Mapping produces an organization of space that is static.
Peters, 20 [Kimberley Peters works for the Helmholtz Institute for Functional Marine Biodiversity at the University of Oldenburg and for the Institute for Chemistry and Biology of Marine Environments, 11-2-2020, accessed on 7-24-2022, PubMed Central (PMC), "The territories of governance: unpacking the ontologies and geophilosophies of fixed to flexible ocean management, and beyond", https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7662200/]/ISEE
What both were challenging was the difficulty of transferring a landed way of ‘doing business’ to sea in respect of the dynamism of the sea and mobility of life within it. They were presenting alternative geophilosophies (geographically de-territorialized modes of thinking) and different ontologies (of a world not rooted, but mobile). The sea, both sets of authors argued, is geophysically liquid, mobile, three-dimensional. You can draw a line on map, but not the ocean itself. You can attempt to designate a zone, but the sea and life at sea move [61,62]. More so, because the deep sea is legally an international space and for the most part is beyond state jurisdiction, it cannot be territorialized in the same way (although this, of course, does not stop some from trying; see [6]). These different modes of knowing and understanding, of fluid geophilosophies and ‘wet’ ontologies—of de-territorialization—unlock different potentials for ‘doing’ governance. In late 2016, I began a project searching for examples where less mainstream governance regimes were being developed. These were ways of organizing the marine realm that had mobilized a radically different ontology from the territorializing, grounded practices typical of ocean management. It is, of course, difficult to search for such approaches that diverge from the accepted, dominant regimes of marine governance. Indeed, where do you start to find ‘experimental’ modes of managing the seas and oceans, and the activities, and life, within them? Such an approach requires looking beyond the ‘trap’, as Elden calls it [42], that can be territory. As Elden urges, we need to start from a point of looking beyond accepted knowledge regimes [42]. This requires a substantial cognitive shift to recognize our own indoctrination in the reproduction of such traps. Instead we must be aware of how this ‘constrains our thinking’ and ‘hamstrings our potential for critique’ ([42], p. 757). Undertaking this work creates space to see or make visible other organizations of governance. This can occur through a tracing of stories, a listening to new narratives, an openness to future scenarios, built through an array of data including official records, archives, mind maps, interviews, oral histories and other qualitative as well as quantitative data sources, including modes of scenario formation to imagine oceans differently through time (for the latter see [63]). The Bering Strait is a narrow seaway of 44 nautical miles positioned between the landmasses of Russia and the American archipelago of Alaska [64]. It was an area with little explicit marine governance, in part because it has not been a well-used global transport route (although it has, historically been a ‘nexus’ for localized trading, something typically ignored in contemporary governance developments; see [65]). Yet with climate change, ice melt, and an increasingly viable passage emerging, vessel traffic is increasing and with it risks to marine life [65]. Indeed, as the Pew Charitable Trust have noted, this poses unique challenges for, a highly productive marine ecosystem… Almost the entire western Arctic population of bowhead whales travels through the strait twice a year. It also provides important food for the Pacific Walrus, spectacled eider, and grey whales. An estimated 12 million seabirds nest or forage in the area each year. The strait is also home to indigenous communities whose inhabitants have lived a traditional way of life along its shores for untold generations. [64] With ecosystem threats owing to ship strikes, noise, discharge and contamination [65], efforts began to consider mechanisms to mitigate potential harm. In 2010, the United States Coastguard (USCG) began a consultation regarding the implementation of a ship routeing scheme for the Bering Strait to guide increased shipping traffic. Although pertaining to mobility—guiding the movement of ships along a corridor—the technique of governance planned and proposed rested on the very static, fixed, territorializing and grounded modes of spatial management typical in marine environments. A maritime motorway, suggested through the USCG Port Access Route Study, would create a static corridor, cut through space, mapped onto the ocean as a surficial device of management. It was a solution that sought to fix in space governance, in a realm of mobility, where whales, walrus, fish, ice, all move. Against this backdrop, an organization, a Marine Exchange was already working with a different geophilosophy and ontology. The Marine Exchange of Alaska (MXAK), a non-governmental, not-for-profit organization that has been operating since 2001, embodies a networked approach to maritime domain awareness. Through a process of information dissemination to help guide users of the marine environment, it is also flexible and responsive to the very mobile and dynamic environment in which it operates, sharing information in ‘real-time’. As Captain Ed Page, director of the MXAK noted, this presents a radically different way of thinking about how we protect and conserve the Bering Strait. So my point is I think the best way to manage places like the Bering Strait is actually send information … using this new technology, warn those at risk… you can say ‘you can go through the Bering Strait but here's the guidelines now, just stay this far away from shore and … we'll let you know where you can go when you get there because it's a dynamic situation (Captain Ed Page, unpublished interview, 5 November 2016). Built through networks—of satellites, weather stations, radar sites, ships, processed AIS data from the Marine Exchange building, the desk operators, the environment itself, fog, rain, sun, mobile marine life, ice floes—the organization of space emerges through an ethos of knowledge sharing that has no discrete territorialized boundaries built on landed assumptions, but reflects the very relational and connected nature of the marine environment and the human and more-than-human ‘actants’ using the space (see also [24]). It works on a networked ontology responsive to ‘earthly’ processes and relations. This de-territorialized, open, networked geophilosophy provides us with an arguably less areal, flat ontology for thinking about governance. By comparison, it provides us with a spherical, three-dimensional, imaginary, where the earth is connected in a system of related, networked, assembled and co-constituted parts; where the ‘earth’ is, as Elden notes ‘in flux, dynamic, indeterminate, and changeable, rather than static and fixed’ ([66], p. xiv). We might think of the Bering example not as a territorialized zone of management—a cartographic, fixed, mode of stewarding space—but an ‘open building site’ (to quote [67], p. 65). Although, to be clear, the MXAK is not a formal governance actor in Alaska (it is an NGO offering services for stewardship over the marine environment) it offers us, by example, a radically different view of how we might ‘do’ governance based on dismantling dominant territorial discourses. As Callon notes, an actor-network provides ‘more an inspirational frame than a constraining theoretical system… (which) postulates between humans and nonhumans… (in) the configuration of sociotechnical network’ ([67], p. 62). As Captain Page noted, …with AIS (technology) you can actually send information to vessels, an icon or a box and explain what it is by visually showing the issue, like, ‘this is an area to be avoided because of the presence of whale… Reduce your speed or give it a wide berth’. Or, ‘there's a presence of ice here, so you want to avoid that ice because your vessel is not configured or not designed to operate in those icy conditions (unpublished interview, 5 November 2016). Of course, such systems are based on goodwill and collaboration that might not be transferable to all examples, but it demonstrates an approach that exceeds [27] the limits of existing marine strategies. Indeed, although a very distinct example, it makes visible the possibility of a different way of doing governance. As Maxwell et al. note, a shift towards dynamic ocean management… defined as management that rapidly changes in space and time in response to changes in the ocean and its users through the integration of near real-time biological, oceanographic, social and/or economic data…. can refine the temporal and spatial scale of managed areas, thereby better balancing ecological and economic objectives. ([60], p. 42)