Russian history confirms settler colonialist motives for aggression
Cavanagh and Veracini 17 [Edward Cavanagh (received degrees from universities in Australia, South Africa and Canada. He has published in the fields of history and law, including Settler Colonialism and Land Rights in South Africa (Palgrave, 2013) and The Griqua Past and the Limits of South African History, 1902–1994 (Peter Lang Publishers, 2011).) and Lorenzo Veracini (An Associate Professor in History at the Swinburne University of Technology in Melbourne, Australia. His research focuses on the comparative history of colonial systems and on settler colonialism. His publications include The Settler Colonial Present (Palgrave 2015), Settler Colonialism: A Theoretical Overview (Palgrave, 2010) and Israel and Settler Society (Pluto, 2006). Lorenzo is editor in chief of Settler Colonial Studies.), The Routledge Handbook of the History of Settler Colonialism (Abingdon: Routledge, 2017) pp.313-316] // st
Russian Settler Colonialism¶ While migration to new lands and frontiers is a dominant theme in Russian history, the existence of settler colonialism1 in Russia is fiercely contested. This chapter will argue that in the 19th century Imperial Russia developed ideologies and practices of settler colonialism which bore a clear family resemblance to those of other European states and peoples. It will concentrate primarily on migration, resettlement and colonization in Russia before the revolutions of 1917 and the establishment of the USSR. While the movement of Russians into Siberia and the other republics of the USSR continued throughout the Soviet period, this took place within a high modernist nation-building framework quite alien to earlier European colonial practice, which distinguishes it from the settler colonialism of the Tsarist period.2 ¶ In the 1920s and 30s the first generation of Bolshevik historians to write about the subject, some of whom were Kazakhs or other non-Russians, had a licence to denounce peasant colonization as one of the Tsarist regime’s many exploitative policies, publishing fierce critiques which explicitly compared Russian settlement in Asia to other instances of European colonialism.3 By the outbreak of the Second World War this could (and did) attract accusations of ‘bourgeois nationalism’.4 From the 1940s the very terms ‘colonisation’ and ‘colonial’ were deeply sensitive when applied to Russia, implying as they did parallels with the policies of Western imperialist powers who were the USSR’s ideological enemies. Soviet scholarship on the subject became largely confined to platitudes on the ‘progressive role’ played by Russian settlers in introducing the indigenous peoples of Siberia and the Steppe to advanced agricultural techniques and Bolshevism, descriptions of the exploitation of these regions by Russian capitalist entrepreneurs, and explorations of the rise of ‘class differentiation’ amongst the settlers.5¶ The narrative of growing ‘friendship’ between settlers and the indigenous populations of Central Asia and Siberia was always one of the least convincing aspects of Soviet historiography, but it has had a long afterlife in modern Russia. Even today, suggestions that Russian colonisation policies had anything in common with those of the Western Imperial powers can provoke extremely hostile reactions from Russian scholars.6 Western historians, meanwhile, were largely restricted to the use of published sources until 1991, and the cold war agenda of much Western historical writing meant that it paid little attention to agrarian resettlement in the Tsarist period.7 Twenty-five years on, we now have a small but valuable body of publications based on archival research which analyse this vital question of the history of Imperial Russia in considerable depth and detail.8 Russian settlement in Siberia, which had already all but erased many indigenous peoples and cultures even before the heyday of settler expansion in the ‘Anglo-World’ in the 19th century, has probably attracted the most attention, with the work of the late Anatoly Remnev standing out as the most important.9 Alexander Etkind has suggested that the history of Russian expansion is best understood as a process of ‘internal colonization’ of different peoples (including the Russians themselves) by a state that was equally alien and remote to all, but this interpretation does not take into account the significant differences which had emerged in the treatment of Russian and non-Russian peoples by the imperial state in the course of the 19th century – differences which can be seen most clearly when examining Russian colonization in Central Asia.10 Here Jeff Sahadeo has given us an excellent account of urban settler society in Tashkent,11 and there are a number of publications on Russian settlement on the Kazakh steppe,12 and in the rural regions of southern Central Asia (Turkestan).13 Much has also been written on colonization in Central Asia in Russian, notably an excellent monograph and collection of documents from the Kazakh historian S. N. Maltusynov.14 Unfortunately some of the other scholarship from Kazakhstan takes a narrowly nationalist view of the question, and that from Russia by and large continues to tip-toe round the more difficult and sensitive questions of inter-ethnic relations, while the idea of Russia’s osobyi put’ (‘Special path’ or Sonderweg) remains persistent.15 Nevertheless, even looking solely at English-language historiography, there is now enough published scholarship on Russian settler colonialism to allow its integration into the wider narrative of European colonial expansion and settlement.16