Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Universality solves better—every defense of particularity is actually a defense of the universal in disguise!

McGowan, 20—professor of film studies at the University of Vermont (Todd, “Introduction: Finding Universality,” Universality and Identity Politics, Introduction, ebook)

But at the same time, the widespread suspicion of universality and corresponding elevation of identity make possible a clarification of both universality and identity. The political catastrophe is a philosophical opportunity. In the wake of this political reversal, we can make clear that universality is not totalitarian and that particular identity isn’t actually outside of universality. Universality is at once what is missing in the totality and the necessary foundation of every particular identity. Paradoxically, the structure of universality can become fully evident in the aftermath of the political turn against the universal. This turn demands a reevaluation of what universality actually is. The universal is not what it seems to be. It is not a quality that multiple particulars possess in common.

The universal is what particulars share not having. The shared absence of the universal rather than the shared possession of it bonds particulars together. The key to an emancipatory politics in the aftermath of Nazism and Stalinism—and in the epoch of global capitalism—is the recognition that the universal is what we don’t have in common or our shared absence.

Understanding the universal as an absence is the key to thinking about universality outside the context of the murderous regimes that invoked it. Stalin can indiscriminately kill peasants that he labels class traitors because he is imposing the universal on Soviet society. But if the universal is an absence—if freedom is not something that one can impose but something that one cannot possess —then this horror becomes theoretically unimaginable.

When we think of universality in terms of absence rather than presence, it ceases to appear as an overarching whole that leaves no room for particular difference and becomes the basis for the subject’s singularity. I attain my singularity through my embrace of universal freedom and equality. For instance, in a gesture of refusing to participate in a system of segregation or in working to expose the violent origins of the iPhone, I become who I am through my contact with universality, through the act that enables me to free myself from my given particular identity—that of an unthinking segregationist or a cheerful iPhone user.

But the retreat from universality that occurs in the twentieth century has militated against this possibility. Thanks in part to the efforts of anti-universalist thinkers, we exist politically in the abeyance of universality and the prevalence of identity. 20 Political struggles today appear as identitarian ones, not struggles partaking in the project of universal emancipation.

But this situation is not just the result of anti-universalist theorizing. It also follows from the structure of capitalist society. Capitalism engenders identity politics. It does so by stripping away the content of all particular identity by imposing the commodity form on every particularity. This commodity form is not a universal but an empty form that necessitates total conformity. Everyone and everything must be translatable into the commodity form. As a result, within the capitalist system, the content of every particularity becomes insignificant. The particular identities of the capitalist and the worker disappear in their roles as capital and labor in the same way that the use value of the particular object disappears in its exchange value as a commodity.

The structure of capitalism vacates particular identity, leaving subjects with a contentless abstraction that few find satisfying. Capitalism’s evacuation of identity creates a vacuum that quickly fills. Identity politics emerges in response to the capitalist system.21 Although there is nothing necessary about the emergence of identitarian struggles, capitalism is a breeding ground for them. Capitalism’s emptying out of particular identity through the general commodity form produces an untenable situation for the subject, an existential emptiness that the struggle for identity attempts to fill. Often, these struggles paint themselves as anti-capitalist or articulate critiques of aspects of capitalism, but actually their role in creating a sense of identity for capitalist subjects helps them to endure the capitalist system.

Particular identity cannot be the basis for the emancipation of every identity because particular identity claims are inherently in competition with other identity claims. Even if an identitarian movement claims to advocate peaceful coexistence with other groups, this claim is necessarily disingenuous. The recognition of one identity comes at the expense of others, which is why identitarians are always quarrelling about the need to recognize the specificity of their identity. We can never reach a point of equilibrium among different identity claims. As long as a movement insists on its identity over universality, this equilibrium will remain out of reach. The only path out of a Hobbesian war of each identity against all others is that of the universal.

We experience identity as the essence of our subjectivity, but this experience is profoundly misleading. Identity, no matter if it seems intrinsic (like race and sexuality) or the result of a conscious choice (like club membership and religious affiliation), is always rooted in the social recognition that sustains it. The most private form of identity has its origin in the given social possibilities. Identity politics hides the alienating quality of all identity and thus has an ideological function.

But many of the movements that we think of in terms of identity politics are actually mislabeled universalist political projects. We must distinguish between what is identity politics and what is an appeal to universality burdened by the term identity politics. Protests against racism or sexism, appeals for gay rights, and calls for rights for trans subjects all seem to fit within the typical definition of identity politics. When we look at these movements closely, however, we can recognize their universalist thrust. It is a mistaken understanding of both identity and universality that leads us to diagnose these movements in terms of the former. The turn back to universality does not simply mean that we must, with Marx, focus on the economy.

As the turn from universality to identity begins to look increasingly irreversible, the time becomes more urgent for calling out identity as an ideological trap. The same urgency demands that we rearticulate the universality that has sustained struggles from the French Revolution to the Haitian Revolution to the Russian Revolution to the suffragist movement to the civil rights movement to the Arab Spring. If certain of these struggles have failed or have gone horribly awry, we must recognize that universality hasn’t betrayed us. We have betrayed it.22

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.