Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm fails—starting points are key!

McGowan, 20—professor of film studies at the University of Vermont (Todd, “Our Particular Age,” Universality and Identity Politics, Chapter 1, ebook)

Universality is the lack in every particular. 16 It is the insubstantiality of the particular, the dependence of the particular on what it is not. No particular entity is simply self-contained and exists on its own. It is always involved with what it is not.17 The universal is not the other on which the particular depends but what makes the particular’s selfsufficiency impossible. The point at which the particular cannot sustain itself in isolation is the point at which its involvement in universality becomes noticeable. The lack that forges this connectivity is the site of universality. If particular objects were self-contained and isolated, it would be impossible to affect them in any way. There would be genuine particularity—isolated monads. But chopping down a tree or eating a tomato or even skipping a rock across a lake reveals the intrusion of universality in the particularity of these objects. These are not just collisions of particulars with other particulars. The lack that makes such collisions possible is a universal opening insofar as it gives the lie to the isolation of the particular.

Because it exists only as an absence, we can never simply have universality. The universal’s status is thus always in question, always subject to doubt and debate. It is never fully instantiated in the way that Aristotle would have it, but this status is what gives universality its transformative potential. By instantiating the universal, Aristotle strips it of its power to transform the present by reducing it to the present. Instantiating the universal has the effect of hiding it.

The link between epistemology and politics is often obscure. But it is my contention that a genuine leftist politics is ultimately incompatible with an epistemology that begins with particulars (or one that demands the instantiation of the universal as Aristotle does). This is the case not just with conservatism but also with liberalism, which always shares the conservative epistemological starting point.

If the particular is the unassailable beginning of our thinking, as conservative and liberal thought have it, we must do everything we can to protect this particular from other particulars that have conflicting interests. According to this position, we begin as isolated beings that form bonds only in order to preserve ourselves. If we believe that there are only particulars and that universals are nothing but the constructs that result from the assembly of these particulars, then it makes sense to move in the direction of an authoritarian rule that would keep particulars safe. The sole point of any social organization would be maximizing the security of the particular, as it is for Thomas Hobbes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.