The United States engages in attempts to achieve a fantasy of security as a palliative to its nostalgia for a “lost wholeness”.
Terada 14 - Randall Terada is a member of Lacan Toronto and works with a number of local community agencies providing psychoanalytic based consulting. He received his Ph.D. from York University in 2013. (Randall Terada, “Review: A Politics of the Death Drive”, American Imago , Vol. 71, No. 1 (Spring 2014), pp. 89-96)
Drawing political ramifications, McGowan rejects both the politics of nostalgia—either progressive or conservative—that seeks to redeem a lost plenitude and the deconstructionist alternative that posits a receding horizon of possibility that politics should seek to keep open. Instead, he argues for remaining within rather than fleeing this recurrent manifestation of loss, this condition of masochistic self-wounding that derails our best-laid plans, for which we then blame others: Rather than trying to avoid violence, we can restore to it its proper object—the self. The more the subject engages in a violent assault on its own forms of symbolic identity, its own ego, its own deepest convictions, the more the subject finds an enjoyable alternative to the satisfactions of aggression. (p. 51) The repetitive return to painful and humiliating experiences of vulnerability and loss marks the transition to a subject of drive. Enjoying what we don’t have, McGowan argues, opens up the possibility of a different type of social solidarity, one based on loss, yet open to infinite possibility.
Politics, Knowledge, and Enjoyment
McGowan cites the 2001 attack on the World Trade Center as an example of an enjoyment in loss with direct political bearings. A social bond emerged through an experience of collective loss, such that the headlines of French newspapers proclaimed on that day, “Nous sommes tous Américains” (p. 160). However, precisely because a return to a foundational experience of loss is traumatizing, the subject seeks to escape this unbearable enjoyment and instead finds something pleasurable to disavow it (p. 38). Because enjoyment of loss is a painful, shameful, humiliating experience, the United States quickly covered over the loss and turned to an assertion of imperial will “that would carry with it the promise of a restored wholeness—the recovery of an imaginary perfect security” (p. 160). For a brief moment, a social solidarity emerged around this loss, but at that precise moment, too, forces were deployed that carried the promise—and nostalgia—of restoring a lost wholeness. Reflecting upon the social context in which these conflicting responses occurred, McGowan discusses the relevance of the proximity of the real other. The decline of grandiose figures representing the lawful order—such as the local parish priest, the politician, or the leader of the local business community who doubles as the local football coach—has led more and more to a decline in prohibitions and common symbolic mediations, all of which has given rise to the unbearable proximity of the other and the ideology of tolerance through which we mediate this new proximity. Tolerance, however, simply strips away otherness, so that we do not encounter the other in its real dimension, in other words, unmediated by a symbolic structure (p. 117). Tolerance, McGowan argues, stands in the way of a radical ethical posture. Paradoxically, the fantasy of enjoyment that the xenophobe constructs around the other “permits an encounter with the real other that liberal tolerance forecloses…The ethical position thus involves sustaining the liberal’s tolerance within the conservative’s encounter with the real other” (p. 120).