Poststructural theorizing abandons universality as a basis for struggle.
McGowan, 20—professor of film studies at the University of Vermont (Todd, “Universal Villains,” Universality and Identity Politics, Chapter 3, ebook)
Most left-wing theorists turned away from universality after Stalinism without directly commenting on it. With the exception of Merleau-Ponty, Jean-Paul Sartre, and a few others, theorists simply took up a defense of the particular as their response to the gulag. The silence of Theodor Adorno on Stalinism is especially conspicuous, given how much time he devoted to the analysis of Nazism and the individuals who succumbed to its appeal. But equally noteworthy is the lack of analysis by figures like Michel Foucault, Gilles Deleuze, and Jürgen Habermas, just to name a few. Almost no major theorist of the generation that emerges during the 1960s tries to theorize why the communist project went so wrong with Stalin.
Instead of explicitly critiquing Stalinism for its universality as they do with Nazism, most theorists tended to particularize Marxism in order to make it more palatable and to eliminate the danger of the Marxist universal that Stalinism represents for them. In this vision, there become multiple forms of Marxism. Stalinism results from the narrowing of this multiplicity to a single universal model. Stalin oversteps by taking Marxism too far in a universal direction, but we can retain Marxism as long as we jettison the universality that makes it unpalatable.
Here, Jacques Derrida is the representative figure. Despite Derrida’s theoretical distance from Marxism throughout his early career, toward the end of his life he attempts to create a new form of Marxist multiplicity. In his late work Specters of Marx, Derrida explains the attitude that he advocates, taking up Marx and Marxism in a post-gulag world. The weight of Stalinism leads Derrida away from any straightforward embrace of Marxism, but at the same time, Derrida doesn’t want to give up Marxism’s critical apparatus.
Derrida elaborates the relationship between deconstruction and Marxism in very careful terms. He refuses either to identify his project with Marxism or to reject this identification, but what is most important is that he rejects the conception of Marxism that sees it as a unitary and universal theory. He states, “Deconstruction has never been Marxist, no more than it has ever been nonMarxist, although it has remained faithful to a certain spirit of Marxism, to a least one of its spirits for, and this can never be repeated too often, there is more than one of them and they are heterogeneous.”29 For Derrida, we cannot dismiss Marxism, but neither can we continue to sustain it as a universalizing project. To do so is to fall victim to the version of Marxism that led to the horrors of the twentieth century.
Derrida attempts to align himself with Marxist critique without any longer being a Marxist in order to avoid any complicity with Stalin. Others take a similar path as they turn away from Marxism’s universal struggle toward a series of particular struggles. They don’t advocate total revolution but particular changes—toppling of hierarchies, exploding of binaries, undermining of institutions, and so on. This shift occurs as a way of moving away from the universalism that supposedly produced a figure like Stalin and the horror of the gulag.30
Instead of inspiring suspicion about Marxism’s overinvestment in universality, the Stalinist catastrophe should have led thinkers to see the danger of total belonging. It should have led to a revaluation of the identification of the universal with the ideal of inclusivity. But this is not what happened. A series of thinkers moved away from the universal social analysis provided by Marxism and toward the analysis of particular power dynamics. This entailed a turn from Marx to Nietzsche as the central figure for emancipatory politics, which was a disastrous turn for the Left.