P3s solve space--- incentivize innovation and datasharing.
Karen Jones 04-2018 [Karen L. Jones is a senior project leader with The Aerospace Corporation’s Center for Space Policy and Strategy, The Aerospace Corporation, “Public-Private Partnerships: Stimulating Innovation in the Space Sector,” https://aerospace.org/sites/default/files/2018-06/Partnerships_Rev_5-4-18.pdf//ZW]
The space economy, once the sole domain of wealthy countries, has rapidly transitioned to a complex ecosystem of public and private entities. Along the way, government and commercial sectors have learned by doing, recognizing and incorporating key successes and lessons learned from past partnerships. Stakeholders must sort through a myriad of complexities, conflicts, and contingencies to shape an acceptable agreement. Most stakeholders recognize that this process is more art than science. Yet there is potential to achieve greater efficiency without sacrificing transparency and accountability by utilizing a decision framework supported by a broad understanding of past experiences in multiple sectors. As the space sector engages in more P3s, more lessons will emerge as partners strategize, plan, and implement. In the meantime, the following lessons, from the case studies discussed above, should continue to resonate with future P3 arrangements: • The government partner must conduct a comprehensive review of a commercial partner’s business plan including market projections, market risk, and related cost projections. These factors may impact the ability to reliably deliver on time and within budget. Avoid business models that are overly optimistic or uncertain. • Create a shared vision among stakeholders. • Establish contingencies for changing requirements. Strategically leverage seed money for private sector development and encourage healthy competition by selecting multiple partners. • Use the partnership to incentivize industry to meet the more stringent demands of the government partner. • Scale contracts to the mission’s longevity and extended success. Be wary of commitments that are longer than technology refresh or capital reinvestment cycles. • Use success to fuel incremental growth and to build longer term trusted partnerships with commercial sector partners. • Carefully structure technical and financial milestones and measure success criteria for meeting milestones, including adjusting payment schedules to reflect any slippage. • Optimize value through shared data agreements between the public and private partners – focusing on a range of intended applications and niche markets. P3s will continue to test traditional approaches to space acquisition and operations. They can demonstrate significant advantages such as improving delivery schedules, quality of service, and innovation. Capitalintensive P3s will continue to experience successes and failures as both the public and private sector become more adept at crafting optimal arrangements. The future also holds great promise for public-private datasharing models as this type of arrangement will begin to spur innovation and extract the most utility from space-derived data products.