Two issues with Marshall: 1---The card says that they were forced to admit that they were wrong because of backlash and anger not that they redid the study or model to determine whether they had errors – doesn’t 100% prove the study wrong 2---There is other evidence that proves that reforestation is good and possible – this ev is a year after Crowther “admitted” to being wrong – accounts for that yet it still optimistic
Robin Fearon, 12-3-2021, "Tree Planting and Reforestation Will Help Limit Global Warming," https://www.discovery.com/science/tree-planting-and-reforestation-will-help-limit-global-warming GH-PJ
Planting new trees is one of the most effective ways to reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) and limit global warming. As forests grow they remove CO2 from the air through photosynthesis, working as a natural reservoir to store . Planned projects worldwide will plant of trees and it is thought that forests will help protect the environment for future generations. An 420 million hectares (one billion acres) of forest have been lost since 1990, converted to farmland and other uses. But by planting new trees in existing forests (reforestation), and growing in areas with no previous tree cover (afforestation) nations are using nature-based solutions to tackle man-made industrial emissions. Afforestation is seen as one of the best ways to store carbon. Data by the United Nations (UN) shows that, by 2015, China had planted 79 million hectares (195 million acres) in an effort to stop farmland from turning into desert. Next was the US, which planted forest covering 26 million hectares (65 million acres), ahead of Russia with 20 million hectares (49 million acres). The US Forest Service says it uses afforestation and reforestation to forestland damaged by events like wildfire, climate change, and insect and disease damage. Benefits it lists from planting include creating new wildlife habitat, improving clean supply, stopping soil erosion, and sequestering carbon. Sadly, despite slowing in recent decades, deforestation losses worldwide still planting gains. Forest areas measuring 10 million hectares (25 million acres) were cut down and every year between 2015 and 2020. That is roughly equal to the land area of Iceland or South Korea each year. Clearing forest releases CO2 and has 23 percent of all man-made greenhouse gas emissions. One study says it has caused day temperatures in Asia, Europe, and North America. In these regions, where more than 15 percent of tree cover was removed, deforestation led to a third of the increase in average hottest day temperatures.