Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US retrenchment prevents war from status competition and gives China a peaceful stake in the current order

Ward, 17 - Assistant Professor of Government at Cornell University (Steven, Status and the Challenge of Rising Powers, p. 217-218

The former approach is one that few policymakers and scholars openly promote.23 If the United States is interested in avoiding the creation of a deeply revisionist, anti-Western China, it needs to accommodate China’s status claims. Since these likely include the right to a sphere of influence in East Asia, accommodation would likely have to involve a reduction of the American military presence and American influence in that region. This does not mean conceding global leadership to China. Rather, the aim would be to acknowledge that China, as a great power, deserves the same rights that the United States does in world politics – including the right to manage East Asia and the South China Sea the way that the United States manages Latin America and the Caribbean.

This approach carries with it great risks and costs as well.What would be the effect on navigation and trade through the South China Sea? Would important American allies like Japan and South Korea turn into Beijing’s vassals? What if an American withdrawal from East Asia produces a regional arms race? And what if China grows more ambitious rather than more satisfied as the United States withdraws overseas?

But accommodation/retrenchment also has some important advantages. Foremost among them is that it avoids antagonizing Beijing: it is premised upon the idea that, all else equal, accommodation is preferable to denial because denial activates forces that empower hardliners. Accommodation holds out the possibility of empowering moderates and facilitating China’s integration within a reformed version of the liberal international order that has served its economic interests well. Another advantage is that accommodation/ retrenchment is cheaper than any approach involving containment. Retrenchment would reduce American military expenditures while simultaneously creating incentives for other regional powers to bear a greater share of their defense burdens. The United States could return to an offshore balancing posture, which would allow it to redeploy to the region only if China tried to overthrow the new version of the status quo order by, say launching a war in East Asia. But by not signaling status denial, Washington would short circuit one of the major causes of radical revisionist challenges in history, thereby reducing the likelihood that active onshore balancing would be necessary.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.