Centering the universal psychoanalytically generates emancipatory politics.
McGowan, 20—professor of film studies at the University of Vermont (Todd, “The Importance of Being Absent,” Universality and Identity Politics, Chapter 2, ebook, dml)
This shared way of relating to the universal can be seen as the basis of freedom. Although societies may suppress the awareness of freedom, freedom is universal across every type of social order. The basis for this universal freedom is the inability of any form of mastery, no matter how despotic, to be complete. No society can determine its subjects with complete success but has a point of nonbelonging on which mastery ultimately founders. This point of nonbelonging universally marks every form of society and every type of culture from within. Despite efforts to minimize its effects, it acts as a constant disturbance of every society’s daily functioning. As the point of nonbelonging, the universal is the reverse side of total despotism. Universality exists in despotism’s lack.1
Even if a structure of mastery assimilates one point of nonbelonging, it cannot assimilate nonbelonging as such. Mastery strives toward becoming total, but as it comes closer to eliminating all resistance, it runs into an insuperable barrier—its own dependence on what it cannot assimilate—that acts as a brake on its total control. This barrier energizes the compulsion to mastery by giving it something to act on and thus a reason for being. But despite the power exercised on it, the barrier proves unyielding because it represents the necessary condition for the existence of any mastery at all. As a result, despotic power can’t achieve total despotism. Its external barrier is really an internal limit. If the external barrier ceases to be intractable, another one will emerge. When it comes to despotism, the elimination of one barrier is always the prelude to a new one that will seem just as intractable as the former one did.
We can see this even in the case of the actions of the relatively nondespotic global capitalist order after the fall of the Berlin Wall. This event signaled the end of what was an intractable barrier for the capitalist order: the Iron Curtain. For a brief interlude in the early 1990s, it seemed as if this order would eliminate nonbelonging altogether. But the interlude did not last long. New manifestations of nonbelonging quickly arose, most significantly in various forms of reactionary Islamicist projects, including Al Qaida’s destructive assault on the United States and the attempt by the Islamic State and the Levant (ISIL) to establish a caliphate in the Middle East. This Islamicist terror appeared in the guise of a new intractable barrier, which is why George W. Bush imagined the war against it as an almost unending one. By proclaiming a War on Terror with no definite end point, Bush announced the replacement for the Iron Curtain.
The emergence of this new external barrier to capitalism’s complete globalization testifies to the internal limit of capitalism’s totalization, a limit not just for capitalism but one that renders every attempt at total mastery futile. Even if the form of the barrier is contingent— for the capitalist order, it might have been fundamentalist Christians rather than Islamicists—the limit itself is necessary. The limit that every structure ultimately runs into is an unassimilable nonbelonging that acts as a constitutive absence for the structure. Nonbelonging is universal.
No society can include us without simultaneously alienating us from it. My belonging in a society always breaks down, which enables me to turn against this society when it takes a direction that I cannot accept. This is why I am free. Freedom is not a value of belonging, of being a member of a free society. Freedom becomes apparent as a value when we experience our nonbelonging, a nonbelonging that is universal because it applies to everyone, even those who most feel like they fit in.
We universally fail to fit in, and this universal failure is the basis of our freedom from social determination. Even the most authoritarian society cannot eviscerate the freedom that exists as a result of its inability to integrate individuals into its order with complete success. No matter how strongly social forces act on us, we cannot simply obey without an unconscious supplement to this obedience that undermines it in some way, which is why the Stalinist Soviet Union required special sites for those who didn’t go along. The gulag exists because universal freedom pervades mass indoctrination as a structuring absence. This absence owes its existence to the unconscious that throws the individual out of joint with itself. If there were no unconscious, there would be no freedom, even though we assume that the unconscious, because it involves what we don’t consciously will, is the site of our unfreedom.
Nonbelonging manifests itself in each subject as the unconscious. To have an unconscious means that I can’t belong to myself, that I can never be completely identical with what I am. The gap that prevents the social order from completing itself intrudes in me by installing a gap between what I will and how I desire, a gap that psychoanalysis calls the unconscious. As speaking beings with an unconscious, our unconscious desire is at odds with our conscious will. I will to limit my caloric intake every day in order to keep fit, but my unconscious desire leads me to eat a Twinkie after dinner and sabotage my diet. Unfortunately, my will to diet is not an act of freedom, but the sabotage is.
Freedom emerges out of an unconscious desire that doesn’t jibe with social demands, not in our free will. Acts of freedom do not occur when I consciously weigh the options and make a decision to revolt but when I feel that I cannot do otherwise and act in accordance with my unconscious drive. This is the paradox of freedom and the result of its origin in what we lack rather than what we have (our conscious will).
The universality of this internal distance in all subjects marks their freedom from total coercion. If the demands of the social order and the responses of the individual subject lined up perfectly, there would be no space for universal freedom. We would be locked into our particular identity and locked into our given world. But we constantly see their failure to line up with each other. Even when I try to act in total conformity with social injunctions, a gap remains between the command and my obedience to it. This gap is necessary for both obedience and revolt. It enables me to invest in obedience through an act of identification rather than just following it by rote. But on the other hand, the gap between the social demand and my obedience makes total obedience impossible. Total obedience necessarily hides some degree of rebellion, which is why the appearance of complete obedience always renders authorities suspicious.
The employee who always eagerly follows the boss’s orders may come home at night and dream about killing the boss. The conscious effort to be the perfect employee cannot exist without some unconscious investment in subversion, even if it isn’t as dramatic as a fantasy of murder. It could be as simple as the enjoyment of showing up colleagues who fail to follow orders as promptly or as efficiently. In this way, the conforming employee would contribute to the disorder of the company rather than its efficiency. All communities suffer from the same problem of nonbelonging, not just corporations (which actually have incentives in place to produce belonging, like employment itself and salaries, that other communities don’t have). Nonbelonging brings freedom because it indicates that we have no substantial support in the social order to rely on.2
It is our inability to fully belong that also provides the basis for the universality of equality. No one can fully belong to a social order that is itself incomplete and thus cannot precisely differentiate between belonging and nonbelonging. There is no secure inside that can serve to define belonging.3 All fail to belong equally, even though some cling to the illusion of their belonging more than others.
Social hierarchies mask this failure and present some people as more equal than others. But this value depends entirely on the assessment of others. It is not self-sustained by any social authority. If no one truly belongs, then no hierarchy has any substantial status. All social hierarchies depend on our collective belief in them. Simply by collectively disbelieving in someone’s importance, we can cause this importance to vanish, which reveals the universal equality that becomes evident through the lack of belonging.