Inclusion of private actors solves downside risks
Nadja El Fertasi 06-22-2019 [El Fertasi has built a career path in NATO over the past seventeen years taking on a variety of posts in different fields within large multinational NATO institutions. She holds a Master’s degree in International relations from the University of Cambridge and is an alumna of the NATO-wide Executive Development Program, Information and Security, “Why Digital Ecosystems of Civil-Military Partnerships Are a Game Changer for International Security and Defence,” https://procon.bg/system/files/4202_elfertasi_digital_ecosystems.pdf//ZW]
Fostering understanding, sharing best practices and lessons learned through dialogue is crucial for keeping pace with digital transformation on both sides of the Atlantic. This forum, focused on digital transformation at large in the defence sector, can help identify problems which need collaborative approaches across the civil-military spectrum. Understanding the problem first from multiple angles will create a vision all stakeholders stand behind. Establishing this dialogue to foster this shared understanding is one of the essential steps for building inclusive public-private partnerships in keeping pace with the challenges of digital disruption. NATO has excellent resources that take innovation to the next level fit for the defence sector. The NATO Industry Advisory Group 21 is the primary forum that serves as an industry advisory hub for NATO and has a transatlantic focus. Building on this forum and expanding its focus from information technology to technology at large to include all five domains of air, maritime, land, space, and cyber will reinvigorate transatlantic-public private partnerships in the digital age. Focusing on disruptive technology that is driving digital transformation in the current era is a necessity. However, the dark side of technology does not recognise civil-military boundaries; thus, involving non-traditional actors is crucial. Rethinking military doctrine and civil-military cooperation in the digital age to maintain information superiority is what will provide ultimate security. Forging partnerships within inhouse NATO expertise (e.g., Allied Command Transformation, Science and Technology Organization, NATO Communications and Information Agency) with the civil sector to include prime contractors, small and medium enterprise, startups, academia and research and development bodies will bring civil-military cooperation into the digital age. A forum for developing a shared understanding on what disruptive technology means for different member states on both sides of the Atlantic will set the scene for bridging the widening innovation gap. Anderson and Townsend argue that disruptive technologies have different meanings in the United States and Europe. 22 Add to that the innovation gap both across the Atlantic and within Europe between various member states, understanding how digital transformation impacts the different security landscapes and interests are paramount for closing this gap. A final aspect to consider is to include all institutional stakeholders from legal, finance, military officers – both users and commanders, the full spectrum of the industry from prime contractors to start-ups, and other non-traditional stakeholders. In particular seen from the recent implementation of Europe’s GDPR regulation which impacts transatlantic digital cooperation. 23 A frank and open dialogue on moving forward in ensuring Europe’s innovation culture does not fall behind in the bigger world scene is warranted. By establishing this dialogue, institutional blindness across the Alliance will diminish, and more focus on finding opportunities within existing bureaucracies will prevail.