Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Biotechnology is the next site for control. The human body will be reduced to bioinformatics.

Faucher, 13 [Kane X. Faucher is a professor at University of Western Ontario, January 2013, accessed on 7-24-2022, Springer, "EX LIBRIS: A NOMAD INFORMATION SCIENCE?", https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/bbm%3A978-94-6209-428-4%2F1.pdf]/ISEE

One area of applied informatics has taken the form of what has been called bioinformatics. This burgeoning field of inquiry involves the storage and retrieval of biological data, be this identifying unique genetic markers in the individual or for security purposes in retinal identification. When it is employed for the regulation and control of individuals by state or corporate entities, the “dark side” of bioinformatics would be an outgrowth of what Michel Foucault calls “biopower,” the overall function of which is to subjugate human subjects to regulatory controls. Even beyond human subjects, bioinformatics in its connection to biotechnologies has been instrumental in the creation of new pest-resistant seeds, such as are developed by major biotech firms like Monsanto, Syngenta, et al. It is possible, with the assistance of Deleuze and Guattari’s concepts, to develop an alternative, if not nomadic, bioinformatics that recognizes what a body can do, and studies its flows rather than subjects bodies to regulatory control relying on computational processes. Although much of bioinformatics, as allied with biotechnology and genomics, starts with mathematical formulae, algorithms, and statistics to discover the simple behavioural rules at a cellular and genetic level to explain biological processes in biotic systems, a “nomadized” or “iterantized” bioinformatics would appreciate the flows and assemblages in biotic systems as being signals of expression. Would it be useful? The short answer would be no, but it is a move away from utility that uncovers the intensive qualities of the biological world. Deleuze and Guattari are rightly suspicious of any practice that takes reductionism as its starting point––be that of an atomic or genetic register––given that it may smuggle hylomorphism as the pivot around which the understanding of the world turns. It is here that we grapple with the metonymy or polysemy of the very word information and how it is applied in different contexts. In information systems theory, this is indexed on the product of data processing and the automation of processes in computing technology. This takes for granted the term of information being under the sole discretion of the technical aspects of the term which excludes from view its more philosophical or even mathematical understanding, although it seems to share more overlap with the latter with respect to a Shannon-Weaver definition. From the technical standpoint emerges the engineering approach to managing large systems, specific communication problems, and “information overload.” Again, this use of information is strictly deployed for the purposes of understanding and improving the infrastructure of “information” systems in communication technologies and the Internet. Winnowing information as a subspecies of computing technologies, researchers in informatics such as Bo Dahlbohm are quite explicit in defining the boundaries which betrays a certain technocentric perspective: To turn computers into powerful computing machines you need to know numerical methods and algorithms; to develop information systems you must master business modelling, systems design, and project organization; personal computing requires psychological theories of human-computer interaction, skills in interface design, and how to do usability studies; and to support networking you must understand human communication and cooperation, network technology and multimedia production, and the role of cyberspace as a new arena for human enterprise (1996, p. 44) When we consider the information landscape today as a process of harnessing social power through regimental ordering systems that distribute variety within constraints via radical customization, the informatic trope continues to operate in the digital Umwelt as a means of identity determination and the colonization of digital space. Moreover, informatics might actually have a considerable impact on relations between the social and data: First, these technoscientific practices and logics form discrete examples where the relationship between the body and language is reconfigured as a relationship of materiality and data/information. Secondly, this manifestation has been occurring in a socio-cultural site thoroughly enframed by the technological apparatus of computer and telecommunications based developments, contributing to the increasingly intimate conjunction of molecular science research and technological development that constitutes contemporary technoscience. (Thacker 1998) One of the main applications of bioinformatics, beyond the sequencing of genes and developing techniques for steering genetic production in harnessing genetic information, would be the direct intervention of biotechnology on plant life. What began with the discovery of DNA and the increasing power of technology, blossomed in the 1970s and boomed in the 1980s toward the manipulation of discrete genetic sequences for maximizing crop yields that could resist pests. In effect, the harnessing of genetic information toward these ends is an attempt to inscribe both the image of the molecular biologist’s intentionality and capital’s drive for utility and production at the very site of life itself. More particularly, the emergence of genetic variations through modification is an