Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Satellites generate a point of view that is not neutral but violent.

Peters, 20 [Kimberley Peters works for the Helmholtz Institute for Functional Marine Biodiversity at the University of Oldenburg and for the Institute for Chemistry and Biology of Marine Environments, 11-2-2020, accessed on 7-24-2022, PubMed Central (PMC), "The territories of governance: unpacking the ontologies and geophilosophies of fixed to flexible ocean management, and beyond", https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7662200/]/ISEE

There is, of course, a need to be just as cautious about these de-territorialized developments in marine management. Captain Page posits that ‘new’ approaches should not necessarily replace old ones with de-territorialized modes supplanting territorialized ones. Indeed, as noted, there is quite some evidence that conservation enclosures ‘work’. Decisions on how to manage the marine environment should be based on the particularities of the situation: the balance between protecting the ecosystem, the economy, livelihoods and more-than-human oceanic life. In some scenarios, depending on the purpose of governance and the desired goals, zoning may be optimal; in others, not. As Captain Page noted, ‘I mean the funny thing is that sometimes these things [dynamic approaches] don't replace something else, they just complement and supplement. They have different capabilities and different features' (Captain Ed Page, unpublished interview, 5 November 2016). There is also a need to be cautious about any assumed benefits of de-territorialized approaches vis-à-vis their territorial predecessors. As Maxwell and colleagues note, there is still a ‘gap’ in some of the data needed to make responsive techniques workable ([60], see also [68]). They also rely on the dependability of technological apparatus (satellite tracking systems and such like). In addition, there is a need to ensure that legal frameworks can support such developments where necessary ([60], p. 42). Boucquey and colleagues argue a point further, noting that we should be careful that the data driving such responsive or flexible processes aren't themselves making ‘durable’ new kinds of ocean knowledge ([10], p. 484). Data are always the mirror of their creator, not the world itself, and this can bring with it challenges in respect of reliability, especially where the data for such processes derive from portals of oceanic information collected and collated by various agencies each with vested (political) interests in how the marine environment is used and protected (and for whom) [69–71]. Indeed, while governance does involve a broad range of actors ([2], p. 317), it is not an equal process. In attempting to include a variety of sectors—humanitarian organizations; ocean conservancy NGOs; private companies; and beyond—governance is said to be ‘bottom-up’ rather than ‘top-down’ in developing modes of organizing, managing and governing people, activities and spaces. As such, the voice of much ocean policy tends to speak in a collective ‘we’ that represents all. Consider, for example, the strapline to the UN Decade of Ocean Science: ‘the science we need, for the ocean we want’ ([53], emphasis added). But who is that ‘we’? What science is needed by different actors, and what kind of ocean do different people desire? Governance, management and policy, accountable as they may try to be, do not ensure every voice is heard and every perspective is accounted for (see Flannery et al. on MSP, [15,16] and the recent report on the latest BBNJ Intergovernmental Conference on Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction, for example, where some nations and perspectives were unable to participate fully [72]). It is necessary to consider the discourses of territory and regimes of power within which territory as a ‘political technology’ sits [4]. Territorializing practice is a political means of taking and appropriating space [5,73]. Modes of ocean governance that are territorial, then, are not politically innocent—they involve the allocation and even seizing of space for a particular purpose (even where that purpose may be situated as a ‘greater good’). In 2014, the Transnational Institute (TNI), Masifundise Development Trust and Afrika Kontakt laid out a brochure highlighting practices of ocean—the snatching of space through schemes such as MPAs, which while situated as beneficial for ocean protection and conservation, can by-pass the needs, experiences, knowledge and uses of local indigenous populations in relation to their ocean space [75]. Indeed, planning and conservation practices based on territorializing logics hold with them colonial traces where territories were first established through the violent land grabs of colonial and imperial enterprise (see [74], p. 10). It is important to go back and engage critically with these histories in the context of present day and future-oriented governance and management strategies to unsettle such approaches [74]. Moreover, it is important that a homogeneous ‘we’ (a ‘we’ that is often a white, western, and predominantly male) also steps back from the work of governance, not just to include, but reorientate entirely approaches to ocean governance through decolonialism. Only this has the potential to truly ‘transform’ the ocean for sustainability.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.