CAFOs must be removed to promote sustainable agriculture and improve food security
Michelle Johnson-Weider 2020 - Ms. Johnson-Weider (J.D., Stetson University College of Law) worked as an attorney in the United States Senate Office of the Legislative Counsel for thirteen years, with primary responsibility for drafting legislative proposals relating to agriculture and nutrition. She spent three years as a program analyst at the Food and Nutrition Service of the U.S. Department of Agriculture and is currently an attorney advisor in the Legislation Division of the Office of General Counsel, Department of Health and Human Services. She co-teaches a class in Legislative Analysis and Drafting at the George Washington University Law School. © 2020, Michelle Johnson-Weider. https://www.animallaw.info/sites/default/files/From%20Factory%20Farming%20to%20A%20Sustainable%20Food%20System.pdf GH-PJ
Sustainable agriculture is the future of food security. CAFOs are neither a viable nor a logical approach to achieving a safe, sustainable U.S. food supply—which is why they are already a failing model. As has been shown, cheap meat is not actually cheap when the environmental and health costs of industrialized production methods are taken into account. Moreover, industrialized agriculture like CAFOs, sometimes promoted as a job creator for depressed rural America, is actually a significant cause of the decline in the rural standard of living and quality of life. As the true costs of cheap animal-based protein are more widely understood, consumers will be less and less willing to see their tax dollars used to prop up activities that damage their rivers and lakes, poison their drinking water and air, and sicken their children. The impact of these consumer shifts should not be underestimated; changes to agricultural practices are already happening, from humane standards for egg production to increased demand for organic food and plant-based proteins. Additional changes are imminent. For instance, although milk production has been increasing, U.S. dairy consumption is down—one of the factors in the record-setting 1.4 billion-pound U.S. cheese surplus.100 Samantha Raphelson, Nobody Is Moving Our Cheese: American Surplus Reaches Record High, NAT’L PUB. RADIO (Jan. 9, 2019, 5:58 AM), https://perma.cc/JQU7-ZXGC. States are also recognizing that the damages caused by CAFOs outweigh the benefits. Oregon considered two bills to increase permitting requirements and environmental enforcement of air and water emissions from dairies with at least 2,500 cows.101 Tracy Loew, Oregon Bills Seek Nation’s Toughest Dairy Recommendations, STATESMAN J. (Dec. 12, 2018, 4:55 PM), https://perma.cc/C92D-XYLZ. The bills gained traction after a dairy farm with 30,000 cows was found to have more than 200 violations of its wastewater permit, including overflowing manure lagoons, improper application of manure to fields, and failure to report spills and leaks.102 Tracy Loew, Oregon Megadairy Lost Valley Farm Fined $187,320 for 224 Environmental Violations, STATESMAN J. (Oct. 16, 2018, 3:34 PM), https://perma.cc/J69X-TQ6Z. Of particular interest is that both bills “declare large dairies to be industrial, rather than agricultural or farming operations,” which would eliminate their ability to qualify for certain state agricultural exemptions and would subject them to local siting and health and safety requirements.103 One of the bills would also require new dairy CAFOs to post bonds “as security against environmental, health or animal welfare costs, such as costs due to manure spills, improper disposal of animals, excessive manure applications, cleaning up 100. 101. 102. 103. Loew, supra note 101. 2020] FROM FACTORY FARMING TO A SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEM 703 abandoned facilities, or relocating animals after a facility closure.”104 In another notable development, Wisconsin appears to be taking a bipartisan interest in increasing CAFO permitting fees to account for their role in the widespread contamination of drinking water in the State.105 Steven Verburg, Tony Evers, Republicans Both Looking to Get Factory Farms to Pay for Cleaner Water, WIS. STATE J. (Mar. 17, 2019), https://perma.cc/WL95-GMDG. Although these state-level efforts are notable, they do not provide a comprehensive solution to what is a national problem. As stated by the Executive Director of the Pew Commission on Industrial Farm Animal Production, “The present system of producing food animals in the United States is not sustainable and presents an unacceptable level of risk to public health and damage to the environment, as well as unnecessary harm to the animals we raise for food.”106 The FARM SAFE Act proposed in this Article would tackle the negative consequences of industrialized agriculture while providing federal support where it is needed most—to promote proven sustainable agricultural practices that protect the environment and public health and help to ensure long-term food security and safety. The FARM SAFE Act is about much more than eliminating bad practices of large agribusiness; it would commit the resources of the federal government— taxpayer funds and agency efforts—to assisting agricultural operations that grow food sustainably. Moreover, the FARM SAFE Act would provide support exclusively to small and midsized agricultural producers whose success or failure dramatically impacts their rural communities. Over time, the changes would restore contaminated watersheds, create new jobs, and revitalize rural America. Sustainable agriculture has the potential of being a true positive for U.S. agriculture. Consider, for example, the USDA organic program, which successfully created an entirely new, internationally recognized brand with ever-growing market power.107 The organic certification program was established under the Organic Foods Production Act of 1990, 7 U.S.C. §§ 6501–6522. For more information, see the USDA Organic website at https://perma. cc/39A2-DNHR. With USDA organic-certified food now featured on grocery shelves from Whole Foods to Walmart,108 Jessica Wohl, Wal-Mart Aims to Push Organic Foods into Mainstream, CHI. TRIB. (Apr. 10, 2014), https://perma.cc/M8YL-5EPH. the success of the organic program has demonstrated that agricultural producers are willing to embrace new production methods when they are compensated for them. In the case of the organic program, this compensation has come in the form of transition assistance and the ability to label and charge a premium for food produced under specific production and handling 104. Id. 105. 106. PEW COMM’N ON INDUS. FARM ANIMAL PROD., supra note 10, at viii. The report further notes that CAFOs are increasingly found worldwide, often in countries with even fewer regulations and enforcement actions than in the United States. Id. at 9. 107. 108. 704 THE GEORGETOWN ENVTL. LAW REVIEW [Vol. 32:685 standards, such as prohibitions on synthetic fertilizers and genetic engineering, as well as proactive management of soil fertility.109 E.g., NAT’L ORGANIC PROGRAM, U.S. DEP’T OF AGRIC., ORGANIC PRODUCTION AND HANDLING STANDARDS (2016), https://perma.cc/D5XY-B7UM. The federal government created the industrial agricultural complex through law and taxpayer dollars; legislative change can redirect those same assets to create a sustainable agricultural infrastructure. Instead of continuing to support a model that benefits the corporate few at the expense of society as a whole, the United States must promote agricultural practices that are proven to minimize environmental harm and public health effects while promoting good stewardship of the soil, water, animals, and other farm inputs. As the watersheds are restored and agricultural operations diversify, opportunities now lost will be reclaimed, from the return of recreation and tourism to restoring jobs whose loss has devastated the rural economy. These are not new concepts, nor is the realization that industrial agriculture is unsustainable.110 As the climate grows more unstable and already strained global resources become even more scarce, the goal of agricultural production must change from producing cheap food quickly to producing nutrient-rich food sustainably.111 Climate changes are likely to make monoculture crop production untenable—even in the near future—and will exacerbate the already dire effects of large-scale agriculture on water quality as more severe storms will mean more flooding, more fertilizer runoff, and more overflowing manure lagoons. Increasing biodiversity, as well as diversity in production methods, will be necessary to survive unexpected disruptions from weather, pests, and socioeconomic difficulties.112