Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Independently—only embracing universality can confront existential impacts.

McGowan, 20—professor of film studies at the University of Vermont (Todd, “This Is Not Identity Politics,” Universality and Identity Politics, Chapter 6, ebook, dml)

There is one arena where the limitations of particularism become fatal. The political implications of the refusal of universality are catastrophic when we look at climate change. Even when we think about climate change as a global phenomenon, our starting point is too often the various disturbances that we link together to form the idea of climate change. We encounter climate change in particular manifestations like shifting weather patterns, more intense storms, higher water levels, increased temperatures, and so on. The question then becomes whether or not the particulars constitute climate change, which is precisely what opens the door to climate skeptics. But even if we all agree that these particular indications amount to climate change, particularist thinking shapes how we respond.

Although climate change requires a universalist approach, we confront it from the perspective of the particular. As a result, most political initiatives are particular: recycling, driving less, biking more, not using the air conditioning, placing solar panels on one’s roof, planting trees, and so on —up to taking a ship across the ocean to reduce one’s carbon footprint. Even the more holistic solutions like the carbon tax or restrictions on carbon output do not confront the crisis through a universalist politics. We can only address the problem of climate change effectively when we address it in universal rather than particular terms.

The problem is not just that our solutions are particularist but that we perceive the crisis through a particularist way of knowing. Epistemology rooted in the particular makes itself felt most prominently in the assumption of an existential scarcity of resources. Those who believe that humancreated climate change is occurring also presuppose this existential scarcity because they take the particular individual as the starting point. For the particular individual, there are a limited number of resources available that the society must distribute in some way. The economic division of resources takes place against the background of a fundamental scarcity. But as the capitalist system hurtles us closer and closer to a global catastrophe, it is important to avoid thinking in particular terms. One cannot fight climate change by not having children, eating vegan, eliminating air travel, or any of the other particular remedies that the advocates of scarcity preach. The only way to join the fight is to embrace universalism. Our universalism must become unrelenting, or we will destroy ourselves through our particularism.

The climate crisis presents us with a unique opportunity for recognizing universality. The climate crisis is universal not because it affects everyone but because it is the point of absence within every social order. What every society shares today is the environmental catastrophe that it cannot master. This hole within every society doesn’t affect every society in the same way, but it marks the limit that no society can eliminate.

By foregrounding the fundamental absence within every social order, the climate crisis puts us directly in touch with the universal. We become aware of the lack that we have in common. Here, Hollywood cinema, which so often leads us astray, offers an instructive example. The disaster film provides an occasion for Hollywood to turn massive destruction into a spectacle for entertainment. In this sense, we should be suspicious of it, since this is the formula that Walter Benjamin uses to define the aesthetics of fascism. But in addition to the spectacle of destruction, the disaster film, at its best, shows us what few other mainstream films do: the reintroduction of absence into the social field, alongside a connection to universality. Within the disaster film, the disaster does not simply pose a threat to the lives of characters. Much more important, it confronts them with the fact of a structuring absence. The disaster disrupts the daily lives of the characters, makes privacy unsustainable, and brings everyone in touch with universality.

In order to register this disruption, every disaster film begins with a variety of characters engaged in their quotidian behavior. Private concerns predominate the openings of these films. We see, for instance, a display of marital troubles in Mark Robson’s Earthquake (1974), the interaction of a town mayor and her children in Roger Donaldson’s Dante’s Peak (1997), or a class field trip in Roland Emmerich’s The Day After Tomorrow (2004). In each case, the focus on private activity serves only as a prelude to its coming insignificance. In the face of the disaster, subjects must turn their concern away from their own particularity and toward the universal.

In the typical disaster film, the disaster makes everyone aware of a fundamental lack that harbors the universal. When the disaster strikes, characters immediately begin to concern themselves with others. The reintroduction of the structuring absence through the disaster is simultaneously the reintroduction of universality. Everyone confronts their equality with everyone else. The disaster film transforms a particularized world containing only isolated monads into a lacking world of the universal.

Perhaps the outstanding example of this trajectory toward universality in absence occurs in Mick Jackson’s Volcano (1997). As a volcano unexpectedly erupts in the middle of Los Angeles, we see characters abandon their private isolation and come together to struggle against the destructiveness of the volcano and the lava flowing through the city streets. But what is most significant about the film is the relationship that it depicts between universality and capitalist particularity. In order to stop the lava flow from destroying a heavily populated portion of the city, the chief of emergency management Mike Roark (Tommy Lee Jones) plans to dynamite a newly constructed skyscraper to form a dam that would direct the lava to the ocean. The skyscraper is the pride of capitalist Norman Calder (John Corbett), who champions particular concerns over the universal in the film.