attempt to inscribe or de- and re-territorialize genetic code along capitalist decoded flows that enable older forms of capital such as the idea of private property (in the form of intellectual copyright, or what we can call the mental labour form of the property flow), and according to relative human scales that inscribe itself in biological ones. The practice of genetic modification or biotechnological engineering differs from its older cousin of selective cross-breeding in that the process for constructing something new and possibly more durable occurs directly at the level of code rather than at the level of the completed organisms placed in relation. At the genetic modification level, the versatility and options for recombination are much more varied, for it becomes possible to splice code from an amphibian with that of a tomato––something that cannot be done at the level of cross-breeding due to the breeding incompatibility of their respective biological kingdoms. As Mark Hansen notes (2000), Deleuze and Guattari’s take on evolution appears to adopt more of a neo-Darwinian approach aligned with their biophilosophy, rejecting in part Bergson’s vitalism. And yet, Deleuze and Guattari seem also to reject Darwin’s natural selection, preferring to raise selection to the level of the abstract machine. In this way, it would be a hasty mistake to impute to Deleuze and Guattari a kind of apologia for biotechnologically based genetic modification as the scene of a more profound selection given the strong relation between biotechnological engineering and capitalism in the decoding of flows and the territorialization of life according to the axiomatic of capitalism itself. We must first distinguish between three ways by which new organisms are produced: 1. By mutations that are not directly aided by human intervention, 2. Selective breeding, and, 3. Direct genetic alteration. Mutations in species can occur partially as a result (or answer to) an environmental problem, such as the development of the frog’s tongue to catch flies, or the adaptation to changing climates and interspecies conditions of competition (what can be called perplication). This may be explained in Deleuzean terms as analogous to the “natural selection” of singularities that form assemblages from the ideal line of matter-movement, their temporary assemblage as a perplication whereby the accidents of contingent reason are what condition and resolve the problemata. They may also occur on the basis of more internal and possibly spontaneous arrangements, such as copying fidelity error from one gene sequence to another. A more invasive procedure emerged due to scientific advancements linked to the discovery of DNA: genetic modification. No longer simply a matter of selective breeding of a single or related species, geneticists could perform their changes directly to the genetic code itself, thus making it possible to cross previous boundaries so that, for example, partial code sequences of a frog’s skin could be grafted unto the code of a tomato’s skin. However, it also implicitly endorses fragmentation of the body, or true organ-ization. When Deleuze and Guattari speak of becoming-other, or the person becomingdog, they are not speaking literally, but in terms of what assists in articulating the very traits of the individual in a process of individuation as rooted in a nonhylomorphic understanding of form and content and the double articulation that takes place in terms of content and expression as a relative line. However, the connections that can be drawn between how Deleuze and Guattari define the rhizome seem to uncomfortably apply to genetic modification insofar as here we are presented with radical connectivity between codes, and a crossing over of signification regimes that in effect designify stable relations to allow the new to emerge. But that is only surface resemblance. What we are presented with is the convergence of neoliberal capital and cybernetics inspired control mechanisms making use of the very technical instruments designed for control and modulation frameworks as applied to the combinatory potentials of genetics in the form of biotechnologies. The distribution of genetic modification activities in large scale agriculture, or agri-business, are now assigned by those whose actions control the possibilities that can be harnessed and exploited in the genetic laboratory. The plant is thus deterritorialized from the field, the gene from its sequence, the farmer from the farming function as dequalified labour. The construction of new patterns in genetic territory are expanded at the macro scale, encompassing now corporatized arable lands for the cultivation of these patterns made manifest in a range of products. Nature itself is not so much “created anew” through selective breeding and natural selection as it is modulated according to predetermined outcomes, and corrective feedback is conducted in a variety of ways to ensure maximum yields of resistant strains, and to engage an apparatus of both political influence lobbying to ensure compliance with the genetic modification mission, and litigation against those farmers who would assert any autonomy with respect to their own seeds or in any way challenge the effects of genetic drift and transgene escape. In this way, despite the heavy emphasis on free modulation, biotech corporations like Monsanto or Syngenta still have recourse to disciplinary structures such as the State and its laws, and in some cases can easily outmaneuver the law by continuing to violate laws that stipulate that GM crops cannot be planted within a defined distance of certified organic crops.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.