, and the everyday matrices of power that constrain autonomy, solidarity and equality on the other. However, anarchism is also a philosophy that is healthily sceptical of analysis for its own sake, and combines its powerful critique of capital and authority with a creative and decentralized mode of praxis. So while we recognize the importance of utopian thought, we are not content to dwell exclusively in the realm of ideas, and advocate for the importance of direct action in changing for the better the material conditions of our own lives as well as the lives of others (Graeber 2009). Notwithstanding the now-cliche ́d refrain that anarchists were at the creative centre of the movements against neoliberal globalisation around the turn of the twenty-first century, anarchist thought and action has profoundly influenced contemporary society in a much more long-term and subcutaneous sense. The proliferation of wikis, peer-to-peer file-sharing and open-source software; the continued popularity of the co-operative movement, tenants’ associations and trade and credit unions; and a host of small- scale mutual aid groups, networks and initiatives—these have, all to varying extents, been pioneered, inspired or run by anarchists. Our perception of anarchism’s role in the world is, however, in direct proportion to our understanding of what anarchism is and where (or how) it takes place. Although at times it may appear that anarchism is chiefly (or solely) manifested in occasional spectacular riots on the streets of Athens, Prague, London and Seattle, papers in this special issue indicate that anarchism is a philosophy of everyday life, ingrained in its practitioners as a tool for survival, wellbeing and social change. It is worth noting that, perhaps precisely due to the legacy of Reclus and Kropotkin, anarchist geographers have tended to shy away from engaging with the more insurrectionary approaches to anarchism, where instead anarchism has been understood as a living breathing process that is acutely implicated in our shared histories, our present circumstances, and our collective futures. In this special issue, a broad understanding of anarchism is deployed to demonstrate how it—much like other political philosophies—is a multi-vocal and developing terrain, contested both from within and without.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.