The dynamiting of Calder’s building represents the destruction of particularity that rejects any universality. The film underlines this idea through its earlier presentation of Calder. As the threat increases, he attempts to persuade his wife, Dr. Jaye Calder (Jacqueline Kim), to stop treating the victims of the volcano and leave the hospital. Norman wants Jaye to forsake any universality for her particular existence. At one point, he comes to the hospital to beg her to escape the danger. He says to her, “These people are strangers, Jaye. Are you doing to die for them?… Answer me!” In response, Jaye simply continues treating the patients and, without ever looking at him, says, “I am answering you.” Jaye answers Norman’s rebarbative particularity with an unwavering universalism. The fact that she articulates her commitment to universality through the act of not speaking befits this commitment perfectly. Through the depiction of this exchange, the film shows that it understands that a point of absence in the structure of signification constitutes genuine universalism. The disaster awakens her solidarity with others while her husband remains unaffected by it. Through this exchange, the film presents the fundamental choice that the disaster makes evident. We can choose to isolate ourselves in our particularity or avow the universal.

Just as in the disaster film, the catastrophe of climate change makes universal equality apparent. In the face of the incipient disaster, all are equal, even though climate change affects people differently. No one can escape, not even the wealthy individuals now buying up land in areas that they believe will be least affected by the disaster. If they survive in some future isolation, they will survive as empty beings, beings without any universality to set them free. The absence of any viable escape for particular individuals is the form that equality assumes today. This is why any project of confronting the disaster must at the same time confront the growing economic inequality in the contemporary capitalist universe.

Capitalism’s inherent refusal of universality leaves it completely ill-equipped to deal with the climate crisis. Its solutions will always be particular—carbon tax, recycling, bike riding, and so on—when the universal is requisite. When large-scale responses emerge within capitalism, they will be profitable for some at the expense of others. We should reject them in the name of universality. The particularist nature of capitalism will attempt to pit people against each other in the name of saving the planet.

When walking through the streets of Berlin in fall 2019, I glanced up at a placard that ominously portended the capitalist future and made me wish that I was unable to read German. The sign (with a very environmental look to it) read: “Berlin Lässt die Unwelt im Regeln Stehen; Mietendeckel bedeutet: Wir können nicht mehr in den Klimaschutz investieren” (“Berlin Let the Environmental Regulations Stand; Rent Caps mean: We can no longer invest in climate action”). Here we have the perfect particularist (and capitalist) twist to the climate crisis. Rather than see the climate crisis as the occasion for articulating universal equality, the placard enjoins Berliners to see a direct opposition between concern for equality and action on the climate. Attempts such as this pose climate action against egalitarian concerns. On the one hand, the placard accepts that the climate crisis is universal, but it uses this universality as a reason for jettisoning the egalitarian project of rent caps. This has the effect of particularizing the climate struggle. The inherent universality of the climate crisis transforms into a particular struggle when the exigencies of capitalism enter into the equation. But capitalism, due to its complete investment in particularism, is unequipped to address a crisis that demands universality. Thus, the fight against climate change must be a universalist fight against capitalism as well.

Particular identity is always a trap, but when the question so clearly involves the whole planet, particularism becomes even more dangerous. It causes us to miss both pitfalls and solutions that universality renders visible. To retreat into our own particular identity is to participate in the ultimate destruction of human existence itself. More than ever before in human history, the urgency of the climate crisis demands an explicitly universalist politics—and a universalist epistemology—in response.

When we sit around wondering why climate skeptics reject the obvious fact of climate change, we need look no further than the universality that environmental destruction makes evident. Identitarians see in climate change a clear argument for the universality that they oppose. Accepting its existence entails admitting the universality that their political position denies. Universality is inherently dialectical. It lets us see what particular identity hides—connection in the midst of division.

Universality allows for a response to a catastrophe like climate change that is equal to the magnitude of the event. Our particular identity, in contrast, leaves us with only a series of responses that can never add up to being adequate to the problem. The stake of the struggle between particular identity and universality is now existence itself.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.