The most important political question is form—universality or particularity comes prior to the aff.
McGowan, 20—professor of film studies at the University of Vermont (Todd, “Our Particular Age,” Universality and Identity Politics, Chapter 1, ebook)
How one conceives a struggle is always more significant than which side one takes in the struggle—because it determines which side will be more psychically appealing. We should not measure political victory by who wins elections or by whose issues triumph but by how we envision the political struggle itself. The decisive political question involves not the conclusions that we come to but the form that politics takes. This is evident on a very elementary level in the thinking of Karl Marx: he sees that if we view global politics as the confrontation between sovereign nations, it is impossible to recognize the class antagonism that knows no national borders. We’ll always be thinking about international conflicts and will never be able even to raise the question of class exploitation that transcends national barriers. Historically, Marxists have spent so much time fighting against nationalism because they recognize that investment in the idea of the nation produces a fundamental barrier to seeing the possibility of class struggle.1
This is why one of the first things that Lenin wanted to do when he created a communist government in Russia was to put an end to Russia’s participation in World War I. Following Marx, he saw that the question of an international conflict would render the class struggle invisible. This lesson from Marxism shows that our conception of what constitutes the form of political conflict shapes the possibilities that will be able to emerge in the actual political struggle.
Others have emphasized the importance of form in politics. For instance, linguist and political theorist George Lakoff provides an instructive effort to establish the significance of form in political campaigning. Frustrated with the consistent failures of the moderate Left in the United States, Lakoff offers some advice. He argues that leftists tend to forget that what counts is how we frame political issues, even more than the positions that we take on them. Framing—or form—can render battles more winnable before we fight them. According to Lakoff, the real political struggle takes place on a symbolic level. It concerns the terms that we use to describe the contest between each camp. In the afterword to his book on this subject, Moral Politics, Lakoff makes his clearest statement on this issue. He states, “The facts themselves won’t set you free. You have to frame facts properly before they can have the meaning you want them to convey.”2 Lakoff has a particular prescription for the moderate Left that reveals how he thinks about form. He envisions changing the moral frame that surrounds contemporary issues from one conducive to conservatives (the Strict Father) to one favorable for liberalism (the Nurturing Parent). For Lakoff, winning the symbolic frame game will enable liberal politicians to triumph in elections.
Lakoff grasps that form matters more than content, which is surely right as far as it goes. But it doesn’t go far enough. Despite his efforts at reframing in a leftist direction, Lakoff remains on a basically conservative terrain because his vision of form is not wide-ranging enough. The problem is that he continues to see the struggle in terms of two competing particular camps but imagines the camps differently than we currently do. He simply wants to replace the particularity of the Strict Father with that of the Nurturing Parent. The battle between these two forms is a battle of opposed particulars, arranged so that a different particular might be able to win. Lakoff has no place for universality. His formalist vision is not formalist enough because it never attains universality. The image he lights on —that of the Strict Father versus Nurturing Parent—is already an admission of defeat before the battle.3
By conceiving of the struggle in a way that leaves universality out of the picture, one accepts the basic conservative premise of politics that says that the starting point for politics is the isolated individual. According to this position, individuals exist in a meaningful way outside the universality that constitutes them as individuals in the first place. Once one accepts this premise, the struggle is already over because universality will always appear as an impingement on the privilege of the individual. No argument about universality will ever ultimately prove convincing for those who see the isolated individual as the political starting point. The conservative victory occurs with the dominance of the image of two (or more) particular forces fighting it out for political supremacy.
What this image gets wrong is that political struggle takes place between universality and particularity rather than between competing particulars, despite the fact that we don’t recognize it as such. The struggle between competing particulars or opposed tribes is always a play of shadows that obscures the fundamental opposition between universality and particularity. Universality concerns and sustains all particulars, but particularity [often does not understand] is often blind to the necessity of its connection to others that universality constantly foregrounds. Although universal and particular exist in a dialectical relation—there is no universality without particularity and vice versa—it matters which position one chooses as a starting point.
This opposition between particular and universal as the starting point is what constitutes the distinction between conservative politics of all stripes and emancipatory politics, even though this is not how the distinction is commonly understood. My contention is that the most appropriate way to understand the terms Right and Left is by associating them with particularity and universality, respectively. If one doesn’t take this step and instead sees the opposition as one involving competing tribes, then one implicitly gives the Right the upper hand.